Wednesday, September 03, 2008

Taps for the Republicans

There's just no way around it. The Republican Convention is poorly designed compared to the Democratic Convention and the whole effect is one of tiredness and confusion. John McCain put Rick Davis in charge of the convention because Davis was doing such a poor job managing McCain's day to day campaign. Now Davis is doing a poor job with the Convention as well.

The whole convention atmosphere portrays age in a particularly unappealing way.

David Kurtz of TPM notes that the delegates at the Republican Convention in Denver are older on average than the Democratic delegates in Denver. Make that considerably older. I'm 54 but I'm pretty sure that I would have been considered a young man among Republicans. I think there was actually some "blue hair" in the crowd.

But it's not just the age of the delegates.

The aging feeling was enhance by the fact that the Republicans featured elderly speakers like Fred Thompson and Joe Lieberman on Tuesday night. It was enhanced by the pale blue background they used for the speakers. A little brighter than eggshell blue, the background was more of a Carolina blue. As a University of North Carolina Ph.D. and devout Tar Heel fan, I normally think of Carolina blue as a great color. But in this setting, it looked so weak and tired that it reminded me of a nursing home.

Strength in exhaustion--not such a great theme.

The sense of aging and impending death was elevated to a level of excruciating pain by the Republican use of flags in the background. Every once in a while a lone American flag would ripple in the background as the speaker was making a particularly serious point. But the isolation of the flag in back of the speaker was disconcerting and reminded me of military funerals.

But who knows, maybe the Republicans wanted to create a nursing home and funeral effect as a way to appeal to senior citizens like my mother.

It that's the case, they should have gone all the way and made "Taps" the theme song for the GOP convention. Maybe the late Johnny Cash would have agreed to sing it.

Tuesday, September 02, 2008

The Republican Dilemna: Doing Well Isn't Good Enough

I'm so biased against the Republican Party that I'm probably a poor judge of whether Tuesday night was effective for them or not.

But I think the Republicans have two problems in putting on a convention.

Credible Spokespeople? Most importantly, many prominent Republicans are no longer credible spokespeople for the Republican Party.

That certainly is the case with the Bush administration. George Bush, Dick Cheney, Karl Rove, Condoleeza Rice, and others have become such powerful symbols of failure and incompetence that they would always be a negative no matter what they said.

The point also applies to prominent Republicans like Rudy Giuliani, Fred Thompson, and Mitt Romney. They all performed poorly as presidential candidates during the primaries and their reputations for corruption (Giuliani), laziness (Thompson), and phoniness (Romney) stick with them even though the primaries have long been over.

Fred Thompson was the featured speaker tonight. In many ways, Thompson gave a rousing Republican speech. I rather think that Thompson's account of McCain's imprisonment in the Hanoi Hilton went on too long. But Thompson got out an energetic version of Republican talking points about Obama. So the speech was generally effective.

But who outside the most committed conservatives is interested in hearing Fred Thompson give a speech of any kind? Hardly anybody I would guess. Ultimately, Thompson was defeated before he started.

And it didn't help that he was upstaged by Bristol Palin, Levi Johnston, and all the mini-scandals emerging around Sarah Palin.

The Message Problem. The other big problem for the Republicans concerns how they are going to deal with McCain's theme of changing the political culture of Washington. When McCain or Sarah Palin take on the "political establishment," it's always the highly corrupt Republican Party establishment that they're fighting. But Republican speakers can't say that because they're addressing a Republican convention in which corrupt figures like Kentucky's Mitch McConnell are prominent delegates.

In the same way, Republican speakers like Fred Thompson have a hard time being specific about the reform policies that John McCain pursued in his battles against the political establishment. That's because all of McCain's efforts were opposed by Republicans in both the Senate (with Mitch McConnell usually leading the charge) and the House of Representatives. McCain's initiatives on tobacco regulation, campaign finance reform, lobbying reform, and immigration legislation have all been overwhelmingly opposed by Republicans. Fred Thompson and other Republican speakers can't say anything specific about what John McCain did or what he accomplished in any of those areas. As a result, much of Thompson's praise for McCain sounded pretty vague.

The only area where McCain took the lead and Republicans agreed with him was the "surge policy" in Iraq. But Thompson could only lean on that so much.

Overall, Fred Thompson did fairly well. George Bush and Joe Lieberman weren't that bad either. But I thought that their decent efforts still fell kind of flat given that none of the Republican speakers were in a position to really advance John McCain's candidacy.

The Destructive Magic of the "R" Word

The Bristol Palin/Levi Johnston pregnancy feeding frenzy is now officially "on." The newspapers, blogs, and everybody else are all over the story.

And the whole issue gets down to one little word that begins with "R."

After everything that John McCain's done to position himself to be elected president since 2000, it looks like his candidacy might be killed by one word appearing in the MySpace page of an 18 year old guy from Wasilla, Alaska named Levi Johnston.

That word is "redneck."

On his now famous "MySpace page," Levi Johnston says "I'm a "f - - - in' redneck" with the New York Post quoting him as liking snowboarding and riding dirt bikes as well.

Johnston goes on:

" . . . I live to play hockey. I like to go camping and hang out with the boys, do some fishing, shoot some s- - - and just f - - -in' chillin' I guess."

"Ya f - - - with me I'll kick [your] ass," he added.

He also claims to be "in a relationship," but states, "I don't want kids."

But it's Levi Johnston calling himself a "fucking redneck" that I think will blow up John McCain's campaign. What Johnston's "redneck" self-characterization does is undercut everything that the McCain campaign has been trying to promote about Palin's Alaska background and provide an anchor for every criticism of Palin in a widely derided "white trash" stereotype.

The McCain campaign and the media have been promoting Sarah Palin's Alaska roots in terms of an outdoorsy rural authenticity of shooting bears and eating tasty mooseburgers. But as soon as Levi Johnston's macho preening about being a "fucking redneck" hit the internet, all that country chic began to look like "white trash" stupidity, ignorance, and awkwardness. Far from being something that "could happen to anyone," Bristol Palin's pregnancy is now "typical white trash behavior." Here's one internet site to illustrate the point but I started hearing the theme on my Eastern Kentucky campus even before I could check the internet after today's classes.
His name is Levi Johnston, and on his now private My Space page, he describes himself as a "fucking redneck." Nice, this does sound like Jamie Lynn Spears all over again. Maybe Casey Aldridge can give Levi some advice on how to handle things, like how to point guns at paparazzi, and how to throw a white trash barn brawl.
All of sudden Alaska looks a lot less like a paradise and a lot more like Kentucky, West Virginia, and Eastern Tennessee in its Deliverance-like patheticness. If the stereotypes work the way I think they will, Alaska behaviors like carrying guns, shooting bears, and dressing a moose will become emblems of the lack of manners, style, lack of intelligence in Alaska. It's all depressingly familiar from life in Eastern Kentucky and web sites are already reproducing pictures from Johnston's MySpace page as evidence of Alaskan backwardness.

In other words, it looks like "white trash."

It wouldn't be so back for the McCain campaign if Levi Johnston's "redneckness" stopped with him. But Levi Johnston is now connected with Sarah Palin's family and the destructive magic of stereotyping means that Sara Palin has already been pulled into the redneck stereotype just like everybody in Appalachia is pulled into hillbilly/redneck stereotyping whether they like it or not.

The power of the redneck stereotype reaches out to John McCain as well. Whether McCain thoroughly vetted Sarah Palin or not was an arcane matter of "inside politics" last weekend. But that's not the case anymore. McCain doesn't have to worry about being stereotyped as a redneck himself (being a long-time member of the political elite helps in that way). But I would bet that the issue of McCain's vetting Palin is going to be reformulated in terms of McCain avoiding the connection with the Palin family (and Alaska). In other words, people will be thinking that McCain could have avoided the whole disaster of connecting himself with Sara Palin, Bristol Palin, Levi Johnston, and the whole "red-neck state of Alaska" if he'd just done his homework.

If that stereotype gets firmly established, McCain has no chance of winning.

After all of McCain's warmongering, race-baiting, policy flipflopping, and kowtowing to the religious right, it's ironic that his candidacy might be brought down because a clueless kid like Levi Johnston decided to brag about being a "fucking redneck" on MySpace.

A Note on Privacy--Sarah Palin's handlers put out a statement requesting that "the media `respect our daughter and Levi's privacy as has always been the tradition of children of candidates.'"

Then again, I'm not sure that bringing Levi Johnston to the Republican convention is a way to keep things private.

The Romance of Tropical Alaska

Has anybody noticed all the media reports that make Alaska sound like a paradise where the people are friendly, honest, and eager to talk, the moose are easy to shoot, and the oil money flows hot and heavy?

It all makes Alaska seem like a tropical paradise.

Except for one thing--most of Alaska is unbelievably cold, dark, and depressing during the incredibly long winters. I went to college in northern New York which is one of the coldest places in the lower 48. One of my professors referred to "the North Country" as "The Gulag." But Alaska's even colder. My department at Morehead State in Kentucky interviewed a woman from the University of Alaska at Fairbanks for a chair position. She was desperate to get out. Most people she knew in Fairbanks spend a good chunk of each winter in Hawaii or New Mexico. But she had stayed in Fairbanks to work on her research instead and now the winters were driving her so crazy that she was positively eager to move to rural Kentucky.

Come to think of it, a couple of my social work colleagues moved from Alaska to Kentucky as well.

