Sunday, November 16, 2008

Conservatism: The General Motors of Politics

On Friday, Senator Jim Demint of South Carolina tore into John McCain for his various apostasies from conservatism:

The conservative senator . . . described how the party had strayed from its own "brand," which . . . should represent freedom, religious-based values and limited government . . . "McCain, who is proponent of campaign finance reform that weakened party organizations and basically put George Soros in the driver's seat," DeMint said. "His proposal for amnesty for illegals. His support of global warming, cap-and-trade programs that will put another burden on our economy. And of course, his embrace of the bailout right before the election was probably the nail in our coffin this last election."


Conservatives need to ask themselves this question though. Would a more "orthodox" conservative have done better than John McCain? Line them up. Newt Gingrich, Mitt Romney, Rudy Giuliani, Mike Huckabee, Bobby Jindal--would any of them come as close as John McCain at 52-46%? What about the Tennessee Triplets of Hard-Working Fred Thompson, LAMAR! Alexander, and "Diagnosing Terry Schiavo is Easy" Bill Frist? Ex-Senators George Allen or Rick Santorum could have run. They're both effective politicians and about as orthodox as "movement conservatives" can get.

But the answer is no. Newt Gingrich has only recently been replaced by Sarah Palin as the most unpopular politician in America. Giuliani is extremely popular until people actually have contact with him. Mike Huckabee isn't any more of an orthodox conservative than McCain. Allen and Santorum were defeated in the swing states of Virginia and Pennsylvania respectively--Santorum by 19 points.

And Bobby Jindal wasn't any more ready for prime-time than Palin.

Conservativism just isn't that popular right now and conservatives would have found that out if they had nominated someone more conservative than John McCain.

William Ayers--Outlaw Pragmatist

Right-wing blogger Jeff Goldstein of Protein Wisdom is still obsessing about former Weatherman and current media sensation William Ayers.

But isn't there a kind of harmonic convergence between Goldstein and the Weathermen now that Jeff' has embraced his inner "Outlaw" and embarked on a minor (very minor!) terrorist campaign against coffee shops and recycling.

Maybe Jeff should look on Ayers as a role model.

Saturday, November 15, 2008

The Obama Model for Marriage

Cynthia Tucker of the Atlanta Constitution urges the Obamas to become a model for marriage in this country.

The Obamas are already burdened by the baggage of cultural expectations, but I’ll go ahead and add another sack to their load: Here’s hoping their presence on the national stage will erase that sixth-grader’s wrongheaded notion. Marriage is an equal-opportunity institution, no matter color, creed or sexual orientation.

“I was really excited when I saw the Obama family on the [TV] screen [on Nov. 4] because I meet so many young African-Americans who, frankly, have never seen an intact family like this,” said Leah Ward Sears, chief justice of the Georgia Supreme Court and a board member of the Institute for American Values, which promotes marriage. “I’m hopeful [the Obamas] will be a brand-new model of what the ideal is, even if many, many of us will fall short of the ideal,” she added.


As if the Obamas have a choice.

By the time US, People, Life, Redbook, O, Vanity Fair, Vogue, and Essence get done buffing up the Obama marriage, it will rank right up there with JFK and Jackie among the most famous marriages of all time.

Let's face it. Reality is reality, marketing is marketing, and women's magazines and morning network shows haven't been able to sell the Bush family as "America's Family" for years. When the media looks at the Obama family, they see "star quality," i. e., models who can deliver higher ratings, more circulation, bigger advertising rates, and more profits.

"There's gold in them there Obamas."

If the family media has their way, we'll know all about how Barack and Michelle met, the little secrets that allow them to keep their love alive, how they raise their children in the White House pressure cooker and what the girls think about boys. The President and Michell Obama will have the model marriage. The kids will be the model children and everything will be lovely in the gauzy sugar plum castles created by the art directors at the various media outlets.

By the time a profit-hungry media is done with the Obamas, the Obama marriage will be bigger than Angelina Jolie and Brad Pitt, bigger than Elizabeth Taylor and Richard Burton, bigger than Ozzie and Harriet, and bigger than King Arthur and Guinevere.

"Guinevere had green eyes, like yours my lady like yours."

Actually, the question isn't whether Barack and Michelle Obama will be role models, the question is whether they will serve as symbolic father and mother to the country. I can see Obama in that role. He's certainly preachy enough in a good, responsible kind of way. Whether the media is going to promote that is another question though.

Friday, November 14, 2008

Good for Prop 8 Boycotts

I've started to see some notices on demonstrations and boycotts for businesses that contributed to Prop 8 in California.

More than a week after the passage of Proposition 8, activists opposed to the ban on gay marriage have shifted their protests to new arenas -- using boycotts to target businesses and individuals who contributed to the winning side.

The effect of the boycotts remains unclear. Merchants said that the overall poor conomy made it difficult to tell whether their businesses were declining specifically because of the threats. But the protests have been highly visible and have drawn strong objections from backers of the initiative.

For those RSI readers unfamiliar with Prop 8, it was a ballot initiative in California to take away marriage rights of gay people that had recently been recognized by the courts. The initiative passed 52-48. At its core, Prop 8 is an ugly act of bigotry that is much like the Jim Crow system of racial segregation. Just as Jim Crow rescinded rights for African-Americans that had been established in the 13th, 14th, and 15th amendments to the Constitution, Prop 8 took away a fundamental right of marriage for gay people that had been recognized by the California Courts. Now California is once again a state where gay people are not recognized as equal citizens, not afforded equal treatment of the law, and are symbolically branded as people who must not be allowed to marry.

During the Prop 8 campaign, gay activists organized a group called Californians Against Hate to target the major donors to the "Yes on Prop 8" campaign by boycotting their businesses. After the approval of the Prop 8 discrimination against gays amendment to the California constitution, Californians Against Hate expanded their activities to demonstrating in front of Mormon temples and the car dealerships of major donors to the "Yes on Prop 8" campaign as well as boycotting the businesses of even small donors.

Good for Californians Against Hate.

As people who have been denied their fundamental rights, it's important for gay people to stand up for themselves and take the fight to those who work to deny them their rights. That's what Californians Against Hate is doing--taking the struggle for gay civil rights to the doorsteps of the people who are persecuting them.

In doing this aggressively, gay people also serve as a role model for African-American activists, Hispanic activists, feminists, and the leaders of other groups that experience pervasive mistreatment. Since the 1980's, Act Up and other gay activist organizations have done tremendous service to gay people (and all people) by being constantly provocative and getting in the faces of everybody who was waffling on gay rights. That's the main reason why gay rights activists have gained so much ground while other causes have stagnated. Californians Against Hate is another example of gay activists pushing forward and everybody else should be thinking about how to emulate them as well.

As for the feelings of the people being targeted by the boycotts and demonstrations. I care just as much for their feelings as they care for the feelings of all the gay people who want to get married but can't.

In other words, I don't care at all.
The Hillary Convergence. Concerning the Hillary for Secretary of State buzz, Josh Marshall claims that he doesn't "have an answer on why either party would want this appointment." Give me a break. The Secretary of State is going to be a central player in an Obama administration that's going to be trying to realign itself in a cooperative posture with the rest of the world. There's the full boil issues of Iraq, Afghanistan, Iran, Darfur, and North Korea and a wide range of just under the surface issues like China, India, and the global financial crisis. Hillary hasn't been that much involved with the Senate and the next four to eight years will be a great time to be a Secretary of State. Why wouldn't she want it.

More importantly, Hillary Clinton has demonstrated a lot of the kind of character that Barack Obama would want to see in a top administrative slot. As much as anything, Hillary Clinton was probably stunned by her defeat at Obama's hands during the primaries. But she swallowed her pride, did what the Obama people asked of her, and did it very well. Hillary's convention speech was by far the best speech I've ever heard her give. That shows a lot to me. I'm sure it also shows a lot to Barack Obama and has much to do with the fact that her name's out there for Secretary of State.
The Church of Opposing Abortion and Gay Marriage! Oh yeah, and what's His Name.

That seems to be the direction the Catholic Church is going these days.

Thursday, November 13, 2008

Hillary for Secretary of State? The Secretary of State job doesn't seem like a natural fit for Hillary Clinton. But there are certain pluses. Hillary would bring a high profile. She'd have clout with President Obama and her clout would keep the perpetually envious troops at the State Department happy.

Besides she'd be better than Bill Richardson.

Obama Owes It All To Liberal College Professors

Maybe some of it anyway. This is my case. What the right claims about liberal professors is true. Liberal college professors view the United States as a racist society, discuss race and racism a great deal in their classes, analyze materials on racial stereotyping, and assign a considerable amount of work by African-American writers. not named Shelby Steele.

My claim is that a couple of decades of this kind of education about race has had its effect. The white college students and graduates who took all of these classes are now more aware of the various forms of white racial hostility, more offended by racial stereotyping, and more interested in African-American ideas. As a result, whites with college experience were not only more open to Obama's candidacy than they would have been otherwise, they were also put off by all the racial innuendo that came out of the McCain camp.

Obviously, Obama was a compelling candidate whose campaign was extremely well-planned and organized. But liberal professors can be seen as helping to prepare the way for Obama's success.
Our Unpublished Book. We finally turned in the Government Program's response to the Academic Curriculum Audit at Morehead State University. The Government Program has now written over 200 pages of Audit-related material since March. That's a decent-sized book.