The other thing that's annoying about the media's Alaska romance is that rural areas in the lower forty-eight get so much nasty stereotyping. When the media pays attention to rural Appalachian areas like Eastern Kentucky, they never mention the friendly people, the great music, poetry, and fiction writing, or the compelling stories of overcoming adversity. Instead, it's all about hillbilly ignorance, high school dropouts, pregnant teenagers, methamphetamine, marijuana growing and poverty. During the Democratic primaries, the media unfairly portrayed tiny Inez and Clay County as the ground zero of American racism.

Obviously, the election is going to be hot and heavy for the next two months.

But after the election, the national media should give rural areas like Eastern Kentucky the same friendly look they gave Alaska during the Sara Palin roll-out.

I'm sure they'll find that we're a tropical paradise as well.

Monday, September 01, 2008

The Palin Family Values: The Plot Thickens

A Tangled Web. There are now two lines of consideration on maternity questions in the Palin family. The first concerns the baby Trigg born in April with Downs Syndrome. The story was that Sarah Palin faked the pregnancy and childbirth and that the real mother of the baby was Pahlin's daughter Bristol Palin. Originating in a Daily Kos diary and promoted by Andrew Sullivan, the phony pregnancy story had not yet found it's way to the mainstream media when the McCain campaign countered by announcing a second big story.

It turned out that Bristol Palin, age 17, is now pregnant.

According to the McCain campaign, Bristol Palin is five months pregnant which would mean that she (most likely) could not have given birth to a child in April four months ago. That set off a fevered round of pronoucements from the McCain campaign and the Obama campaign, reports from Wassila, Alaska, and an enormous amount of blogging and internet commentary.

Nagging Questions. The McCain campaign wants the pregnancy story put to rest, the Obama campaign wants the pregnancy story put to rest, and Time magazine wants the story put to rest.

But I'm not so sure.

The "fake pregnancy" rumor appears to be untrue. Another Daily Kos diarist found a picture of Palin looking obviously pregnant as she was being interviewed on television.

My main question concerns the response to Bristol Palin's pregnancy. Aware that his mother gave birth to him at 18, Barack Obama wants people to drop the story. I understand that. My mother was pregnant with me when she was 18 as well.

But I think it's important to consider how conservative Republicans would have responded if a teenage Chelsea Clinton was pregnant "out of wedlock." Or one of Obama's daughters? Or if Bristol Palin's mother had been a Democrat.

Let's put it this way. Such an event would have provoked a deluge of moral commentary and snarkiness from the right.

Let's start with the snarkiness.

The snark would have started with comments about Chelsea Clinton's appearance. The right makes more jokes about Chelsea Clinton's looks as the left does about George Bush's IQ. John McCain once asked a GOP audience: "Why is Chelsea Clinton so ugly? Because her father is Janet Reno."

If Chelsea Clinton had become pregnant when she was 16 during the 1996 election, conservative satirists would have had a field day. There would have been endless commentary about the father's taste in women, what it must have been like to have sex with a woman as bad looking as Chelsea Clinton, or how ugly the baby would have been.

Needless to say, Janet Reno would have made a reappearance.

And Republican politicians like John McCain would have loved it--and repeated it.

Would the right have treated Bristol Palin any better if Sarah Palin had been on the Democratic ticket? I don't think so.

If Chelsea Clinton had gotten pregnant at 16, is there any reason to think that the conservative commentatariat would not have hesitated for a second in portraying her pregnancy as a

Conservatives already view teen pregnancy as a symptom of liberalism's advocacy of relative values as opposed to the supposedly absolute values of conservatism. Here's Star Parker writing for the conservative blog Townhall.com.

Conservatives, as I stated above, are clear about this. Traditional values we learn from the Bible. We can simply point to the Ten Commandments. And liberal values? The absolute here is that there are no absolutes. Everything is relative, and the only absolute is to welcome and tolerate everything.

Starting from this position, conservatives would have condemned a Chelsea Clinton pregnancy as an example of the failure of both liberal values and liberal parenting on the part of the Clintons. The key is Parker's comment on the only liberal absolute being to "welcome and tolerate everything." Conservatives lament that pre-marital teen sex is no longer condemned like it was in the forties and fifties. They don't like the toleration of teen sex by parents and public opinion and they don't like the encouragement of teen sex that they see in television, movies, videos, and music.

In this context, writers on the right would have hammered hard at a Chelsea Clinton pregnancy for what it said about the liberalism of the Clinton family and the liberalism of American culture.
The same would have been the case with Bristol Palin if her mom had been a Democrat.

It's unfortunate that Bristol Palin is pregnant and it's also unfortunate that her pregnancy has become a matter of controversy during an election season.

But Bristol Palin is lucky that her mom's a Republican.

Otherwise, the right-wing would have made her pregnancy a symbol of everything that was wrong with the Democrats, liberalism, and America.

Hey Charlie, Stay Safe Man

Hurricane Gustav is slated to come ashore near the city of Franklin, LA about 100 miles west of New Orleans. My brother-in-law Charlie Carew is living in Breau Bridge about 50 miles northwest of Franklin where he remodels a house every once in a while. It's not so much that Charlie and his girlfriend Rachel don't work hard, but he's an exacting, artistic kind of guy. So, he doesn't finish very quickly.

Unlike your average politician, Charlie's not exactly a guy who lives for family and he's hard to reach in the best of times.

This isn't one of those times.

So, we'll just wish him the best and keep trying to reach him.

Sunday, August 31, 2008

Yowsa!

Andrew Sullivan is hinting that Sarah Palin may not have had a Downs Syndrome baby after all. Instead, Sullivan believes that it may have been her daughter Bristol who was actually pregnant with the baby while Sarah Palin pretended to be pregnant and took credit for the birth.

Very weird.

But Enquiring Minds, and who doesn't have one these days, now want to know.

Is Alaska Closer to Russia?

The McCain camp is now saying that Sarah Palin has foreign policy experience because Alaska is close to Russia. But couldn't one also say that Alaska is closer to Russia than it is to the United States?

UK 27-Louisville 2

The University of Kentucky football team is a good story of a long-struggling program that's finally getting off the bottom. The coaching staff there--Rich Brooks, Joker Phillips, and Steve Johnson--is good at taking medium level recruits and turning them into highly productive players in the SEC. Kentucky gone from three or four wins a season to seven or eight and they've won two bowl games in a row against good teams (Clemson and Florida State).

Even better, the UK coaches do it without being ostentatiou Bobby Petrino-like assholes, Nick Saban-like control freaks, or making a big show of the kind of "intensity" that revolves around humiliating their players.

Today, UK beat the University of Louisville in a rivalry game 27-2. It wasn't the best win in the world. UK's offense wasn't very well coordinated and only scored one touchdown after being handed field position on the seven. The main problem is receiver. UK had three receivers get drafted by the NFL last year--Keenan Burton, Steve Johnson, and Jacob Tamme. The replacements showed some potential against Louisville, but they've got a long way to go before Kentucky faces Florida, Tennessee, and SEC competition.

The UK defense scored two touchdowns off turnovers and got important stops. But Louisville's offense was wretched and they started with bad field position all day. So, it's difficult to get a read on UK's defense. One good sign is that safety Marcus McClinton didn't get much business. As the last line of defense, McClinton used to have to make a lot of tackles on opposing backs bursting through the UK defensive line and linebackers. Today, he was like the Maytag repairman in the defensive backfield, waiting for something to happen.

That's a sign that UK's defense has gotten generally stronger.

Tape-Blogging the McCain/Palin Event

I'm looking at the YouTube video of the roll-out for Sarah Palin in Dayton, Ohio on Friday. Well, McCain certainly looks a lot better hugging Palin than he looked hugging George Bush.

But Palin's speech isn't that great. It wasn't bad or terrible either. It was just ok. Palin delivered the lines that McCain's team wrote for her in a workmanlike fashion. But she talked as though she had just heard a couple of days ago that McCain's theme for her would be "shaking up Washington."

Actually, she probably did hear that for the first time a couple of days ago.

Palin might be geeked up to be McCain's vice-presidential candidate, but her heart didn't seem to be particularly in that speech.

So what's Palin about. According to the Dayton speech, she's about:

Marriage--it's Palin and her husband Todd's 20th wedding anniversary. Todd's a working class guy who's a commercial fisherman, member of the Steelworkers, and a championship snow "machine" worker.

Lots of kids--Palin has five kids, including a baby with Downs Syndrome.

Military--Palin's oldest son, Track, is in the army, serving in an infantry brigade, and is headed for Iraq.

The crowd of 12,000 is cheering and chanting "USA, USA." No surprise there. It's all identity politics among whites. The core of liberal political identity lies in the civil rights movement, Martin Luther King and opposition to racism, misogyny, and homophobia they associate with conservatives. The right identifies with the male-headed household, the military, and other traditional institutions they view liberals as rejecting.

Given that white identity politics is about rejecting the opposing side as immoral, offfensive, and repugnant, cheering the military service of Palin's son is mostly a way for white conservatives in the crowd to stick it to white liberals.

"Hockey Mom Politician"--Sarah Palin began her political career in the PTA before getting elected mayor on an agenda of cutting property taxes. She stood up to "politics as usual"--the special interests and lobbies, and the "good old boy network."

Taking risks--"A ship in harbor is safe. The people of America expect us to seek public office and serve for the right reason. And the right reason is to challenge the status quo and serve the common good."

Testimonial to McCain--She's posing McCain as a threat to "business as usual in Washington. This is a moment when principles and political independence matters not just the party line."

This is the core of Palin's "message" in this speech, that John McCain and her will be ready, willing, and eager to take risks to "shake up the status quo" in Washington. This, instead of her foreign policy inexperience, is where the Democrats should challenge McCain and Palin. It's not the "status quo in general" that needs to be changed, it's the status quo created by George Bush, Karl Rove, and the Republican establishment. John McCain might have been an "agent of change" in 2000, but he failed to get tobacco, immigration, and other reform legislation passed. In other words, John McCain is largely a failed reformer. Now McCain hews so closely to the right-wing line that he's become an agent of the GOP status quo.

And that's much of what McCain's nomination of Sarah Palin says, that McCain is now a fully enlisted soldier on the Republican side of the culture wars.

This is where it becomes evident that Sarah Palin is pretty much of a downer as a public speaker. She's not as bad as McCain himself and she's actually doing a decent job of reading the teleprompter. But it's slow, mechanical, and has very little emotional force. Democrats complained pretty vociferously about Mark Warner's speech. But Palin's not even on Warner's level, let alone Hillary Clinton, Bill Clinton, or Barack Obama.

Progress? Now Palin is moving on to women's issues by citing the 19th amendment, Geraldine Ferraro, and Hillary Clinton. This is shaky ground for a conservative like Palin. Much of the reason Palin was nominated was that Palin was a "woman" who could embrace many aspects of women rights without being a feminist or abandoning traditionalism. Palin has been both a star athlete and a beauty queen, a female office-holder and a mother of five children, an avid hunter and fisherwoman and a traditional wife.

The McCain campaign is eager for Palin to embrace both the post-feminist and traditional sides of her life. This is how they want to appeal to disappointed Hillary voters.

But this is where it gets dicey. Palin was booed today in Washington, PA when she gave a little tribute to Hillary Clinton. Conservatives are still enormously hostile to feminism and Hillary Clinton is the most important symbol of "pushy feminists" to conservatives.

I wouldn't be surprised if Palin didn't give up this kind of token nod to feminism and concentrate on stoking the conservative base as a lifelong NRA member, virulent opponent of abortion, and eager promoter of oil drilling.

A woman can only be so many things to so many people.

Saturday, August 30, 2008

The Cynicism of the Palin Nomination

My initial impression of Sarah Palin is that she's an engaging politician and public figure who's a lightweight in terms of national politics and international affairs. The short-term question about the politics of the Palin appointment concerns how quickly she learns, whether she can avoid embarrassing herself as she learns more about the world beyond Alaska, and how she projects herself through the national media. One thing is for sure. Pahlin's learning curve is going to be steep. Before her nomination, her interests were overwhelmingly local. Even responding to earlier speculation about her being nominated for vice-president, she quickly brought the discussion back to the local interests of Alaska:

As for that "V.P. talk"...I tell ya, I still can't answer that question uh, until somebody answers, for me, What is it exactly that the V.P. does, every day? I'm used to, uh, being very productive and working real hard in an administration...we want to make sure that that V.P. slot would be a fruitful type of position, especially for Alaskans and for the things that we're trying to accomplish up here for the rest of the U.S., before I can even start addressing that, uh, that question.

Democratic surrogates and the media focus on Palin's lack of foreign policy experience. She doesn't seem to have any experience with the economy, health care, infrastructure, or education either. That doesn't necessarily mean that Palin has no potential. The point is that nobody knows what Palin's potential is. I don't know. The media and the Democrats don't know. Most important, the McCain campaign doesn't know what Sarah Palin's about.

And that's what makes the Palin nomination so inappropriate.

There is no way that McCain could have known much about Palin. Before nominating the Alaska governor, McCain's had only met Palin once or twice and talked with her on the phone once. His advisers might not have known her even that well. Given that he had minimal information on Palin, McCain was in no position to know how prepared she might be to be vice-president, the nature of her temperament, or whether she's capable of engaging in a national level campaign. In fact, the McCain camp did not vett Palin at all and it appears that McCain did not have any more information about Palin than was available to the average blogger.

Perhaps not even that much.

According to conservative journalist and former Bush speechwriter David Frum:
Sarah Palin may well have concealed inner reservoirs of greatness. I hope so! But I'd guess that John McCain does not have a much better sense of who she is, what she believes, and the extent of her abilities than my enthusiastic friends over at the [National Review Online] Corner.

In the final analysis, Palin's lack of experience says a lot more about McCain's cynicism than it says about Palin. Why did McCain nominate Sarah Palin? The most important reason was he wanted to drive the news cycle. Because the McCain camp expected that Obama's Thursday night speech to be extremely successful, they wanted to make a big splash on Friday as a way to keep the media from giving Obama a great deal of credit.

McCain chose Palin primarily as a "surprise female candidate" to dominate the news and didn't believe that he needed to have a lot of detailed knowledge for that purpose. So, the McCain campaign didn't vet Palin, didn't have McCain campaign with her, or try her out as a surrogate before nominating her. I understand the reasoning behind this. Winning "media cycles" is important for a McCain campaign that's always in danger of falling permanently behind and any contact with Palin risked spoiling the media value of the nomination.

At the same time, the cynicism of treating the vp nomination as a disposable media product is typical McCain. For McCain, there is little that is not disposable in this way. The cynicism can be seen on the policy level with McCain's ever-changing positions on taxes, immigration, campaign finance reform, and judicial nominations. But it's probably even more cynical that McCain has adopted the same Karl Rove mentality about personally attacking opponents that George Bush used against him in 2000. For McCain, all the slime bombs that he and the rest of the right are throwing at Obama are "just politics" and kind of fun at that.

In a way, McCain's worse than Bush. After 9-11, the Bush administration had an authentic mission of remaking the world that they pursued in a dishonest and criminal manner. All McCain has is his cynical drive to get elected "by all means necessary." If the country were so unfortunate as to elect McCain, we basically would be set adrift as neither a McCain administration nor the Democrats in Congress would have the mandate or the political capacity to govern. It would be four more years like the last two years of the lame duck Bush administration. It would be a disaster.

Oh No! A Grad Student in the Family

Well, Mrs. RSI is officially a graduate student at the University of Kentucky. Yesterday was her last day of work as a school nurse with the Gateway Health District. Mrs. RSI got a touching send-off from her school. The nurse who replaced her got all 200 kids in the elementary school to sign a card and then presented it in a school assembly.

I'm not usually big for sentiment, but I must say that Mrs. RSI is well deserving.

Later, we had a nice gathering with friends and their children on the patio of the local Italian restaurant and just talked about stuff. It turned out that one of our friends was a shot-putter in high school just like me.

I knew there was something special about her.

This morning, Mrs. RSI went off to her first class in the Masters in Nursing program at the University of Kentucky in Lexington sixty miles away. Before she left, the girls and I admonished her that she needed to "make good choices" while she was at school.

Then, she was on her way.

Friday, August 29, 2008

Sarah's The One

Here's some short takes on the Sarah Palin nomination:

Experience. Barack Obama's been a national figure for almost four years. Sarah Palin's been a national figure for almost four hours.

Palin's Role Model. Joe Biden said that John McCain would be picking the next Dick Cheney for Vice-President. McCain picked the next Dan Quayle instead.

The Hillary Effect. Hillary Clinton's candidacy was about expanding opportunities for women. Little did Sarah Palin know that she would be the first woman to benefit from those opportunities.

The Bill Effect. Chris Matthews claimed that Hillary Clinton wouldn't have been running for president if Bill hadn't slept around on her. Sarah Palin would be running for vice-president if Bill hadn't slept around on Hillary either.

The Republicans and Women. By nominating Sarah Palin, conservative Republicans have proved once again that they don't hate women. Conservatives have two behaviors toward women-- hating women or proving that they don't hate women.

Foreign Policy Experience. Who says Sarah Palin doesn't foreign policy experience. She has visited the Lower 48.

It Takes a Village. Before being elected governor, Sarah Palin's main political experience was serving as mayor of her hometown of Wassila, Alaska--population 8,000 and change. Yes, it does take a village to raise a vice-president.

Cindy Shouldn't Worry. Miss Teen RSI thinks that John McCain is sleeping with Sarah Palin. But Cindy shouldn't worry. Sarah Palin only owns three houses.

It's Sarah Palin for McCain VP

Well, McCain didn't pull the trigger on Lieberman after all. It makes me glad that I didn't write all those posts about how sure I was that it was going to be Lieberman.

Sarah Palin is a safe choice for the right wing. She's pro-life and has five kids with one of them being a Down's Syndrome baby. Palin's also a kind of political reformer who ousted an ethically tainted governor. That means she won't be easy to associate with the Mitch McConnell/Tom DeLay corruption wing of the Republican Party.

Two points:

1. Given that the Palin announcement came the day after Obama's speech, I'm not sure there's going to be much of a "Palin Promotion Blitz" before her own nomination next Wednesday.

2. Palin is going to have to answer a lot of questions about her knowledge of foreign policy in general and domestic policy in the other 49 states. There's reason to suspect that she's never been interested in much outside Alaska.

Thursday, August 28, 2008

Obama's Speech--Welding together Principles, Policies, and Testimony

The Tremendousness of it All. Barack Obama's acceptance speech was such a monster home run that it might be reverberate all the way through the Republican convention next week.

The speech was so good that it's difficult to think of images that fully capture the quality of Obama's thought, the skill in his rhetorical constructions, and forcefulness of his emotion.

But that doesn't mean I can't try.

Obama's speech was so tremendous it left the McCain camp speechless.

Hillary and Bill Clinton's speeches were terrific and hit all the supportive marks they needed to hit. But as good as they were, Obama was better and seeing the speech made it possible to understand why he won the Democratic nomination.