The Cult of Conservatism

We had our last political forum of the 2008 Presidential Election at Morehead State University last night. It was an interesting panel. In a way, it was typical academic stuff warning against irrational exuberance. All the participants--including Erik Lewis and John Hennen of Morehead State and Randall Swain of EKU-- warned against people reading too much into the election. Everyone was cautious about getting too optimistic about an Obama presidency.

Actually I disagreed. I feel an enormous amount of exuberance and I'm extremely optimistic about the upcoming Obama administration.

But the most interesting thing about the panel was John Hennen's remark that conservativism is becoming a "cult" rather than a movement. I often post about the ways that conservatives are viewing themselves as separate and apart from the nation as a whole. But I hadn't thought of conservativatism as a cult before. I'll have to think about that one some more.

It was nice to welcome Randall Swain back to Morehead to participate in the forum.

It was even nicer to get nine hours of sleep afterward.

Tuesday, November 11, 2008

What's There to Debate? Alexander Mooney of CNN writes that President Bush's "legacy is sure to be hotly debated for decades . . . " What's there to debate. Nobody debates the legacies of James Buchanan, Franklin Pierce, or Herbert Hoover, and other failed presidents. Why would they debate the legacy of George Bush?

Sunday, November 09, 2008

Bill Kristol, Puppies, and Conservatism

Bill Kristol's column on Obama's victory speech has a little sidebar about puppies and ideology that reveals his ignorance of conservatism in the age of Sarah Palin and Dick Cheney:
Obama was, naturally, asked about the promised-but-not-yet-purchased puppy at his press conference Friday. (If one were being churlish, one might say that it was typical of a liberal to promise the dog before delivering it. A results-oriented conservative would simply have shown up with the puppy without the advance hype.)
Despite his relentless efforts to promote Palin, Kristol still doesn't get it. A "results-oriented conservative" like Sarah Palin wouldn't have shown up with the puppy, she would have rode shotgun on a helicopter as she chased the desperate little puppy over miles of tundra before she shot it.

Conservatives liked the movie Bambi where Bambi's mom got shot. They like shooting puppies too.

After Palin shot the poor little thing, Dick Cheney would have started an interrogation. I won't go into the gory details, but let me just say that Cheney wouldn't have taken "woof" for an answer.

Unlike Bill Kristol and his New York Times audience, real conservatives are "Outlaws" who don't care about puppy-dog sentiment any more than they care about the environment or the Geneval Convention.

Or life in general.

If Outlaw-in-chief Jeff Goldstein of Protein Wisdom gets ahold of life, he's going to "jump it, drag it behind a dumpster, and take whatever cash or drugs it happens to have on it."

Now that's a real conservative.

It's Beginning to Look a Lot Like . . .

Now that the election is over, Christmas is already in the air. Stores have Christmas decorations out, families are nailing down their Christmas travel plans, and the RSI family is thinking about breaking out their traditional Rocking Santa dolls.

Unlike Mrs. RSI, I'm not one of the people who gets grouchy that Christmas starts before Thanksgiving and even before Halloween. If anything, I wish the Christmas season were longer. How many seasons of generosity and good will do we get to have in the United States?

But what about Thanksgiving? It looks like Thanksgiving is going to gradually slip into the netherworld of Veterans Day, Colombus Day, Flag Day, President's Day and the other holidays that everyone acknowledges but hardly anybody celebrates.

Even though the turkey is good, Thanksgiving just doesn't have enough the commercial, patriotic, or religious punch needed to stand up to the Christmas dynamo.

Anyway . . .

"It's Beginning to Look a Lot Like Christmas."

Saturday, November 08, 2008

RSI vs Protein Wisdom: The Final Triumph

I was devastated to learn today that I have been BANNED from the right-wing blog Protein Wisdom. Last year, I defeated Protein Wisdom blogger Jeff Goldstein in a debate on race. Poor Goldstein. He got completely sidetracked by my sophisticated pose as a college professor. It threw him entirely off his game. That and the fact that he's not nearly as talented as his many pronouncements indicate.

But this is the ultimate triumph--having such an big impact that I'm banned from Goldstein's blog. Maybe he can send me a plaque to honor the occasion. I'm at Ric Caric/ Department of Geography, Government, & History/Morehead State University, Morehead, KY 40351.

All kidding aside, maybe it's for the best. Goldstein is a high strung, insecure guy who's pretty unhappy with the way things have worked out so far in his life. I wouldn't want my teasing comments on Protein Wisdom to be the thing that drove Goldstein off his nut. I wouldn't be able to forgive myself if I were the guy who triggered Goldstein into blowing away the Obama supporters at his local coffee shop.

You know, he's an "Outlaw" now .

Peace, Jeff--it'll work out in the end.

A Little Self-Delusion on the Right

Conservative commentator Michael Barone isn't impressed by Obama's win and doesn't think that people on the left were particularly overwhelmed either.
How to defeat terrorist enemies sheltered in the territory of our putative ally Pakistan. How to live up to the high expectations so visible in the cheering and tearful faces in those crowds in Berlin, Invesco Field and Grant Park -- after a victory that was thrilling, but not quite what the Democrats hoped for.
Needless to say, Barone doesn't know what he's talking about because he doesn't talk much with "real-time" Democrats. But I do and there was pretty much a consensus around a six-point win by the time the final voting began on Tuesday. Poll analyst Nate Silver of FiveThirtyEight.com is particularly among the left because he's so accurate and because he was a popular DailyKos diarist. Silver's model predicted the six point win that Obama got. So did RSI and one of RSI's colleagues at Morehead State University.

Barone seems to think that Democrats were expecting a huge landslide. But the fact was that "hope" for victory only solidified into "expectation" of victory on the day before the election. Active Democrats were expecting one last slime attack on Obama, still wondered if whites were that solid on an African-American president, and were still haunted by the 2000 and 2004 campaigns. So, it wasn't exactly as if confidence was high the weekend before the election.

But the polls on Monday, Nov. 3 showed an uptick for Obama and everybody started to become more confident. Friends started telling RSI they were no expecting Obama to win while RSI himself started telling students and colleagues that he expected the election to be decided in Obama's favor by 10pm or 11.

When the expectations actually started panning out, Atrios summed up a lot of feelings by blogging "holy shit" several times. People were stunned that they had been right about the election, stunned that Obama had run such a near-perfect campaign, and stunned that it had all worked out so well.

Democrats expected Obama to win, but the election was much more than they had allowed themselves to hope for. A lot of people cried to see it. Magic Johnson cried all night long. Mrs. RSI cried throughout Obama's terrific victory speech.

Obama's six point win was not exactly what conservatives like Barone feared, but it was exactly what Democrats were hoping for.

Friday, November 07, 2008

Socialism from Ronald Reagan to Barack Obama

Conservatives can't make up their mind whether Barack Obama is going to be a "center-right" president or a socialist. Establishment Republicans like Karl Rove and David Brooks say "center-right." Wack job Michael Reagan says socialism.

Who to believe?

The Obama administration will probably propose these items:
1. an economic stimulus package focused on building infrastructure and creating new jobs;
2 a national health insurance system;
3. a new system of regulations for the financial system;
4. beefed up environmental and consumer legislation.

I'll eat my copy of Adam Smith's Wealth of Nations if that's a "center-right agenda." The socialism question is a little more tricky. It depends on what you're talking about when you use the terms capitalism and socialism. If we're talking about "actually existing capitalism" (to use a Marxist term), then Obama and the Dems are just as committed to preserving capitalism as the Bush administration. The Bush administration was so committed to preserving actually existing capitalism from depression that they went against their own principles and at least partially took over investment companies, insurance companies, and banking system. Those can be called "socialist" measures because they involve government taking control over sections of private business. But it's socialism in defense of capitalism.

An Obama administration would do the same.

But Michael Reagan sees capitalism in terms of an ideal laissez faire economic system with no government interference outside enforcing laws against theft and fraud. From this kind of pie in the sky perspective, "socialism" is any kind of government involvement in the economic system and the U. S. has become more and more of a socialist country since the Teddy Roosevelt administration.

From this perspective, the Obama administration would be a socialist government if they did so little as raise the taxes of the wealthy by 3%.

If this is socialism, so be it. Capitalism served as a prop for feudalism for centuries before free markets became dominant. Who's to say that socialism can't serve as a prop for capitalism until there isn't very much capitalism to prop up any more.

Here's to socialism in defense of capitalism--the best of both systems.

At least for now.

Protein Wisdom Does Dillinger

Protein Wisdom has become the blog home for right-wing bitterness over Obama's election as president. Here's Jeff Goldstein doing a full Dillinger in protest (quoted in full).

Another moment of unabashed OUTLAW pragmatism
Sure, I know I’m supposed to break down cardboard boxes before I put them in the recycle bin. But fuck it, I took a chance.

And if the truck decides it doesn’t want to pick ‘em up as is, those boxes can sit there in the street until they become moldy or weather shredded — or home to a family of angry bobcats, for all I care.

It ain’t like my name’s on the things.

What a rebel!

Thursday, November 06, 2008

The Offer to Lieberman

Harry Reid has given Joe Lieberman an offer that he shouldn't refuse but probably will. Reid seems to have told Lieberman that he wants to strip the Connecticut senator of his seat as chair of the Homeland Security Committee and give him a sub-committee to chair instead.

That's fairly generous.