Like any other Democratic presidential candidate, Barack Obama has to face down the GOP slime machine. The speech succeeded extremely well at this as Obama confronted McCain's most popular ads head on without being defensive in the slightest. Describing how he saw the faces of his family in returning veterans from the Iraq war, college students who have to hold jobs while in school, and woman talking about setting up small businesses, Obama portrayed his own family as a model of everyday patriotism, hard work, and achievement. Then he addressed McCain's celebrity ads:
I don't know what kind of lives John McCain thinks that celebrities lead, but this has been mine. These are my heroes. Theirs are the stories that shaped me. And it is on their behalf that I intend to win this election and keep our promise alive as President of the United States.
By rooting himself in lower middle-class striving, Obama rooted himself in everyday American life in a way that powerfully belied the celebrity aspersions in McCain's attack ads.

Finally, as a new public figure and an African-American swimming against the tide of racial stereotypes, Obama has to prove himself over and over. Tonight Obama proved himself yet again just as he proved himself against Hillary Clinton and during his overseas trip. For that, Obama will get another chance to prove himself during the debates.

Why Obama's Speech Worked So Well. Barack Obama's speech was excellent in many ways. He was especially successful in staking out his own positions and he could do so because he did such an excellent job os welding together core values, specific policy proposals, and personal testimony.

Obama articlated his idea of core American values in several versions of this sentence:
That's the promise of America - the idea that we are responsible for ourselves, but that we also rise or fall as one nation; the fundamental belief that I am my brother's keeper; I am my sister's keeper.
There are two sides of the rhetorical equation--individual striving and obligations to other people. Andrew Sullivan views Obama's speech as quintessentially liberal--"more unabashedly, unashamedly liberal than any Democratic acceptance speech since the great era of American liberalism" in the 1960's. Actually, the individual elements in Obama's equation--responsibility, hard work, drive, innovation, and success--have strong echoes of the conservative Democratic themes that resulted in welfare reform during the 1980's and 1990's. But Obama connects these kinds of "bedrock" values to liberalism in a very common-sense way when he stresses that government needs to do "that which we cannot do for ourselves - protect us from harm and provide every child a decent education; keep our water clean and our toys safe; invest in new schools and new roads and new science and technology." By incorporating conservative values into a liberal framework, Obama articulates a kind of stripped-down "consensus liberalism" that had a great deal of rhetorical force but could also appeal to anyone socialized into American traditions.

Then, Obama articulated his specific policy proposals in terms of his core values. The Democrats often get criticized for either talking about values without policy or talking about policy in a way that's unconnected to core values. But Obama avoided these shortcomings.

Change means a tax code that doesn't reward the lobbyists who wrote it, but the
American workers and small businesses who deserve it.

Unlike John McCain, I will stop giving tax breaks to corporations that ship jobs overseas, and I will start giving them to companies that create good jobs right here in America.

I will eliminate capital gains taxes for the small businesses and the start-ups that will create the high-wage, high-tech jobs of tomorrow.

I will cut taxes - cut taxes - for 95% of all working families. Because in an economy like this, the last thing we should do is raise taxes on the middle-class.


Obama avoided wonkishness by articulating his proposals briefly and clearly. But he was also successful in connecting each of those proposals to core values of striving, work, and responsibility. That's a lot of the reason these kinds of economic proposals--which are standard Democratic Party proposals--had a force that most Democratic politicians aren't able to give them. The same was the case with Obama's proposals on education, health care, energy, and foreign policy. They were brief, specific, and closely connected to his vision of what's at the core of American life.

What gave all of this even more force was that Obama was successful in further connecting his policy proposals and vision of core values with testimony about lower-middle class and middle-class Americans. At the beginning Obama told a number of anecdotes about his mother, grandmother, grandfather, factory workers in Indiana, women starting up small businesses, and the like. Having done so, Obama set himself up to pose the idea of his idea of political change as a force that emerged from outside Washington:

You have shown what history teaches us - that at defining moments like this one, the change we need doesn't come from Washington. Change comes to Washington. Change happens because the American people demand it - because they rise up and
insist on new ideas and new leadership, a new politics for a new time.

And I've seen it in this campaign. In the young people who voted for the first time, and in those who got involved again after a very long time. In the Republicans who never thought they'd pick up a Democratic ballot, but did. I've seen it in the workers who would rather cut their hours back a day than see their friends lose their jobs, in the soldiers who re-enlist after losing a limb, in the good neighbors who take a stranger in when a hurricane strikes and the floodwaters rise.

Obama's testimonials to the power and possibility of the yearning for change were capped by a final, and very moving, testimonial to the civil rights movement. Yesterday was the 45th anniversary of the "I Have a Dream Speech" and Obama held off any reference to the speech until the end of his speech when he represented Martin Luther King and civil rights activism as a particularly American movement that "pushes us forward even when the path is uncertain; that binds us together in spite of our differences; that makes us fix our eye not on what is seen, but what is unseen, that better place around the bend."

By linking up everyday striving and the various ways that most people sacrifice for each other with Martin Luther King in this way, Obama was able to present ground his policies in a compelling vision of the United States as a society brought together by a shared yearning for a "better future."

It was great stuff. I'm glad I saw it.

Obama Better Than a Rock Star--A Note on Appearances

The McCain campaign and the Republicans have a lot of fun with Obama's "rock-star" and "celebrity" status. But Obama did not look like a rock star during his speech at Invesco Field tonight.

He looked better. A lot better.

When I see telecasts of bands playing the Super Bowl and other stadium venues, my first impression is almost always that the band is physically overwhelmed by the massiveness of the space.

That didn't happen to Obama. Most of the time, the cameras stayed fairly tight on his face and Obama filled up the camera with smiling, impassioned, tough, and determined expression. It was a stadium speech in front of more than 80,000 people.
Even when cameras panned away from Obama to his backdrop, they did so in a way that did not diminish Obama's physical presence. Obama was helped by the bright blue flooring. It had an electric, bright, bouncy feeling that went along very well with the beginning of his speech. He was also helped by the way he was placed out front, by himself in such a way that background visuals couldn't clutter from Obama's presence.
The people who arranged the cameras also had a way to pan to the audience without making Obama look as small compared to the stadium as he actually was. It looked like the directors had the cameras pan to fairly small sections of the large crowd rather than try to capture the crowd as a whole. Obama would have looked small if he had been justaposed to the whole crowd. Arrayed against small sections, he looked comparatively larger.

Partly because of brilliant staging, Obama dwarfed the stadium.

The Latest Fiasco of the Repugnant Conservative

Today, the John McCain campaign has to throw another conservative under the bus. This time it was John Goodman, a guy who seemed to have served as an adviser on his health care proposal. Goodman's clever idea is that everybody "effectively" has health insurance because they have access to the emergency room.

Here's Goodman's "solution" to the problem of those who don't have health insurance (via Talking Points Memo)
"So I have a solution. And it will cost not one thin dime," Mr. Goodman said. "The next president of the United States should sign an executive order requiring the Census Bureau to cease and desist from describing any American -- even illegal aliens -- as uninsured. Instead, the bureau should categorize people according to the likely source of payment should they need care. "So, there you have it. Voila! Problem solved."

What goes unstated in relation to these kinds of conservatives is just how repugnant and inhuman they are--the lack of concern for human suffering of any kind, the eagerness to cover up inconvenient facts, the smugness with which it's all done.

It's just disgusting.

Live Blogging Bill Richardson

8:16, Bill Richardson wasted no time laying into John McCain. He must have been reading RSI when he said that John McCain was telling people they didn't know their own minds.

Best line: "John McCain pays hundreds of dollars for his shoes, but he's going to make you pay for his flip flops."

Joe Biden--The Good and the Bad

Joe Biden got very emotional in his VP acceptance speech, largely because Biden views the VP nomination as a validation of his political career. Last night, that quest for validation gave his speech an emotional authenticity that added a great deal to the oratorical quality of the speech.

But the downside is that Biden needs that validation so badly. That's what often makes him questionable as a top level politician.

Wednesday, August 27, 2008

The Forward Leader vs the Default Option

Liberal blogger Matt Yglesias reminds me of something I've thought for a long time. Noting high favorability ratings for both Obama and McCain, Yglesias claims that "before this campaign started, John McCain was the most popular politician in America and Barack Obama was a widely admired rising political star."

It's a good insight, but I'd go a little farther. John McCain has been the most popular politician in the United States since 2000. As a result of the 2000 campaign, McCain had a very strong base of support among moderates and independents and was also liked and trusted on the left. In fact, I believe that McCain was more broadly popular than either Gore and Bush during the 2000 general election campaign. The only constituency that disliked and distrusted McCain was the conservatives who dominated the Republican Party. Of course, that was enough to keep him from winning the Republican nomination. But McCain was a dominant political figure.

McCain remained highly popular through the beginning of the 2008 election campaign. That popularity was somewhat "well-worn" as Hillary Clinton and Barack Obama emerged as popular Democrats and McCain's began to strongly defend the war in Iraq. But McCain was still popular enough that he could serve as a "default option" for Republicans when alternative candidates like Rudy Giuliani and Mitt Romney proved to be unpopular.

The durability of McCain's popularity has a significant impact on the race between him and Obama. Most important, McCain's personal popularity has made it possible for him to stay even in the race despite popular disdain for the Bush administration and broad hostility toward the Republican Party and conservativism as an ideology. John McCain has been able to sustain the "McCain Brand" despite associating himself with damaged goods in the Republican Party.

As a result, one of the questions for the Republican convention next week is whether the assocition with Republican figures like Rudy Giuliani, Mitt Romney, and various Republican senators and members of Congress is going to help or hurt McCain.

I suspect the latter.

The durability of McCain's personal popularity also defines some of the tactics around Barack Obama. Obama has slightly higher "favorable" ratings than McCain at present, one of the most important objectives of Obama's campaign has to be solidifying his "favorability" ratings as voters get to know him. Obama needs to prove himself over and over again in order for people to fully trust their positive perceptions of him. That's why Obama's overseas trip was important for him. Questions had been raised concerning Obama's ability to lead in foreign affairs. Obama needed to show that he could do it.

This is why Obama needs to keep having an affirmative, positive dimension to his campaign. He wants to keep reinforcing his general favorability.

At the same time, Obama and his surrogates need to convince voters that John McCain is no longer the politician they grew to respect between 2000 and 2004. It's not so much "tearing down" McCain as convincing people that McCain is no longer the politician they originally liked and trusted. Last night at the Democratic convention, Joe Biden was especially effective at contrasting Barack Obama's positions to McCain's to show that McCain's views had become exactly the same as President Bush's.

Conversely, much of what the McCain campaign is about is an effort to encourage voters to question their own favorable impressions of Barack Obama. In some ways, McCain's campaign reminds me of the efforts of the Los Angeles police in relation to the Rodney King trial back in the early 90's. Because the police officers were shown beating Rodney King on videotape, their defense attorneys focused their efforts on convincing jurors to believe the police accounts rather than their own eyes. This is what McCain is doing with Obama as well. At bottom, the McCain campaign's repeated sneering at Obama as a "celebrity" is an effort to convince people that their positive impressions of Obama's speeches and campaigning are wrong and that Obama is "really" a shallow Britney Spears/Paris Hilton kind of person.

For Obama, this means that he needs to redouble his efforts to solidify the connection between himself as a leader with his largely popular positions on the issues. Obama's mainstream Democratic views on the war in Iraq and Afghanistan, the economy, taxes, social security, and education are all broadly in line with American public opinion. Currently, Obama is seen as an intelligent and charismatic leader and plausible presidential candidate. To seal the deal, Obama needs to establish himself as the political leader who can effectively champion these important issues over the coming eight years. In other words, Obama needs to show himself as "the man" (to quote Jack White from The Root) for an ambitious, forward-looking political agenda.

Otherwise, a majority of voters could vote for McCain as a "default option" they know and trust.

Tuesday, August 26, 2008

Bringing in the Big Leaguers

A Big Leaguer. Michelle Obama was a highly effective amateur, but Monday night was basically amateur night at the Democratic Convention. Last night, the Democrats brought in the big leaguers for the prime time television slots. Former Virginia governor Mark Warner gave an outstanding keynote address that focused on broad opportunity and creativity as competitive advantages for the United States. I have to admit that I've always been suspicious of Warner because of his reputation as a "moderate," and "non-partisan," which usually means "agree with the Republicans," Democrat. But Warner's speech was much more of an Al Gore vision of the tremendous opportunity that can be created as the U. S. addresses energy and environmental issues. Warner had a lot of ideas and he delivered the speech with fire and enthusiasm even if one could still see a little of the geek behind the heavy hitter. Unlike the Republicans, the Democrats have a deep bench of credible "presidential" figures behind Barack Obama. Mark Warner is one of them.

Hillary in Her Own League. If Mark Warner's speech was outstanding, Hillary Clinton's was even better. Before getting into what Hillary Clinton said, I thought that her commanding presence on the podium was a strong testament to her leadership ability and the leadership ability of all women. Much of what Hillary Clinton established with her presidential campaign is that women could be more than plausible as candidates for president of the United States. And Hillary continues to represent herself as "presidential timber" even in defeat.

I may be biased because I supported Hillary Clinton up through the Kentucky primary in May, but I agree with everyone who sees her speech as a monster home run. What Hillary needed to do most was to urge her most disappointed supporters to get behind Obama. That hasn't been a problem for me. I've always thought well of Obama despite the fact that I liked Hillary better and Obama outhustled and outfought Hillary during the primaries. He deserved to win. But a large number of Hillary supporters are still doubtful and Hillary directly challenged them directly by asking if they really believed in the issues that Hillary was fighting for. It was the best way for Hillary to appeal to disappointed supporters. Hillary Clinton's views on health care, education, foreign affairs, and veterans are almost exactly the same as Obama's. The best way for her to talk to her supporters was to emphasize what she and Obama shared in this way.

At the end of Hillary's speech, she referred to the first women's rights meeting in Seneca Falls, NY in 1848 and made an extended reference to underground railroad heroine Harriet Tubman and her urging women to "keep going, keep going, keep going." I thought that was an inspired way to bring together the traditions of women and African-Americans striving for opportunity and equality in the United States.

I was inspired by it anyway.

One of the questions tonight is whether Joe Biden is in the same league as Hillary Clinton. I suspect that Biden will do well even if he's not quite at Hillary's level.

Last night, Hillary was in a league with few peers and her husband is not one of them.

Fortunately, Barack Obama is.

Monday, August 25, 2008

The Democratic Convention--Day One

Gotta Love the Democrats--Not so much the politicians, but the everyday Democrats in the convention hall. It's not just the top of the ticket that's diverse. The Democratic convention has been a testament to American diversity since the 70's. White Democrats, Asian-American Democrats, Asian-American Democrats, and Hispanic Democrats could all be seen tonight. Fifty percent of the Democratic delegates are women and a lot of emotion and personality was shown on the faces of female delegates as Teddy Kennedy and Michelle Obama were speaking.

The Democrat Party has never done particularly well by women, African-Americans, Hispanics, and Asian-Americans. For that matter, the Democrats haven't done very well by gays either and it's been awhile since they've done much for labor unions. One of the real disappointments of the Democratic Party is that the leadership has never been strong enough, principled enough, or clever enough to redeem the hopes of all their supporters.

But the willingness of active people from all of these groups to continue supporting the Democrats despite repeated disappointment is a testimony to the resilience of hope among the many groups that continue to be disadvantaged and discriminated against in American society.

All of these folks are a testimony to the human spirit.

Good Atmospherics. I like the design of the platform stage. It's largely a blue stage and backdrop, interspersed with red and pink color columns. It has a sweeping, dramatic kind of effect. There is some Republican commentary that the colors are "pastel" and "weak" compared to the colors of the official flag. I don't find that to be the case. The design strikes me as inspired by internet graphics and has a very kind of bright, optimistic, buoyant effect. It's consistent with Obama's message of America as a nation of hope, promise, and progress. The Republicans tend to view strength in terms of attacking and being under siege. For the Democrats, strength lies in a kind of bounding vitality and it's precisely this vitality that the cameras pick up in the faces of the delegates as they pan the crowd.

A Comment on Speeches. Michelle Obama's speech was by far the best speech that I saw this evening and far outshone Nancy Pelosi and Teddy Kennedy. What's interesting about that to me is that Michelle Obama is still a non-politician despite the fact that she's been on the campaign trail for almost 20 months.

One of the understated themes of the Democratic Party is the extent to which they've become the "family love" party. Once again, there's a big difference between the Democrats and the Republicans. When the Republicans say "family values," they mean a series of "no's"--no abortion, no pre-marital sex, no single mothers, no gay rights, and no to equality between men and women in the household. They might as well call them "frigid family values." To the contrary, the Democrats are all about love, energy, warmth, and nurturing whether its Nancy Pelosi talking about her grandchildren, Teddy Kennedy on his gigantic boat, or the on-stage enthusiasm of Barack Obama's daughter.

The person who was best at this was Michelle Obama. Michelle Obama's enthusiasm and happiness were almost as infectious as that of her seven-year old daughter's. She had a very effective way of grounding herself in motherhood and community while expressing her own aspirations as the aspirations of everyone. Michelle Obama even reached to the famous St. Crispin's Day speech in Shakespeare's Henry V to link all families to the Obama presidential campaign.

Here's Shakespeare:

This day is call'd the feast of Crispian. He that outlives this day, and comes safe home, Will stand a tip-toe when this day is nam'd, And rouse him at the name of Crispian. He that shall live this day, and see old age, Will yearly on the vigil feast his neighbours, And say 'To-morrow is Saint Crispian.' Then will he strip his sleeve and show his scars, And say 'These wounds I had on Crispian's day.' Old men forget; yet all shall be forgot, But he'll remember, with advantages, What feats he did that day.


And Michelle Obama:
And as I tuck that little girl and her little sister into bed at night, I think about how one day, they'll have families of their own. And one day, they - and your sons and daughters - will tell their own children about what we did together in this election. They'll tell them how this time, we listened to our hopes, instead of our fears. How this time, we decided to stop doubting and to start dreaming. How this time, in this great country - where a girl from the South Side of Chicago can go to college and law school, and the son of a single mother from Hawaii can go all the way to the White House - we committed ourselves to building the world as it should be.
Just as Shakespeare portrayed "old men" as showing their wounds and telling the feats they did at Agincourt, Michelle Obama expects young mothers "to tell their own children about what we did together in this election."

It was a great touch.

Unfortunately, Nancy Pelosi and Ted Kennedy did not do nearly as well. Watching Pelosi speak was positively painful and made me wonder whether the Democratic leadership was going to fail at crunch time yet again.

Sunday, August 24, 2008

Should I Trust My Mother-In-Law?