Lieberman campaigned enthusiastically for John McCain, vociferously complains about being abandoned by the Democratic Party, and talks all the time about switching to the Republicans. As a result, there's a good argument for booting Lieberman out of the Democratic Senate caucus altogether.

Instead, Reid is indicating that Lieberman can no longer have a prominent function as a member of the Democratic caucus without going out of his way to be punitive.

That seems about right.

Committee chairmanships are determined by party in the U. S. Senate and Joe Lieberman is far from being a Democrat in good standing. He can't be chair of something as important as the Homeland Security Committee.

But Lieberman can be chair of something and Senate sub-committees still do a lot of important work.

But Lieberman probably won't accept. He's been bitter about the Democratic Party ever since he got nowhere with his 2004 presidential run. McCain's loss just increases the bitterness.

Maybe Reid and Lieberman will work out some sort of deal, but it's likely that Lieberman will bolt to the Republicans before the Senate starts its new session in January.

I can't say I'll miss him.

The Republicans: a White People's Party

My crude math indicates that 96% of the Republican vote came from whites. That makes the Republicans a white people's party. That's not the same as being THE white people's party. Making up almost 75% of the population, whites were also 64% of Obama's vote. But Obama's support came from a multi-racial, multi-ethnic coalition. McCain relied almost entirely on the white vote.

Wednesday, November 05, 2008

Sympathy for Conservatives

I have to admit that I feel a little sorry for conservatives right now. CNN has a report about conservative bloggers and pundits meeting soon to figure out a way forward.

On Thursday, a group of prominent conservatives, including political and media strategists, will meet in Virginia to discuss just that. Media reports suggest a group of 20 people will talk about what the party needs to do in a Democrat-dominated government and what must be done in order to avoid a third cycle of defeats for Republicans in the next midterm elections.
I wish them well, but I think it's going to take awhile for the enormity of the Republican and conservative defeat to sink in. Setting a new direction will be a whole different issue.

Personally, I can't think of any element of conservatism that does not stand repudiated. Here's a few examples.

Small Government Conservatism--There can be no doubt that small government conservatism stands repudiated. There's three bottom lines here. The American public wants more government not less. The American public wanted government to resolve the financial meltdown and the American public wants more government regulation of the financial sector rather than less.

Market Approaches to government programs. Privatizing social security and medical accounts approaches to health care have been rejected as well. McCain's "market approach" to health insurance is one of the reasons why he lost and he would have lost by a lot more if he had really pushed social security privatizaation.

Religious and social conservatives. Add Sarah Palin to the long list of things that the public rejects about religious conservatism that includes the Terry Schiavo case, the attack on evolutionary theory, opposition to stem cell research, and opposition to the morning after pill and contraception. But the ultimate repudiation of social and religious conservativism is still on the horizon. Gay rights lost in California yesterday, but it's pretty obvious that gay marriage is going to eventually be legal all over the country.

Neo-conservative foreign policy. Even with the relative success of the surge, the American public still broadly rejects the Iraq War and wants American troops out of Iraq. And it isn't just that the public has repudiated the Bush administration's conduct of the war. The public has long concluded that the invasion itself was wrong.

Maybe I'm missing important dimensions of conservatism, but those are the four pillars of conservatism as I know them.

But the situation is actually worse.

The American public is also beginning to reject some of the secondary elements of conservatism. Let me just name a few.

1. Their instinctive belligerence.
2. The use of racial stereotyping and innuendo in conservative political campaigns.
3. The hostility of conservative constituencies to African-Americans, Hispanics, gay people, and other minorities.

In my opinion, the rejection of conservativism by the American public is so thorough and so energetic that what conservatives really need to do is rethink their sense in which they're American.

The rest of the country is moving away from conservatives so fast that they really need to grapple with their sense of how they're connected to the rest of American society. To the right, conservatives are the only "real" Americans.

Henry Louis Gates on Obama's Victory

One of the black people who came out of hiding was Henry Louis Gates, a prominent African-American literary scholar and public figure at Harvard University.

Gates has a post on The Root from which I'm drawing this excerpt. I might have some commentary at some point but for now I'll just reprint this inspired piece of writing:
How many of our ancestors have given their lives—how many millions of slaves toiled in the fields in endlessly thankless and mindless labor—before this generation could live to see a black person become president? "How long, Lord?" the spiritual goes; "not long!" is the resounding response. What would Frederick Douglass and W.E.B. Du Bois say if they could know what our people had at long last achieved? What ould Sojourner Truth and Harriet Tubman say? What would Dr. King himself say? Would they say that all those lost hours of brutalizing toil and labor leading to spent, half-fulfilled lives, all those humiliations that our ancestors had to suffer through each and every day, all those slights and rebuffs and recriminations, all those rapes and murders, lynchings and assassinations, all those Jim Crow laws and protest marches, those snarling dogs and bone-breaking water hoses, all of those beatings and all of those killings, all of those black collective dreams deferred—that the unbearable pain of all of those tragedies had, in the end, been assuaged at least somewhat through Barack Obama's election? This certainly doesn't wipe that bloody slate clean. His victory is not redemption for all of this suffering; rather, it is the symbolic culmination of the black freedom struggle, the grand achievement of a great, collective dream. Would they say that surviving these horrors, hope against hope, was the price we had to pay to become truly free, to live to see—exactly 389 years after the first African slaves landed on these shores—that "great gettin' up morning" in 2008 when a black man—Barack Hussein Obama—was elected the first African-American president of the United States?

I think they would, resoundingly and with one voice proclaim, "Yes! Yes! And yes, again!" I believe they would tell us that it had been worth the price that we, collectively, have had to pay—the price of President-elect Obama's ticket.

Black People Emerge From Hiding

I remember a writer from an African-American blog saying in June that black people needed to shut up until the election was over.

Come to think of it, black people pretty much did go into hiding during the general election campaign.

But now that Obama's won, African-Americans are coming out of the racial closet and are pretty damn happy about it.

Good for them. Good for us. Good for all of us.

Crude Reaction II--O-BA-MA

Tuesday, November 04, 2008

The Almost Final Electoral College Look

It looks like Obama might take North Carolina, Indiana, and Missouri. He's ahead in North Carolina and Indiana and only behind by one point in Missouri. If memory serves me right, the last area to report in Missouri is St. Louis where Obama could be expected to rack big majorities.
If Obama wins all four states, he would have 365 electoral votes to 156 for McCain.

Some notes:

1. No Social Conservatism here. If Obama wins Montana, that will be the only big surprise for a state win. But Obama's margins in Pennsylvania, New Hampshire, and New Mexico exceeded expectations. Pennsylvania is a special case with an 11 point Obama win. Obama rolled up more than a 450,000 vote margin in Philadelphia while also winning all of the inner ring of suburban Bucks, Chester, and Montgomery counties and most all of the second ring as well.

One has to wonder if McCain and Palin spending all that time in rural Pennsylvania actually hurt them by stimulating opposition in the metro areas.

2. Down to their last safe state. The Republicans only have one safe haven and one tossup on the Atlantic seaboard, with Georgia as the toss-up and South Carolina as the lonely Republican haven. The Republicans are in danger of becoming slipping from a regional party to a subregional party of part of the Old South, the Great Plains, and the more isolated Mountain States.

3. The Next Ultimate Journey. The Holy Grail of the Democratic Party used to be Florida. With Florida at least temporarily conquered, the target for Democratic aspirations will shift to Texas. The Republicans need to rethink.

Crude Emotional Reaction

Holy Shit! I saw it in the numbers. The electoral vote total is going to be in my range. But I couldn't believe Obama would win until Obama actually won. And I still don't believe it.

It's Obama, It's Early, Time to Celebrate

Live--Blogging 3, It's Over

CNN is projecting Obama as winning Ohio.

Now, Rudy Giuliani is on Fox saying "it ain't over till it's over."'

But it's over.

Live-Blogging--No. 2

CNN calls Senate races for Jeanne Shaheen in New Hampshire and Tom Udall in New Mexico. It's been called for Susan Collins from Maine as well. I was a year behind Collins at St. Lawrence during the early 70's.

Wolf Blitzer is back on the air and Obama has clinched 174 electoral votes to 49 for McCain.

But William Schneider is reminding me of why I don't miss television.

He's asking a question about the impact of race on the election but what he's saying would be a lot more significant if he had broken down "racial attitudes" by race.

The students sitting next to me start having a conversation about race. The consensus is that electing Obama will bring an early surge of white racism but that it would peter out.

Live-Blogging Election Night

I'm back on the Morehead State Campus where one of my colleagues has set up a multi-screen set-up for Election Watch.

Very Cool!

My first stop was at the campaign headquarters of my brother-in-law Tom Carew who was running for a city council seat in Morehead. Tom Carew is a very responsible and well-respected citizen in Eastern Kentucky. He won easily.

Bringing myself up to date:

Rocky Mountain High, Pennsylvania. Among the contested states, Obama has been declared the winner in Pennsylvania and New Hampshire. With Obama winning in Pennsylvania, things get tough for McCain and that's why the crowd in Grants Park in Chicago is so loud. If McCain wants to win, he is going to have to get Colorado as well as all the toss-up states in order to win.

Personally, I don't see that.

If the rest of the election goes to form, Obama has already won.

Now we need to see if the rest of the election goes to form.