My mother-in-law just got off the phone saying that PBS was saying that McCain was going to announce his VP pick and that it would be Lieberman.

I made a quick internet check and couldn't confirm that, but thought I'd pass it along anyway.

Obama Nominates--Republicans Attack

In what has to be the least surprising event of the 21st century, the McCain campaign launched attack ads as soon as Obama announced that Joe Biden was his choice for VP. The idea was to hurt Obama among Hillary Clinton voters by questioning why Obama didn't choose Hillary.

Conservative media presence William Kristol also has a column out criticizing Obama as having a "glass ceiling" for women.

Of course, if Obama had chosen Hillary Clinton as his VP, the Republicans would have launched attack ads criticizing her as well. Likewise, if he had nominated Kathleen Sebelius of Kansas, Kristol would have called it "the worst form of affirmative action."

It looks like the McCain campaign and the Republicans are turning the presidential election into a "free fire zone" in which they shoot at anything that moves.

But there is also a point when the attack ads start having diminishing returns.

If the McCain campaign attacks everything about Obama, they could find that each bullet hurts a little bit less as the criticism has less and less impact.

In this sense, the main effect of yesterday's attacks on the Biden nomination might have been to lessen the impact of McCain's next round of attack ads.

Saturday, August 23, 2008

Some Biden Advantages

A lot of the commentary about Joe Biden that I've seen since Saturday's announcement of Biden as Obama's VP choice is nonsense that reflects a poor understanding of how American politics works.

Biden No Wise Man. Most importantly, Joe Biden is not going to be Obama's "wise man" on foreign policy in the way that Dick Cheney and Condoleeza Rice have been for Bush. There's a big difference between Obama and Bush. Obama knows a lot about the world and is interested in finding out more. Bush knew nothing and was proud of it.

If Obama is elected, he'll have a Secretary of State, a National Security Adviser, and other foreign policy advisers. Obama might listen to advisers, but my guess is that people will have influence to the extent to which they pose ways to make Obama's own ideas workable. The question about Biden's "influence" will not be how much he knows about foreign policy, but how much he's in sync with Obama's basic instincts. But it isn't likely that Obama and Biden will be in sync. Obama's basic instinct is toward self-control while Biden has trouble with self-discipline. That will make it tough for Biden to be much of an influence.

Biden's "Pennsylvania Roots." Another myth. Biden isn't going to get any more votes for Obama in Pennsylvania because he was born in Scranton (die-hard Republican country by the way) than if he had never seen Pennsylvania. Biden's family moved from Scranton to Delaware in 1952 for godssakes.

The reason that Biden isn't going to help Obama in Pennsylvania is that being from Delaware almost guarantees that he's not going to be any better known in Pennsylvania than anywhere else. Because Delaware borders on the Philadelphia area, news from Delaware can't filter through the enormous clutter of "Philadelphia news" to other regions in Pennsylvania. People in Scranton are much more in tune with New Jersey and Binghamton, NY than they are with Delaware.

Biden's Catholicism. Biden's Catholicism isn't going to help him with Catholic voters any more than John Kerry's did. The reason is that Biden is pro-choice on abortion and that his pro-choice stance will cause controversy which will drown out any sense of Catholic identity. That of course is unless McCain nominates Romney (Mormon) or Lieberman (Jewish). Then, the question of religious identity will be up in the air in unpredictable ways.

The Biden Advantage. But at the end of the day, I think Biden is a plus for Obama. Anything Biden says critically about McCain will be immediately amplified into the public realm through the blogs, cable media, and mainstream media. Given that Biden has a lot of good one-liners about Bush foreign policy, Iraq, and McCain's general recklessness, there's a chance that Biden's comments can dominate several news cycles to the advantage of the Obama campaign. If Obama let's Biden talk, I think Biden will be a 1-3 point plus for the Obama ticket.

Biden has other advantages for Obama as well. In a certain way, selecting Biden makes Obama look "safe" on race. Biden has made some racially inappropriate remarks (calling him "articulate" and "clean") about Obama, but Obama was so little concerned with this kind of petty stereotyping that he was willing to nominate Biden anyway. That's something that could reassure white swing-voters that Obama isn't a "resentful" kind of black person and make them more inclined to vote for him.

Nominating Biden also helps nail down an Obama advantage on maturity. Although Biden himself if not that much of a grown-up, nominating a "heavy hitter" makes Obama look even more like a grown-up. One of the curious things about the presidential campaign is how Barack Obama's almost preternatural maturity and self-control are playing out. It would have taken extremely outsized confidence for Obama to choose Hillary (especially with the Bill problem), but it still took a great deal of confidence for Obama to choose Biden. Given that John McCain is not a particularly mature guy (given his wise guy antics, temper tantrums, etc.), selecting Biden might help Obama open up a maturity gap.

Given that it's a close race, any advantage that Obama can find is significant and Biden helps.

Biden's Effect on McCain

McCain still has to choose a VP nominee. I imagine that McCain will want someone who can project the same foreign policy gravitas as Biden during the VP debate. That should play in Lieberman's favor.

Biden: What a Great Statesman!!!

So, it's Joe Biden after all.

That's excellent.

Over the last ten years, Sen. Joe Biden of Delaware has grown into one of the few statesmen we have in the United States, and he'll provide a striking contrast to the steroid fueled, hot-headed warmongering of John McCain.

Unlike Mitt Romney, Joe Biden is a real human being instead of a Stepford android. That fact alone will make Biden come off better in the VP debate.

Finally, Joe Biden is a fine campaigner who's been winning elections since the early 70's. He has a very clean and articulate way of speaking that will create a great deal of good feeling for Obama out on the stump.

Biden is also a veteran of the television news show circuit and will be a strong surrogate for Obama.

Joe Biden--A great American and a great choice by Obama.

Friday, August 22, 2008

Is It Biden? Where Can I Go to Slit My Wrists?

There's an ABC News report that Secret Service personnel are on their way to start giving protection to Joe Biden as Obama's VP nominee.

I hope it's not true.

Talk about "Old School." Joe Biden's politics is pre-Belushi let alone Will Farrell. Biden's also a free-wheeling bloviator. Actually I think the word was invented with Biden in mind. Anyway, Biden seems to have taken lessons from Bill Clinton on how to say the wrong thing at the wrong time.

As African-American Political Pundit points out, Biden is especially bad on race.

Biden's also one of the super-insecure guys who can't get over the fact that he doesn't have an Ivy League degree even though the University of Delaware is an excellent college.

That got him in trouble back in 1988 when he bragged about being as smart as anyone right before he got caught cribbing from a Neil Kinnock speech.

In other words, Biden wasn't even smart enough to steal from a really good speaker.

Well, tonight I'll do the equivalent of slitting my wrists.

But tomorrow, I'll reboard the Obama bus and start talking about what a statesman Biden has become over the last ten years.

I still hope it's Hillary though.

RSI's Burgeoning Musical Career

A magical moment in RSI's musical career. After Mrs. RSI and I agreed that she would make dinner tonight, she asked if I would play piano while she cooked.

Not bad for an intermediate piano player.

RSI Delusion: Killer Ads for Obama

As someone who writes a lot, I have to admit that there are some delusional elements involved in writing. The biggest delusion is Malcolm Gladwell's fault. After the publication of The Tipping Point, every minor event is portrayed as a critical moment that can result in rearranging the whole structure of American politics, the Middle East, and the world in general. Even writers who haven't read the book now suffer from the delusion that EVERY SINGLE MOMENT IS UNBELIEVABLY IMPORTANT TO THE FATE OF THE UNIVERSE. Like a lot of delusions, the tipping point delusion threatens to kills us as a result of exhaustion.

But there are less tiring delusions as well. Political reporters often suffer from the "consultant delusion" that they can provide politicians advice on how to conduct campaigns. But unless their names are Karl Rove and James Carville, reporters have never been consultants for political campaigns and they don't have any idea of the basics of political campaigning. Most of what reporters seem to do is interview the campaign staff people who protect candidates from reporters. Just as sports writers don't know the basics of their games, political writers don't know anything about developing a message, organizing events, securing endorsements, fundraising, putting together a "ground game," or running an ad campaign. They don't have access to internal polling either.

But that doesn't mean reporters can't do ersatz consulting and they do a lot of it.

Bloggers like myself are even worse. We're under the delusion that we're political journalists even though most of us don't even do any of the background interviewing that "real" journalits do. Despite only having access to secondary or tertiary sources of information, blogs like this one are bursting with advice, commentary, and judgment. Needless to say, it's all very democratic and I often comfort myself with the thought that I do have a Ph.D. in political science from a reputable school (UNC-Chapel Hill). But I also have to admit that much of what I'm writing is speculative at best and that the specter of delusion haunts blogging in general.

But ploughing ahead despite the risk of delusion, I want to offer advice to the Obama campaign on their television ads. Now that the story of McCain's four separate properties with seven houses is out, Obama has a great opportunity to launch some attack ads on McCain's energy policies. One of the things that McCain and the Republicans are recommending is that our country build 45 nuclear power plants. But the power with nuclear power plants has always been where to put them. Given Three Mile Island, Chernobyl, the terrorist threat, and the problems with processing nuclear wastes, nobody but nobody wants a nuclear power plant built anywhere near them.

So, why couldn't the Obama campaign do attack ads at John McCain's various homes asking McCain if he wants a nuclear power plant next to one of Cindy's houses? They could do "man and woman on the street" interviews asking neighbors or actors posing as neighbors whether they want a nuclear power plant nearby. The Obama campaign could even do some sort of Michael Moore schtick with an interviewer searching a neighborhood for anybody who would want a nuclear power plant built in their back yard.