Notes on a Potentially Breaking Wave

Some final thoughts as I wait for voting results to come in:

The Pennsylvania Tease. Pennsylvania has become somewhat of a holy grail for Republican presidential candidates. McCain put a lot of time and resources into Pennsylvania and there's been a lot of commentary about how desperately he needed the Keystone State after losing Iowa, Colorado, and New Mexico. But Bush also put considerable energy into Pennsylvania. The Republicans are constantly tempted by the Republican "T" that surrounds Philly and Pittsburgh with put a lot of conservatives and evangelicals. They'd also like to keep some beachhead in a Northeast that seems to be falling permanently out of their grasp. But the problem for the Republicans is that their social conservatism kills them in the Philly suburbs and Sarah Palin is a constant reminder of the GOP's social conservatism. Bush lost Pennsylvania by four in 2000 and two in 2004. McCain might fall even father behind this time.

Repudiating Rove? This election initially looked like a repudiation of Karl Rove's strategy of maximizing the party base and ignoring independents. But it didn't work out that way as neither candidate made the classic move from "primary partisanship" to "general election moderation" designed to appeal to moderate voters. The dynamic factor here was McCain. He never let up in his efforts to mobilize the Republican Party's conservative base and even brought out Dick Cheney as his campaign closer. But even more importantly, McCain moved Obama away from moderation by mocking him as an empty celebrity. By the time the conventions got started, Obama was just as much a partisan Democrat as Teddy Kennedy or Bill Clinton. If Obama wins as expected, it will be a result of the appeal of the progressive partisanship rather than the "One America" rhetoric he started with in 2007.

No Longer A Center-Right Nation? Charles Krauthammer, Newsweek, and just about anybody doesn't have a DailyKos diary is now reminding Barack Obama that the United States is a "center-right country" that doesn't like the "liberal agenda." Here's Krauthammer:
McCain is the quintessential center-right candidate. Yet the quintessential center-right country is poised to reject him. The hunger for anti-Republican catharsis and the blinding promise of Obamian hope are simply too strong. The reckoning comes in the morning.

But Krauthammer might have a surprise coming. It's not just the Bush administration and the Republican Party that's being repudiated. The American public might be pushing the reject button on social and religious conservatism, hyper-aggressive neo-conservative foreign policy, anti-immigrant sentiment, and the heightened concentration of wealth. The broader public is getting fed up with talk radio and Fox as well. Rush Limbaugh is smart enough to know that moderates hate him, but the conservative establishment have yet to catch up with the fact that the American public is rejecting the conservative movement as well as the Republican Party. My own perception breaks down by race. The broader white public is ready to support progressive policies if it looks like they're going to work. Everybody else is willing to live with Obama's mistakes.

Wimpy Conspiracies

The "fluff right" blog Protein Wisdom is pushing the "William Ayers wrote Obama's book" sham. What a wimpy little conspiracy theory! Back when the right-wing had guts, they accused Bill Clinton of murdering half the population of Arkansas.

TODAY'S THE DAY--VOTE FOR OBAMA

I'm so excited about today I couldn't sleep past 6:30am even though I have today off. It's still Obama by 6-8 points. Yesterday was a big plus day for Obama in the polls. Everything looks good.

Monday, November 03, 2008

Vote Suppression as a Civil Rights Crime

If the polling bears out and Barack Obama is elected president tomorrow, he's going to have to deal with a large number of "legacy issues," including the two wars in Afghanistan and Iraq, the financial meltdown, Guantanamo, the military tribunals, the extraordinary rendition program, health care reform, and climate change.

One legacy issue that hasn't caught the media's attention is "vote suppression"--the efforts of Republican officials to intimidate grass-roots vote registration efforts, develop schemes to lower voting rates among poor people, and scare people in minority communities away from voting.

It should be illegal.

Voting is a fundamental right in American society--as much a cornerstone of democracy as the right to freedom of speech, freedom of religion, and freedom of assembly.

At its root, vote suppression is the attempt to intimidate, coerce, or otherwise prevent American citizens from exercising that fundamental right.

As a result, all forms of vote suppression should be outlawed.

It should be a felony to engage in any behavior designed to intimidate, coerce, or otherwise prevent eligible voters from exercising their right to vote. That includes seeking to scare people away from voting, engaging in registration purges with the intent of eliminating eligible (as well as ineligible voters), or excluding people who have moved recently, lost their homes, or are homeless from voting. It should also include the various efforts by election officials to limit participation.

Vote suppression has become "politics as usual" for the Republican Party. Thus, it could be argued that making vote suppression illegal would be a form of "criminalizing politics."

So be it.

Republican vote suppression is an attempt to prevent people from exercising their fundamental rights as Americans.

It should be a crime.

I Sure Hope Rove is Right!


Who would have thought I would agree with a moral cesspool like Karl Rove. But Rove's final election map is pretty much what the 52-46 I expect for Obama victory is going to look like. The only difference is that I would have left Indiana and Missouri as toss-ups. But that's splitting hairs and there's something to be said for choosing anyway.

Some final thoughts as I wait for voting results to come in:

The Pennsylvania Tease. Pennsylvania has become somewhat of a holy grail for Republican presidential candidates. McCain put a lot of time and resources into Pennsylvania and there's been a lot of commentary about how desperately he needed the Keystone State after losing Iowa, Colorado, and New Mexico. But Bush also put considerable energy into Pennsylvania. The Republicans are constantly tempted by the Republican "T" that surrounds Philly and Pittsburgh with put a lot of conservatives and evangelicals. They'd also like to keep some beachhead in a Northeast that seems to be falling permanently out of their grasp. But the problem for the Republicans is that their social conservatism kills them in the Philly suburbs and Sarah Palin is a
constant reminder of the GOP's social conservatism. Bush lost Pennsylvania by four in 2000 and two in 2004. McCain might fall even father behind this time.

Repudiating Rove? This election initially looked like a repudiation of Karl Rove's strategy of maximizing the party base and ignoring independents. But it didn't work out that way as neither candidate made the classic move from "primary partisanship" to "general election moderation" designed to appeal to moderate voters. The dynamic factor here was McCain. He never let up in his efforts to mobilize the party base and even brought out Dick Cheney as his campaign closer. Even more importantly, McCain moved Obama away from moderation by mocking him as an empty celebrity. By the time the conventions got started, Obama was just as much a partisan Democrat as Teddy Kennedy or Bill Clinton. If Obama wins as expected, it will be a result of the appeal of the progressive partisanship rather than the "One America" rhetoric he started with in 2007.

No Longer A Center-Right Nation? Charles Krauthammer, Newsweek, and just about anybody doesn't have a DailyKos diary is now reminding Barack Obama that the United States is a "center-right country" that doesn't like the "liberal agenda."

Here's Krauthammer:
McCain is the quintessential center-right candidate. Yet the quintessential center-right country is poised to reject him. The hunger for anti-Republican catharsis and the blinding promise of Obamian hope are simply too strong. The reckoning comes in the morning.

But Krauthammer might have a surprise coming. It's not just the Bush administration and the Republican Party that's being repudiated. The American public might be pushing the reject button on social and religious conservatism, hyper-aggressive neo-conservative foreign policy, anti-immigrant sentiment, and the heightened concentration of wealth. The broader public is getting fed up with talk radio and Fox as well. Rush Limbaugh is smart enough to know that moderates hate him, but the conservative establishment have yet to catch up with the fact that the American public is rejecting the conservative movement as well as the Republican Party.

My own perception is that the broader white public is ready to support progressive policies if it looks like they're going to work. Everybody else is willing to live with their mistakes.

The First Four Polls of the Day

Twenty-four hours to go. TWENTY-FOUR HOURS TO GO!! This morning's first four polls were good for Obama. Gallup had him up by 11, NBC by 8, Zogby by 7, and Research 2000 by 6.

There's a little bit of worry in the Research 2000 tracking poll which has only had Obama up by 4 for the last two nights. That's within the margin of error.

But I've still made my last campaign contribution.

The Cutest Thing Around

Mrs. RSI turned 53 yesterday. Still just the cutest thing I know.

MoveOn.Org SCANDAL!

Yes, that's right. SCANDAL. When Mrs. RSI woke up this morning, she had a message from MoveOn.org in her mailbox asking her if she was "NERVOUS" and to contribute $25 if she was. Of course, she's nervous! Who wouldn't be nervous if they were faced with the prospect of John McCain becoming President of the United States after this campaign? But using that nervousness as a fund-raising gimmick is shear EXPLOITATION and MoveOn.org should be ashamed.

Fortunately, Mrs. RSI resisted the urge the send more of her hard-earned pension to those blood-suckers.

Update: Oh, I forgot to mention that RSI sent $25 in last-minute cash to the Obama campaign. It seems they needed more money.

Sunday, November 02, 2008

RSI Waffles: Now It's Obama by 6


It turns out that RSI is a nervous, insecure kind of person after all. Who would have known? On Oct. 24, I thought Obama would win by either 6 or 8 points and came down on the side of 8. After a week of waffling, I still see Obama as winning by 6-8 points but now come down on the side of 6.
Now it's Obama--52, McCain--46 and give me my nerve pills.
That's how the Pew polling organization views it as well. Of course, Pew had Obama by 15 in their previous poll. So, they might not be the most reliable people in the world this time around.

Nate Silver's statistical model at FiveThirtyEight.com has gradually come down from Obama by 8 to Obama by 5.4.

The above map from Electoral-vote.com pretty much captures what I see with Obama winning at 52-46. Among the currently contested states, Obama captures Pennsylvania, Ohio, Florida, and Virginia while McCain wins Arizona, Montana, and North Dakota. The only difference is that I believe McCain would also win North Carolina and that Indiana and Missouri would still be toss-ups.

That would put the electoral college at Obama--338, McCain--178 and toss-ups--22. That's a big Obama win and gives him a pretty decent mandate given that the Democrats are going to increase their majorities in the House and Senate.

If Obama wins by eight points, then he would also add Indiana, Missouri, North Carolina, and Arizona which would make it 375-163.

Stay tuned for more waffling.

Saturday, November 01, 2008

Deep Paranoia: Who Will Be the First to Call for a Coup?

Spokespeople on the right have achieved new levels of intensity in their expressions of contempt for Barack Obama. In a column today, Thomas Sowell characterizes Obama's only qualifications as being "ego and mouth."

But who will be the first to call for a coup to prevent Obama taking office?

My guess is that it will be one of the defense neo-cons like Frank Gaffney. But there are others like political philosopher Harvey Mansfield as well.

The Electoral Map: A Quadrant Analysis


This is Karl Rove's electoral map from Wednesday, Oct. 29. It has Obama with 311 electoral votes and leading in states with another 56 electoral votes. That would be 367 electoral votes if Wednesday's trends held. Rove views McCain as having 157 electoral votes and leading in Montana with another 3 for 160 if trends hold.

It's hard to tell what the trends are going to be. Obama is up by 5 today in Rasmussen and 10 in Gallup. Given that Obama's been gaining in Gallup, it may be that the map will look even better for Obama on Tuesday. In particular, Arizona and Georgia might be joining the ranks of the toss-ups by then.

And this brings me to my point. Even if Obama should lose, this map looks very promising for the Democratic Party and I think it looks promising for the future of the country as well. It looks like the Republican Party is going to have to leave the 19th century if it wants to be competitive in presidential elections. And that would be very good for the whole country.

For the purpose of this analysis, I'd like to divide the country into quadrants. The east/west line is easy because it would run from North Dakota's eastern boundary to the Texas/Louisiana line. The North north/south line is less regular but it would begin at Pennsylvania's southern border, bisect Ohio, Indiana, and Illinois, and continue through the northern borders of Missouri, Kansas, and Colorado through to the Pacific.

The Northeast and Midwest are blue. Obama's domination of the northeastern quadrant bounded by New Jersey, Maine, Minnesota, and Missouri is striking. Famously traditional Republican states like Maine, Vermont, and New Hampshire are solidly blue. Obama's also ahead in Ohio while Indiana has become a complete toss-up. The only two states where McCain is clearly ahead are Kentucky and West Virginia.

A blue region is also coalescing in the Southeastern quadrant of former Confederate states. The inroads that the Obama campaign is making in the formerly Solid Republican South are almost as striking as Obama's northern domination. Maryland is a solid blue state because it's becoming more northeastern in character. But the key is that Obama has leads in Virginia, North Carolina and Florida while he's making inroads into Georgia (which most maps have as a "lean McCain" rather than a solid McCain). Virginia and North Carolina are more heavily influenced by Northeastern style population patterns in the DC suburbs and Research Triangle while Georgia and Florida have burgeoning metro areas that trend Democratic. The ultimate prospect is that the Old Confederacy could split into an "Atlantic South" that is Democratic and a Traditional Gulf/Mississippi/Appalachian South of Alabama, Mississippi, Louisiana, Arkansas, Tennessee, and South Carolina.

If that happened, the Civil War would be almost over.

It's also useful to view the Southwest as a single quadrant although Texas has many Southern characteristics and California is more Pacific than Southwestern. But the Democrats are gaining steadily in the western part of the quadrant other than Utah and only leaving the Texas, Oklahoma, and Kansas corridor to the GOP.

In this sense, Texas becomes the popular anchor point for the national Republican Party even though demographic trends are leading toward larger Democratic constituencies of hispanics and urban dwellers.

In other words, it's a relatively weak anchor.

The northwestern quadrant looks even weaker for the Republicans as Montana and North Dakota become swing states and the Republicans are left with isolated Wyoming, Idaho, and Alaska as well as the Plains states of Nebraska and South Dakota.

In this view, the Republicans would just have to change if they wanted to remain competetive in national elections. They would have to make a real appeal to the metro areas and retreat on social conservativism, hostility to science, and military belligerence.

Otherwise, the Republicans would face a real prospect of being outstripped by some sort of moderate, technocratic third party . . . and dying.

And its' not that far off. Michael Bloomberg already wants to be the presidential candidate of that party.

The Brave Geese of Kentucky

Every morning for the last six weeks, we've seen a couple flocks of geese flying north through Morehead. I'm not sure what's going on but there's a certain way in which you have to admire the brave geese of Kentucky as they fly up into the colder weather.

Friday, October 31, 2008

Sarah Palin's First Amendment

Sarah Palin was on a right-wing news outlet today complaining that she was losing her First Amendment Rights. The crux of her complaint is that the mainstream media is referring to all of her accusations concerning Barack Obama and William Ayres as negative campaigning and convincing people that Palin is campaigning inappropriately.

"If [the media] convince enough voters that that is negative campaigning, for me to call Barack Obama out on his associations," Palin told host Chris Plante, "then I don't know what the future of our country would be in terms of First Amendment rights and our ability to ask questions without fear of attacks by the mainstream media."
The poor dear.

For Palin, the First Amendment means that she should be free to speak but that it should be unconstitutional for others to try to convince people that she's wrong or acting inappropriately. She should be able to speak but others should not be free to disagree with her in any kind of effective manner.

There's a substantive truth underlying Palin's argument. McCain, Palin, and the GOP media are de-emphasizing their own policy positions and proposals as they rely more very heavily on their accusations concerning Obama and Jeremiah Wright, William Ayres, Rashid Khalidi, socialism, and terrorism. If the Republicans are going to get hammered for negative campaigning every time they make these accusations, there's a sense in which they might as well not have a right to speak at all.

Why speak if what you say is not going to have an audience?

There's another problem as well. There's a certain way in which a person can not have free speech in the fullest sense of the word unless there is an audience to consider their views. In On Liberty, John Stuart Mill worried considerably about the kind of "social censorship" in which the harsh moral judgments of mass audiences either discourage people from speaking. Mill viewed the social censorship of the 19th century United States as doing more to suppress speech than the kind of government censorship that was associated with absolute monarchy. The main punishment of social censorship was the moral ostracism of speakers from social circles or a generalized "respectability." Ostracism is a punishment in two distinct ways. It punishes through the pain and humiliation of being excluded and also punished through the separation of the speaker from any audience willing to consider her speech.

From Sarah Palin's point of view, media characterizations of her references to William Ayres as negative campaigning serve as a social censorship that deprives her of her First Amendment Rights. Indeed, there is a sense in which she is being censored in that she is being ostracized out of the political community and therefore kept morally apart from the audience which she is trying to convince. Obviously, Palin's references to the First Amendment are misplaced because the First Amendment addresses government censorship rather than the social censorship she is experiencing as a vice-presidential candidate.

But the effect is powerful all the same.

Ultimately however, Sarah Palin has no complaint. What she is attempting to do to Obama is the same thing she accuses the media of doing to her. In repeating the insinuations about William Ayres, referring to Obama as a socialist, etc., Palin is calling Obama's status as a member in good standing in the American moral community with the implication that no one should take Obama's policy proposals seriously because Obama is not "really one of us."

In this sense, the McCain and Obama campaigns have been engaged in a game in which each side appeals to the larger American community to decide which campaign is outside the moral consensus and should therefore be socially censored. The McCain/Palin campaign is losing the moral war in the mainstream media and is suffering some social censorship effects as a result. But Palin has no basis for complaining about a condition that she would have been glad to impose on the Obama campaign.

Wednesday, October 29, 2008

The Student Debate

Tonight I watched a student debate between the campus Republicans and Democrats. I could tell that the student debaters did a significant amount of research. But they also struggled to connect their facts to the main themes of the Obama and McCain campaigns. The students were smart but the fact that they struggled is an excellent reminder of just how talented people Barack Obama, John McCain, Hillary Clinton, and Joe Biden are.

Testing: The IM Advantage

We learned today that Miss Teen RSI got a lot higher scores on last year's round of standardized testing. I guess those hundreds of hours she spent doing instant messaging with her friends paid off.

Socialism in America: The Republicans Move the Ball Forward Again

As the presidential campaign stumbles to a close, the Republicans have made "socialism" into the bright shiny new word that symbolizes their fears about Barack Obama and the Democrats.

But all of this talk about socialism can have the secondary effect of encouraging discussion of formerly taboo proposals like nationalizing health care. All the scare talk about socialism might make socialism less scary and start encouraging practical talk about socialist ideas.
Is that what the Republicans really want?

After all, the government could even nationalize the leading banks.

Wait a minute!

The Bush administration has already nationalized the banks. They've also nationalized the biggest insurance company (AIG) and are now providing guarantees for 80-85% of housing loans through government control of Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac.

In other words, the Republicans are not just talking about socialism, they're doing socialism.

One of the most important writings in American socialism is Edward Bellamy's Looking Backward. If the U. S. becomes a socialist country one day, people may be amused to "look backward" at the irony of the Republicans doing so much to move the cause of socialism forward in 2008.