Yes, I know that it's delusional to think that I could give Obama's ad people advice on their ad campaigns.

But there it is.

My Gut Says Clinton

Yesterday, I was talking with a student about Obama's vp pick when it hit me that all the secrecy might mean that the pick will be Hillary Clinton. The idea is that if Obama were going to pick Kaine, Sebelius, or Bayh, his campaign would have leaked more information about the pick as a way to increase their national name recognition.

My gut says Hillary.

But my gut has been known to be wrong.

Thursday, August 21, 2008

Obama v McCain: Is the Slime War Coming?

The election fight between John McCain and Barack Obama is getting hot and it looks like both candidates are preparing for a two-month "slime war" leading up the election.

Let the slime begin.

After Obama's poorly received showing at the Saddleback Forum, the Obama campaign decided to get tough and came out with ads portraying John McCain as an out of touch plutocrat who doesn't know how many houses he owns. The Obama campaign could mine McCain's wealth for these kinds of attack ads from here to November. It's bad enough that McCain married into Cindy McCain's family wealth rather than earning any of it himself. But McCain also dumped his injured and disfigured first wife to hook up with Cindy's money in the first place.

Talk about personal dishonor. All of this not only makes John McCain look not only like an out of touch plutocrat but a pampered sleazeball as well.

Now that McCain's running as the candidate of the Republican establishment, Obama could attack him more for his connections with Bush, Cheney, Rove, Charlie Black, Rush Limbaugh, and the rest of the incompetent warmongerers. Today, Obama had an ad out in the Atlanta market slamming McCain for his links to Jack Abramoff friend Ralph Reed. Obama's people could literally put out hundreds of ads on that score.

But the McCain people aren't going to be outdone on attack ads. When are the Republicans ever outdone on personal attacks?

The McCain campaign responded quickly with their own ads about Obama connections with 60's radical William Ayres and Chicago real estate scammer Tony Rezko. In fact, the McCain campaign seemed to be waiting for just this opportunity to "go nuclear" on Obama. With Obama now engaging in "personal attacks," the McCain people feel authorized to start hammering away on Jeremiah Wright, Ayres, Rezko, and any other shady connections they can dredge up.

It'll be interesting to see how the looming slime war plays out. My impression is that Obama has the advantage. If one adds up the personal liabilities, McCain liabilities far outweigh Obama's. Given that Cindy McCain is his wife and that John McCain has benefitted enormously from her wealth, the problems with McCain's status as a pampered sleazeball have more significance than Obama's problems with black nationalist minister Jeremiah Wright.

The same thing concerns McCain's connections with the Republican establishment vs Obama's connections with William Ayres and Tony Rezko. Abramoff, Reed, Black, Limbaugh, Rove, and the rest of the figures Obama could attack are all nationally-known figures who play or have played significant roles in Republican Party politics and John McCain's campaign. Because the same can't be said for Ayres and Rezko, it will be much easier for Obama to score points than McCain.

But is Obama going to sustain several rounds of attacks on McCain? The McCain people have already drawn the line in the sand. Given that Obama has attacked McCain, McCain is now going to go all out on attacking Obama and will be daring Obama to respond in kind.

That way McCain will be able to criticize Obama for being "weak" if he doesn't respond with more attacks on McCain and criticize Obama for giving up his "new politics" if he does respond.

In my opinion, Obama has to dive into "the slime war" and attack McCain with all the moderate, post-partisan gusto he can muster.

There's lots of testimony showing that voters don't like "negative campaigning" and "politics as usual." But voters are even suspicious of candidates they view as "weak" and Obama would be perceived as a weak politician if he decides to back down.

Given that such a widespread perception of weakness would kill his candidacy, Obama needs to ratchet up his attacks on McCain.

Once you start attacking, you can't stop.

Wednesday, August 20, 2008

The RSI Perspective on VP's

Clueless on Obama. I have to own up to the fact that I don't have much of an idea concerning Obama's VP selection and don't have much of an idea of how he's thinking about the issue either.

Sebelius, Biden, Tom Kaine, Evan Bayh--they've all objectionable. Sebelius, Kaine, and Bayh are all relatively non-partisan moderates. Outside Sebelius being a female candidate, who's going to get excited about any of them.

As for Biden, talk about the politics of the past! Biden peaked in 1988. Maybe Biden would be better than the faceless moderates, but that's not saying much.

As a "moderate with a face," Obama obviously is not thinking of other moderates as "faceless."

So I'm clueless.

But I'm hardly alone in my cluelessness.

McCain and the Lieberman Factor. It's easier with McCain. I'm quite certain that John McCain wants Joe Lieberman to be his vice-presidential candidate and is deciding whether he's willing to take the Republican Party blowback from nominating Lieberman. If McCain decides that he can get away with nominating Lieberman, I think it will be Lieberman. If McCain decides to go with a conventional Republican, it will probably be Tim Pawlenty. I can see Mitt Romney as having a chance as well.

But it's all about Lieberman now.

Loose Change for Hummer

China's Hunan Changfeng Motor backed out of any effort to buy GM's Hummer division. For some reason, they saw "limited potential" to market the gas guzzling monstrosity.

MSN claims that Hummer is worth $1.5 billion on the open market, but author Kim Peterson neglects to add that it would only be worth 1.5 bill to companies that want to lose a lot of money.

There's about 95 cents in loose change in my pocket. That's about what I'd pay for the whole Hummer operation.

And I'd probably still lose money.

Otis Hensley: Where Did All the Fun Go?

Otis Hensley Jr sits in a jail cell in Harlan, KY, imprisoned for the crime of being a jerk.

At least that's Hensley's side of the story.

Hensley was shopping at Don's Supersaver when he encountered a grandmother and two girls, ages 11 and 13.

According to Hensley, "one of the girls turned around and looked at me and smiled."

Then, Hensley responded by saying to the grandmother: "Maam, do you want to trade them girls for a good fattening hog?"

Hey, what a cut-up! Great sense of humor! Nothing funnier than trading a couple of girls for a very large pig. They do it all the time in foreign countries don't they?

Hensley claims he had already pulled that joke at the bank that day--and nobody objected.

But the grandmother did object and she went the girls' father who objected even more and Hensley ended up sitting in jail charged with "first-degree unlawful transaction with a minor, a Class B felony that can carry a sentence of 10 years to 20 years."

Ouch!

I imagine the grandmother has a different story.

But even on Hensley's account, the world isn't quite as tolerant of treating girls as the equivalent of pigs, cattle, and chickens anymore.

And that's a good thing.

Tuesday, August 19, 2008

Fretting About Obama

There was a lot of fretting about Obama over at liberal news blog Talking Points Memo (TPM) today. Editor Josh Marshall thinks that Obama's basic message of "change" and "hope" has been diluted or is otherwise not having the impact it used to have. He wants Obama to have a simple message that can be boiled down to one sentence. Of course, Obama had already boiled everything down to two words once--hope and change. However, Marshall thinks that Obama needs another memorable and simplistic formula.

Others worry that Obama has not done anything to define McCain and would like to see Obama portray McCain as an "out of touch plutocrat," a "dangerous warmonger," or the kind of person who would "say anything to be president."

The fact that McCain is all three of these things should help.

I'm fretting about Obama as well, but the bottom line is that Obama is being himself. Obama has always talked about the need for an uplifting "new politics" that gets away from the intense partisanship of the left and right. And like or not, Obama is getting away from many of the basic modes of partisan politics. Obama is not making a determined effort to define McCain with negative ads and he's discouraging third-party ads attacking McCain. Likewise, Obama's not employing aggressive surrogates to either attack McCain or defend himself. He's not really associating himself very closely with Democratic constituencies like African-Americans, Hispanics, white progressives, unions, or gay rights activists.

Instead of promoting divisions, Obama's promoting a "One America" politics of unity and he's doing so primarily through grass-roots organizing for his campaign. I was very sceptical of this kind of "post-partisan" politics during the primaries and that's why I supported Hillary Clinton.

But it's a little late to be sceptical now.

Obama is the Democratic Party's nominee and he is the only hope to keep John McCain and the Republican Party out of the presidency for the next four years.

Instead of fretting, people on the left should be pitching in to participate in Obama's grassroots campaigning and promote the virtues of Obama's approach to politics.

And hope to hell it works.

Thomas Sowell Understands McCain

Conservative columnist Thomas Sowell says that American foreign policy is to "speak loudly and carry a little stick." Actually, that's pretty close to John McCain's policy on Georgia which is to "speak as loudly as possible without carrying a stick at all."

Monday, August 18, 2008

GOP's Low Standards for McCain

GOP spinmeisters are humping the heck out of how great John McCain did at the Saddleback forum on Saturday night. Actually, I also think McCain did well because he hit his usual talking points and stump anecdotes in an effective manner.

But it's not like hitting your talking points is THAT big of a deal for a candidate like John McCain who's been running for president for the last twenty months.

But here's National Review editor Rich Lowry salivating in the New York Sun:
Within the first 15 minutes, McCain had established a moral seriousness stemming from his long experience as a national leader and his conduct in Vietnam as a POW that Obama simply couldn't match. Throughout the night, McCain brought up Iraq, al Qaeda and the Georgia crisis, while Obama was determinedly inward-looking. Asked whether he thinks evil exists, Obama cited Darfur, then street crime in the United States. McCain invoked Osama bin Laden.
Lowry's comments are fundamentally a reflection of the low standards that the right has for presidents. In the 2000 and 2004 campaigns, George Bush was given considerable credit for "beating expectations" any time he got his facts straight and worked his way though his talking points. The media liked Bush even though they didn't think he was knowledgeable and gave him points for showing almost any kind of knowledge.