Monday, October 27, 2008

Big Audit Day Today

I've been doing major work on the government faculty's response to the audit this weekend.

9:00am--Meeting with other GGH faculty

4:00pm--Meeting with Provost

In the meantime, I'm going to be looking at materials concerning the Business College and MPA programs.

In Political News

An ABC/Wash Post poll has Obama up by 8 in Virginia.

Sunday, October 26, 2008

A Thought on Conservatism

The standard line:
If Obama wins big and the Democrats sweep in Congress, this election will be a repudiation of the Republican Party.

What I'm beginning to think:
If Obama wins big and the Democrats sweep in Congress, this election will be a repudiation of the Republican Party, conservative ideology, and conservatives as people.

Saturday, October 25, 2008

Praying for Palin in 2012

I'm thinking of converting to a religion because I want to pray to some divinity for the Republicans to nominate Sarah Palin for the presidency in 2012.

But it's hard.

Do I convert to a religion like Christianity, Islam, or Judaism and pray to one all-powerful divinity?

That seems sort of dicey. What if there are lots of gods and praying to one offends all the others? What if none of these accounts of the one god are the one true account? How do you tell which account of the one god is true and which account is false?

Sheesh, investing in monotheism seems even more tricky than investing in the stock market.

In some ways, praying to lots of Gods seems to be the safest bet but polytheism is generally associated with animal sacrifice. But my dog is barking in protest even as I write. Good dog! Good dog!

Hey! I know how I'll solve the problem. I'll follow the example of the McCain campaign and just make up a lot of stuff about the God I want to pray to.

Anyway, I'm praying for Palin.

Friday, October 24, 2008

The Hoax in Political Context

On Thursday as the Ashlie Todd Hoax story was breaking, John Moody, the over-caffeinated vice-president of Fox News, wrote the following:
If the incident turns out to be a hoax, Senator McCain’s quest for the presidency is over, forever linked to race-baiting.
That's far from being the case. McCain's not dead yet and events could shake up an election that can appear set in concrete. Likewise, there are decent polls like GWU/Battleground which have Obama ahead but also have McCain leads within their margin of error.

But the Ashlie Todd Hoax story does get at a fundamental problem of constant bad news that is dogging McCain.

With Obama off the campaign trail while visiting his sick grandmother in Hawaii, McCain could use the breathing space to focus attention on his message.

But there's been a steady stream of minor distractions that have kept that from happening.

First, it was Sarah Palin and her $150,000 wardrobe

Then, brother Joe McCain made an idiot of himself by calling 911 over stalled traffic.

And finally the Ashlie Todd story.

The report on Todd being mugged and disfigured was originally flagged by Matt Drudge in an effort to help McCain. But the whole incident has focused attention on the McCain campaign in a negative way and distracted from McCain's message.

You can't stick a fork in John McCain just yet, but he certainly is not going to make much progress as long as his campaign keeps shooting itself in the foot.

RSI's Prediction: Obama 53, McCain 45

This is how I see the election turning out. Actually, I'm somewhat conflicted in that I view the numbers as working out to a six point Obama win even though my gut tells me it could be higher.

But there are some principles of variance.

Obama and McCain are going to add up to 99% of the vote

I believe that Obama currently has a 6 point lead that could be an 8 point lead.

At a six point lead, it would be Obama 51, McCain 45, Others (Barr, Nader, McKinney) 1% and undecided 3%.

Eight points would looke like Obama 52, McCain 44, etc.

Give Obama one point for enthusiasm and turnout and one point for his share of the undecideds. Subtract a point for "buyers remorse" among whites. That's a one point plus for Obama. If he has a 6 point lead now, that would put him at 52. If he's up by eight, that would be 53 with an electoral college vote well into the 300's.

Give McCain two points for undecided voters but subtract two points for discouraged conservative turnout. Add a point to McCain for"buyers remorse" among whites. That gives McCain a plus one altogether.

In other words, I think everything is going to cancel out and Obama's lead is going to stay the same over the next 12 days.

If it's Obama +6 right now, the final outcome would be Obama 52, McCain 46. If it's Obama +8, it would be Obama 53, McCain 45. I'm more comfortable with Obama 53, McCain 45.

The Woman with the Backwards B

Yesterday, there was a story of a McCain campaign worker who had been mugged by a "dark-skinned" black guy who then carved a backward "B" into her cheek after he saw her McCain sticker.

To her credit, right-wing columnist Michelle Malkin flags this case as a likely hoax.

The most prominent female conservative columnist now that Ann Coulter's lost her mojo, Malkin thinks the "B" could have been carved backwards because the young woman did it herself. She also wonders why the "B" could be so neatly and clinically done in the context of a mugging.

What makes me suspicious is that it's a "B" at all. What people identify with Barack Obama is his exotic-sounding last name. Barack Obama's much more of an "O" than a "B."

What if the young woman's story doesn't pan out? Well, she would need a lot of help.

But we'll have to see first.

Update: It appears that the young woman has confessed that the incident was indeed a hoax. Very unfortunate.

Thursday, October 23, 2008

A Palin Puff--Today's Drag for Tomorrow's Queen

Marc Ambinder of the Atlantic is already puffing Sarah Palin for 2012 even though she hasn't finished dragging John McCain down in 2008.

Sarah Palin is the drag queen of American presidential politics. Palin is a constant testimony to John McCain's poor decision-making. She knows less about American politics and policy than a lot of college freshmen. She's more of a drag on the presidential candidate than Spiro Agnew, Geraldine Ferraro, and Dan Quayle.

And they're already puffing her for next time?

Well, bring her on.

Joe Klein Super-Puffer

In an article out this morning, Time magazine super-star Joe Klein fits Barack Obama for a place on Mount Rushmore. As is usually the case with Klein, supersizing Obama is a way to supersize himself as well. But despite all the gushing, Klein's argument is basically accurate. Obama is cool under pressure and showed strong political instincts in dealing with Iraq, Afghanistan, and the financial meltdown. Likewise, the ways he's handled McCain during the debates has also shown that Obama has a really steely character underneath the inspirational surface.

A general comment on Obama. If Obama wins on Nov. 4, he will have beaten the two strongest politicians he could have faced--John McCain and Hillary Clinton. Hillary Clinton got a lot stronger after her February meltdown, but Obama was able to claw back and maintain the slim lead he had earned in states like Iowa, Wisconsin, and Virginia. At the end of the long game with Hillary, he was able to pull out an impressive win in North Carolina.

What's happening with McCain is a little different. I've seen some recent footage of McCain on the stump. He's looking a lot better as a speaker than he did in June and has become a formidable candidate even as he's revealed his weaknesses. What we have now is John McCain at his best even though he's severely hobbled by having Sarah Palin as a VP pick.

However, Obama has improved even more than McCain. What the second and third debates showed was that Obama was better than McCain at his best.

In this sense, what's most impressive about Obama to me is that he's either beaten or is beating such high quality opposition.

Tuesday, October 21, 2008

McCain Blows His Finances

According to the Politico, the McCain campaign has dropped their attack ads and have now devoted their entire 83 million dollars on buying clothes for Sarah Palin.

Well, not quite.

But the McCain campaign has shelled out $150,000 in "accessory" payments, primarily to buy clothes, make-up, and the like for Sarah Palin.

That's a lot of fashion for a woman who's "just folks."

Update: It appears that the evil Matthew Yglesias has scooped me yet again.

Everybody Loves Sarah

One of the things I've noticed is that everybody has been happy with Sarah Palin over the last two days.

The Republicans are happy with her because she draws big crowds, fires up the base, and gets after Barack Obama and Joe Biden. For Moe Lane, a diarist at RedState.com, the energy of Palin's attacks on the Democrats reminds him of "why we all did our happy dance when McCain picked Palin."

But the Democrats might have an even bigger case of happy feet because the Palin nomination is proving to be such a huge drag on John McCain's candidacy. Ameriblog and TPM flag an item in today's NBC/Wall St. Journal poll indicating that the number one concern voters have about John McCain is his nomination of someone so obviously unqualified as Palin for VP.
Now, Palin's qualifications to be president rank as voters' top concern about McCain's candidacy -- ahead of continuing President Bush's policies, enacting economic policies that only benefit the rich and keeping too high of a troop presence in Iraq.

What's even better for the left is that the talk has already started about the Republican Party nominating Sarah Palin for president in 2012.

Talk about manna from heavy.

But the people who must be happiest about Sarah Palin are the good citizens of Alaska who are glad that Palin isn't spending much time in the state anymore.

Plato as Queer Theorist?

Somebody must have already written on this, but I was wondering yesterday if Plato wasn't a queer theory and "Western civilization" as conservatives know it isn't rooted in queer theory.

The crux would be whether Plato's concept of the Idea is connected to homoerotic ideas concerning the beauty of young teenage boys.

Homosexuality as a powerful ideal during Plato's time as reflected in his own comments in the Republic and military models like "The Sacred Band of Thebes." The Sacred Band of Thebes was a military unit made up of pairs of male lovers that was the core of Thebes' military prowess during the period of Theban military ascendancy in the 370's.

Conversely, Plato's rejection of "family" is thoroughgoing. Plato certainly dispenses with the "family" model of the Olympian gods. In The Republic, Plato also imagines a city where Guardian children aren't raised in families. Indeed, families aren't allowed to be created in Plato's ideal city at all and love in viewed as the ultimate source of tyranny.

Perhaps he started with the contemplation of boys as he worked out his alternative view of the contemplation of the Ideal.

Monday, October 20, 2008

Does the Right Think Obama's a "Socialist"

To be honest, I don't think so in most cases.

My impression of conservatives is that their name-calling is more of a form of "identity politics" than anything else. A big chunk of right-wing culture is bound up in the politics of gestures like wearing an American flag lapel pin, flying a flag, or sticking Support the Troops bumper stickers on cars. Far from indicating a love of country, this kind of symbolism is mostly about asserting a conservative identity and declaring a person's opposition to what they view as liberalism. In other words, the patriotic displays of conservatives are more about conservative identity politics than anything else. If anything, these kinds of patriotic displays represent the strong sense of ambivalence conservatives have over having to share the United States with liberals and (non-conservative) minorities.

The intensive name-calling of Barack Obama by conservatives should be understood along the same lines. Certainly, some people on the right believe that Obama is a socialist according to their very loose definitions of socialism. In the same way, I imagine that the poor woman at the McCain rally who thought Obama was an Arab was being serious.

But the connection between the insult and the reality doesn't concern most people on the right.

That's because calling Obama a "socialist," "terrorist," "traitor" or "Muslim" is more a way for conservatives to assert their identity as conservatives than anything else. In other words, conservatives are not making a claim about Obama so much as they're making a claim about themselves being the kind of person who would insult Obama in these ways. It's the gesture itself that counts rather than the reference of the gesture to any reality.

In a way, conservatives seem to enjoy these kinds of gestures more to the extent that they don't refer to anything outside themselves. In saying something that is rude or inflammatory, people on the right are indicating the social taboos that they're willing to violate in order to assert their conservatism. Once again, give that conservative identity is constructed primarily in opposition to white liberals and all the taboos of "political correctness" that liberals and their minority allies are viewed as enforcing, breaking those of taboos is an especially pleasurable way to reaffirm a person's allegiance to the conservative cause.

From the point of view of many conservatives, "truth" is just another taboo that they are glad to violate. If they can come up with one fact that vindicates the insult (say Obama's middle name of Hussein), that's more than enough to justify the "socialist" or "terrorist" accusation from the conservative point of view. They don't care whether Obama actually is a socialist or terrorist or not. Indeed, the fact that Obama is not a socialist gives a special relish to enunciating the insult.

So how should people on the left respond?

My opinion is that we on the left should focus on criticizing the phony, dishonest, character of the gesture rather than waste our time denying that Barack Obama is a socialist, terrorist, or traitor. In doing so, we get at more of the truth of what conservatives are saying.

No Tears for Mr. Blackwell

The famous Mr. Blackwell, the guy who started the celebrity put-down industry with his "Worst-Dressed List," died yesterday at 86.

It's hard for anybody to die but I have little sympathy for Mr. Richard Blackwell.

Originally published in 1960 after Blackwell failed as an actor, his "Worst Dressed List" grew from a clever bit of bitchiness to a nasty annual ritual, a principle attraction of Oscar night with Joan Rivers, and finally an on-going gig for the "entertainment news" specialists like Kat Giantis.
It's an ugly business that's become a major public abuse ritual in our ugly public culture.

I wouldn't want to be remembered for starting it all.

Sunday, October 19, 2008

The RSI Family: A Proud One Millionth

Barack Obama raised $150,000,000 and recruited 610,000 new donors. Of course, a substantial part of that money could be called the Sarah Palin Prevention Fund. A lot of people don't want to see Sara Palin get any closer to the White House than her current address in Wassila, Alaska.

The RSI family is proud to claim that we contributed $150 or so. That makes us a proud one millionth of the solution.

Panic Over Powell Endorsement

Today, Colin Powell endorsed Barack Obama for president. I'm not particularly impressed. Like the dollar, Colin Powell used to be an inflated currency that has since fallen on hard times.

But if I were a conservative, I would be in a state of panic.

If a guy who lied about Iraq before the UN and blithely discussed torture techniques is supporting Obama, who's left to bolster McCain.

Saturday, October 18, 2008

A Country Without White Liberals?

Nate Silver of FiveThirtyEight has a useful post on the way in which Sarah Palin is holding political events in areas where there are disproportionate majorities of white people.

But Palin doesn't just refer to small towns as the "pro-America" part of American because they don't have many black people and hispanics.

She thinks of small towns as not having many white liberals either.

The same is the case with the McCain flack who referred to Southwestern Virginia as the real Virginia in opposition to the Northern suburbs.

Sure, Southwestern Virginia is overwhelmingly white.

But the white population in Southwestern Virginia also does without many of those good government, politically correct whites who are easily disgusted by racism, bigotry, disdain evangelical Protestantism, and aren't very much attached to patriotic symbols.

The McCain people wish liberals would go away as well as minorities.

John McCain's Slime Trail

I may have used this image before but I think of the presidential election as a race between a turtle and a snail. Contrary to Obama's image of Obama, I think of him as a "slow" candidate who is able to stake a slim lead and nurse it to the end. He never got far ahead of Hillary Clinton and he's never gotten that far in front of McCain but he's stayed in front the whole time.

If Obama is a turtle, McCain is a snail and the slime trail behind McCain is getting bigger and bigger.

TPM sums it up well:
McCain's entire campaign is now comprised of innuendo and lies meant to tie Obama to various stereotypes of African-Americans and of course Arab terrorism. His purported foreign policy experience hasn't been part of the campaign's message in weeks. Just black, black, black, terrorist, terrorist, terrorist.

The Election Enters the "Archie Bell Phase"

Hi everybody! I'm not Archie Bell. I'm not the Drells and I don't have a new dance either.

And I could really stand a new dance right now.

That's because the 2008 presidential election is starting to remind me of the old Archie Bell and the Drells hit "Tighten Up."

Archie Bell didn't sing much on "Tighten Up." But he had very cool way of talking over the music.

"Tighten up on that bass now/ Tighten it up/ Ha, ha, yeah"

As late as Tuesday, the polls had Barack Obama ahead by 8 points with several polls showing 13 or 14 point leads. "Feeling Stronger Every Day" was my song and I was feeling it. I felt it even more on Wednesday when Barack Obama won the debate and my friend Matthew Kerbel from Villanova told me that he thought the election was in the bag for Obama.

But today, the TPM poll composite has Obama up by only 5.3 with a range from 2 (Gallup traditional) to 7 (Research 2000, IBD/TIPP, Hotline/FD).

As Archie would say, "Now let that guitar fall in/ Oh, yeah/ Tighten up on that organ now."

Actually, there's reason to expect the tightening to continue. The debates are over. McCain doesn't have any more chances to look like a bully, blink 100 miles an hour, pop out with his Uncle Fester eyes, or do that tongue thing. He won't have to worry about explaining his unpopular policies to sceptical audiences of swing voters either.

If McCain doesn't do anything stupid (a big "if"), he can look forward to another solid two weeks of sliming Obama.

Or as Republicans call it, "raising questions."

So, whether liberal bloggers like it or not (and I don't), "Tighten Up" might be the song for the really ugly part of this election.

"Come on and tighten up/ Let's tighten it up now/ Let's tighten it up now/ Tighten it up."

Sing it, baby. Actually, Mrs. RSI says I can't sing.

But neither could Archie Bell.

Friday, October 17, 2008

Palin: Macaca Moment Sans Macaca

One of the things that conservatives have been trying to do is to promote rural or small town life as a symbol of traditional America along with the military, the flag, and the Pledge.


Everybody knows the rural mythology. The myth of rural people is that they are more oriented toward family and religion, closer to the land, and more traditional. People who live in rural areas therefore represent something more honest, less corrupt, and less manipulative than the cities and suburbs. Rural people are also less subject to popular culture than people in cities and represent something that stands apart from, and superior to, the American norm.


This is a relatively small part of what Sarah Palin is referring to when she talks about small towns and rural areas as "the pro-American" part of America, or the "real America."

But here's the rub.


The right isn't attracted to the "ideal" rural America at all. Otherwise, they wouldn't be such big supporters of corporate agriculture against family farms and mountaintop removal against local property owners. If they valued rural life, conservatives wouldn't be so eager to waste the lives of the guys who join the military either.

Conservatives are more attracted to the underside of the rural life--the suspicion of outsiders, the almost palpable sense of cultural inferiority to the urban world, and the traditions of male predominance in households, white elites running the towns and counties, and evangelical religion as an adjunct of the local elites.

They also work overtime to cultivate the resentments that many in small towns and rural areas have for the "liberals" who have undermined the legitimacy of the traditional hierarchies.

And it's largely worked.

I grew up in small town upstate New York and now live in small town Eastern Kentucky. But I've also lived among liberal urban elites in Philly (the academic history circles around the University of Pennsylvania) and college towns like Chapel Hill and Ann Arbor. Urban elites have their weaknesses. My liberal/left friends tend to measure people by the quality of their work and self-control in their manners. They also have a warped view of the United States as a nation because they don't get out of the urban belts very much. But my urban friends are also curious about Kentucky and other rural areas and generally eager to find out more. They like all things exotic and count rural America as having a kind of "friendly strangeness" that they're interested in.

That's not so much the case with rural folks. In upstate New York and Eastern Kentucky, the resentment of urban culture is often very intense. An unhealthy percentage of rural self-identification is bound up in "sticking it" to the liberal opinion they associate with the urban world. That's one of the reasons (although not the only reason) why Confederate flags, nooses, and casual racism and misogyny are so pervasive in rural areas.

It's also one of the reasons why people in rural areas are so emphatic about patriotic symbols like the flag, the Star-Spangled Banner, and the military.

That's why being "pro-American" in Sarah Palin's sense is often a way to express hostility to the "outsider Americans" that rural people view as judging them.

Actually, it's too bad that cultural bitterness has such a hold over rural white areas.

My town of Morehead, KY is a college town in the Appalachian foothills where there's a healthy mix of rural people, people who've moved here from urban areas, and academic types like myself. Given the general poverty of Eastern Kentucky, there's not much here that's very stable. But the lack of stability is also a constant prod to the ingenuity of people around here and Morehead is thus a very creative place.

It's also very friendly.

From the Morehead perspective, it's easy to see a fruitful amalgamation between American urban and American rural, easy to imagine us all as living in one country.

But then the Sarah Palin's of the world get busy stirring up the bitterness to further their own ambitions.

And then you find that the same battles need to be fought over again.

Pre-Emptive Attacks on the Obama Administration

The Wall Street Journal's has started attacking the Obama administration well before the Nov. 4 election.

Today, it was Matthew Kaminski predicting that the David Axelrod approach to inspirational "hope" and "change" didn't work after Duval Patrick was elected in Massachusetts and wouldn't work if Barack Obama is elected president.

According to Kaminski, Patrick's "inspirational outsider" approach didn't work because Massachusetts Democrats didn't want to go along. They were also still holding a grudge over Patrick beating an insider in the primary.

But it isn't the same.

If Obama is elected, he's going to have a very Democratic Congressional leadership. He may have started with outsider rhetoric, but Obama was also a Democratic Party "golden boy" who landed a gig as the keynote speaker for the 2004 convention. The leadership might have thought that Obama was running four years too early, but they were also suffering from a long-standing case of "Clinton fatigue" and weren't looking forward to eight years of a Hillary presidency.

As a result, there hasn't been even a whisper of unhappiness with Obama's nomination from the Democratic Congressional leadership.

But the bottom line is that Barack Obama has added a foundation of good policy ideas to his "hope" and "change" themes. During his debates with John McCain, Obama looked like a steady, seasoned, and practical politician while McCain was playing an immature version of a maverick.

If Obama's elected president, he'll get a tough ride. But it will be because the country is going through tough times more than anything else.

Thursday, October 16, 2008

He's Got Uncle Fester Eyes


What John McCain reminded me most of last night was Uncle Fester on the Addams Family.

The problem was McCain's blinking.

McCain started the debate blinking more than a hundred times a minute. But at some point McCain seems to have realized or been informed that he was blinking like a maniac.

At that point, McCain started fighting so hard to keep his eyes open that it looked like he was in pain.

Here's a video of McCain's Uncle Fester eyes.

Wednesday, October 15, 2008

Greetings from the Socialist Republic of America

Maybe the Bush administration should consider changing the name of our country.

After all, it could be argued that the Bush people have fundamentally changed the relation between government and business in the United States by taking over the gigantic mortgage guaranteeing operations in Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, taking over the nation's biggest insurance company in IAG, and now partially nationalizing the eight biggest banks.

Perhaps we're not the United States of America in the same capitalist sense we used to be.

Personally, I kind of like the Socialist Republic of North America with it's nod toward our Hispanic heritage,

But Socialist Republic of America is shorter.

Maybe we should go with that instead

Looking at the Tuesday Polls

Well, it certainly looks good for Obama.

Yesterday, CBS/NYTimes came out with a poll that had Obama 52, McCain 39. That's the biggest Obama lead but could be even bigger than it looks if the 3 point margin of error is taken into account. Counting margin of error, the CBS poll ranges from Obama 55-36 to Obama 49-42.

What's interesting about the CBS poll is that it has McCain tracking down around the minimum Republican vote of 38% that was established by George H. W. Bush in the 1992 election where Ross Perot ran.

If the CBS poll is right, McCain is scraping the Republican bottom.

My own initial prediction was Obama 57, McCain 43 and the CBS poll is on track for that kind of landslide. GW/Battleground, ABC, and one of the Gallup estimates also have Obama out front by ten or more.

But I'm not going to be distracted by either self-interest or good news. At this point, I tend to agree with Nate Silver at FiveThirtyEight.com that CBS is likely a bit of an outlier and that Obama's actual lead is somewhere around 8%.

Assuming some margin of error here, I think Obama's lead ranges from 5 to 11 points.

If that's the case, the Obama campaign should continue doing pretty much what it's doing--performing well in tonight's debate, using its financial advantage to blanket battleground states with television ads, and gearing up its massive ground game,.

What Obama's doing is working. So the Obama people should keep doing it.

What about the McCain campaign? The McCain campaign should assume that McCain's only down by 5 and that he needs to shave that lead down to 2 over the next two weeks.

If they can get a strong debate performance from the candidate, the McCain campaign could run a two level campaign and it looks like they've already started.

At the top and visible level, the McCain people could run a "nice" campaign in which they have McCain and his lead surrogates (Joe Lieberman, Carly Fiorina, Lindsey Graham) emphasize McCain's sacrifices, experience, and general orientation toward low taxes and a strong military.

Such a Republican brand campaign has a lower value than it used to, but still might be good for a couple of points.

At the gutter level, the McCain people can count on Rush Limbaugh, Sean Hannity, and the rest of the conservative media to engage in racist fear-mongering. Limbaugh came out with a racist rant just yesterday while Stanley Kurtz of NRO did his best to create another bridge from Obama to Jeremiah Wright.

It's ugly bigoted stuff, but it's not like Republicans haven't done it before.

It's still plausible that the combination of nice conservativism and gutter conservatism could move the poll numbers a modest 5% over the next three weeks and give McCain a squeaker win.

But I don't think the McCain people will be able to turn the tide. To boil it all down, nominating Sarah Palin poisoned the water for a traditional Republican campaign.

At this point, I'd say it's most likely that Obama's going to win.

And he deserves it.

Tuesday, October 14, 2008

The Worst Thing About the Sarah Palin Blunder

The French diplomat Talleyrand was famous for pooh poohing ethics in relation to Napoleon by claiming that one of the emperor's decision was "worse than a crime, it's a blunder."

Today, recovering Republican strategist Matthew Dowd argues that John McCain's nomination of Sarah Palin was mostly a crime of putting politics before country:
Dowd proclaimed that, in his heart of hearts, McCain knew he put the country at risk with his VP choice and that he would "have to live" with that fact for the rest of his career.

Of course, nominating Sarah Palin to be vice-president would be a crime if McCain won. Given the report on the Troopergate scandal in Alaska, it looks less and less like Palin is fit to be the governor of a small state let alone have any national responsibility.

The Palin nomination is also a crime against the Republican Party's future. Palin is a singularly reckless and partisan right-winger whose showmanship makes her a strong contender for the Republican presidential nomination in 2012 (whether McCain wins or loses). But Sarah-mania is also a trap. As long as she's involved in national politics, Palin will be a very attractive figure for conservatives. Palin is also highly unpopular with non-conservatives that she could never win a national election. As a result, any Palin candidacy would tend to keep conservatives trapped in an ideological ghetto of their own.

But nominating Sarah Palin was also a blunder. And it was a blunder for several reasons.

First, the Palin hurt McCain because it put him on the defensive. The problem emerged even when McCain was ahead of Obama and Palin was enjoying popularity. Because Palin lacked much experience beyond Wasilla, Alaska, the McCain campaign first had to answer a wave of questions about her lack of experience. Then, there were succeeding waves of questions, first about her knowledge from the Gibson and Couric interviews and then her abuse of power in the Troopergate investigation.

The McCain campaign was on the offenseive during June and July with their attacks on Obama's celebrity status. But they've been playing defense ever since the Palin nomination.

Second, the Palin nomination cemented the idea that John McCain was running a gimmicky presidential campaign. Of course, McCain had already pulled lots of gimmicks ranging from his poverty tour of Appalachia, the challenge for Obama to travel with him to Iraq, the follow-up challenge to Iraq to do ten townhall meetings, and the nasty, race-baiting "Celeb" ads.

But when John McCain tabbed Sarah Palin as his "stunt nomination," he set himself up for the "gimmicky candidate" narrative that bit him during the financial meltdown. The Wall Street crisis would have played against McCain as a Republican in any case. It played much worse against him because all of his manuevers have been seen as "gimmicks" and McCain was seen as a "gimmicky" candidate in a time of crisis. The idea of McCain as a gimmicky kind of guy began to take hold in the discussion over the Palin nomination and has been one of the cancers on his campaign ever since.

Good Idea from Pat Buchanan

Who says conservatives don't have good ideas. Here's a good idea from Pat Buchanan. Liquidate our empire.

Obama Surging in the States

Obama's surge in last week's national polls is being reflected in this week's state polls. The latest state polls cited at TPM have Obama "up 52%-43% in Colorado, 54%-38% in Michigan, 51%-40% in Minnesota, and 54%-37% in Wisconsin."

There's still very plausible scenarios by which McCain could stabilize his campaign and squeak out a win. What he would have to do is recapture Florida and Virginia and then pretty much run the toss-up states.

But Obama is looking strong right now.