The same was the case here.

The idea behind the Saddleback forum was for the religious public to get a better idea of how Barack Obama and John McCain what kind of persons they were apart from their talking points and how they thought about issues. That's a lot of what Obama did. He talked about himself as a person, his religious faith, his big controversial decisions, and his weaknesses as a human being. People who listened to Obama came away with a better idea of Obama's capacity for dispassionate evaluation of himself, the people around him, and various kinds of issues. They also came away with a sense of the kind of president he would be.

But McCain changed the game and used the Saddleback forum as a way to present his standard talking points and anecdotes to a national audience. Unless McCain has morphed into a version of his talking points, he didn't give any indication of what kind of person he is or how he thinks about any kinds of issues. McCain toed the conservative party line on every point and expressed no self-doubt about doing so even though he has recently changed his positions on a variety of issues like Bush's tax cuts and immigration.

For a conservative like Rich Lowry, stating the right-wing party line is the most important qualification that anyone could have for president.

But its a very low standard.

To the contrary, Obama showed himself as a whole person rather than an extension of his talking points. That's what gives Obama a chance to serve effectively as president of the whole country instead of just being president of his party.

The Introspective Basis of the McCain Campaign

It's beginning to look more and more like the McCain campaign is using introspection as the basis for the criticisms of Barack Obama.

For example, the McCain campaign knew they were getting into racist territory when they put out their provocative "Celeb" ad with Obama juxtaposed to Paris Hilton and Britney Spears. Of course, it didn't bother them much. Republicans have been running race-baiting presidential campaigns since the 1960's.

What differentiates the McCain campaign is that they decided that they would gain a further advantage from Republican traditions of race-baiting by accusing Obama of being the one to play"the race card." But senior McCain staffers like Rick Davis and Steve Schmidt couldn't have pursued the "race-card" theme is they hadn't been aware of their own race-baiting.

There's also the celebrity angle.

There's no politician in American who loves being a celebrity more than John McCain. He's appeared on Saturday Night Live and late-night talk shows as well as cable comedy shows. McCain was also a regular on shout-fests like like Crossfire and appeared more than any other politician on Sunday morning news shows like "Meet the Press."

One of the main reasons why the McCain campaign has ridiculed Obama for being the "no. 1 global celebrity" with so much relish is McCain's awareness of the extent to which he himself values being a celebrity.

In other words, McCain's criticism of Obama for being a celebrity was born out of introspection.

Today, McCain moved on to Obama's foreign policy positions. John McCain has shown a willingness to say almost anything to reassure the conservative base of the Republican Party that he's one of them. Among the many topics on which McCain has reversed himself are Bush tax cuts, the "agents of intolerance" in the religious right, right-wing judges like Samuel Alito, immigration policy, torture, and off-shore drilling.

No doubt McCain's going to change more of his positions as the election campaign becomes more heated.

Given the burning intensity of McCain's ambition, it should be no surprise that McCain is accusing Obama of adopting positions solely to further his presidential ambitions. Speaking about Obama's position on Iraq, McCain claims that:
“Behind all of these claims and positions by Senator Obama lies the ambition to be president . . . What’s less apparent is the judgment to be commander in chief. And in matters of national security, good judgment will be at a premium in the term of the next president.

McCain was criticizing Obama's vote against war funding in 2007. But Obama had opposed the invasion of Iraq from the beginning. Thus, his vote against war funding was perfectly consistent with his views of the war.

When McCain talks about "ambition to be president" as driving Obama's positions on policy issues, he's really talking about himself and projecting onto Obama.

However, if McCain looks at himself closely enough, he'll find that his criticisms of Obama are an extremely good guide to why John McCain himself should not be president.

Sunday, August 17, 2008

McCain's Version of the "Winona Ryder Defense"

You know, I was willing to give John McCain a break on the accusations that he knew Rick Warren's questions in advance for Saturday night's Saddleback Forum.

My though was so what if McCain heard some of Obama's answers while he was in his limo on the way to the event? Warren informed both Obama and McCain of his first two questions. McCain probably already knew what his first two responses would be anyway.

But then, I saw the reaction of McCain's spokeswoman Nicole Wallace.

“The insinuation from the Obama campaign that John McCain, a former prisoner of
war, cheated is outrageous.”
Talk about projecting guilt.

That's the POW version of Winona Ryder's defense at her shoplifting trial in 2002. According to Dahlia Lithwick of Slate:

Both the crime and the trial were about looking like a celebrity. The movie star had already dropped $3,000 that day on clothing and accessories, yet still shoplifted a $140 hair band and a $750 thermal shirt (because God knows, she couldn't go pay $16 for them at Target). So her attorney trotted out the people-who-look-like-her-don't-take-stuff defense (emphasis mine), alternating it with the people-who-don't-look-like-her-persecute-people-who-look-like-her-because-they're-jealous defense.

Like Winona Ryder, Wallace was arguing that John McCain didn't cheat because "people like John McCain don't cheat."

That sounds like a confession of guilt to me.

Saddleback: Advantage McCain and His Tribe

A Sense of Relief. Well, I'm certainly glad the Saddleback Civil Forum is over. Wheew!

That's partly because I'm an atheist. In principle, I'm all for holding political events in mega-churches, sports stadiums, the Convention Center in my hometown of Morehead, KY, local diners, television studios, Vegas casinos or any other place where people legally gather. In a democracy, politics needs to be in the places where people gather. Given that people gather in churches, why not churches?

But I also find almost any religious atmosphere to be kind of creepy. So I'm glad that major political events like debates aren't often held in places of worship.

Or casinos for that matter.

I'm also glad the forum is over because I thought John McCain came out ahead.

Why McCain Won. McCain had a simple formula for promoting himself as "the Republican candidate"--take the "conservative" line on every point, get out as many of his conservative talking points as he could, and relate anecdotes designed to make conservative talking points appealing to everyone.

Chuck Todd of NBC correctly emphasizes the extent to which McCain focused on getting out his talking points as opposed to answering Rick Warren's questions. When asked about three wise people he would listen to, McCain listed the conservative hero of the moment Gen. Petraeus as no. 1. When asked about when people acquired rights, McCain said "at conception" without hesitation and didn't bother to explain why. McCain was just as emphatic about wishing that none of the Supreme Court liberals were on the Supreme Court and gave the straight conservative line on "legislating from the bench" to explain why.

McCain also used his stories about being prisoner of war to significant effect in explaining himself as a person and illustrating conservative talking points.

Why was this effective? It was effective primarily because McCain was offering a cohesive conservative world view that he knew a large part of his audience would embrace. Peggy Noonan regrets that McCain and Obama moved around a lot as children and are consequently not grounded in regions. But, the impact of Limbaugh, Hannity, and Ann Coulter has been that conservatives identify themselves more and more as a national movement and less and less as having a Southern, Mountain, rural, or suburban perspective.

Conservative tribalism is a national phenomenon and John McCain was representing the whole conservative tribe in his performance at Saddleback. McCain didn't perform as an individual, he performed as a "conservative."

And he performed conservatism about as well as it can be done.

The Problem with Obama. It's not that Obama performed poorly. Obama was thoughtful and articulate and I'm sure many people in the mega-church audience left with a better appreciation for Obama's intelligence and sincerity. I know I came out of my viewing of the video liking Obama better as a person.

But for all of his intellectual architecture, Barack Obama's answers to Rick Warren's questions were essentially bridges "from nowhere and "to nowhere."

Let me illustrate with the question of abortion. When Obama first was asked about abortion, his response was that abortion was a "serious moral question." I have no problem with nodding to the sincerity of the pro-life position, but Obama also never explained why he took the pro-choice position that abortion is a fundamental matter of a woman's freedom. In fact, he did not articulate a single reason why anybody would be pro-choice or why anybody would think that the right to seek abortions is a fundamental human freedom as articulated in Roe v Wade.

This was a tremendous failing on Obama's part. Because Obama failed to champion his own views about abortion, Obama's response did not have the moral or political clarity of McCain's position and Obama failed to represent the moral integrity of the millions of Americans (like me) who have taken the pro-choice position, the millions of women who have received abortions, and the tens of thousands (at least) of medical personnel who have been involved in performing abortions.

By failing to champion the pro-choice position, Obama also did nothing to make his pro-choice position more appealing to anybody who is an undecided voter.

The same was the case when Obama explained how his decided to oppose the invasion of Iraq despite the fact that he thought it would hurt him politically. He did nothing beyond mentioning his suspicions about WMD to indicate why he opposed the invasion, why he still opposes the invasion, and why he thinks the invasion has been a disaster.

Why Obama decided not to advocate his own positions is "beyond my pay grade" as Obama would say. But Obama failed to represent his own position, failed to represent the "liberal tribe" across America, and failed to convince anyone outside the liberal tribe about the validity of his positions.

At the end of Obama's hour on stage, about all anyone could say about him was that he was a "smart, articulate guy."

That's not enough and it's not nearly as much as John McCain accomplished.

Conclusion. It's been known for some time that Obama is less effective in debate and townhall forums than he should be. One of the reasons why I thought he should take up McCain's challenge to do 10 townhall debates is that I thought Obama would get better at them as he moved along. At this point, Obama needs to improve his "debating" performance dramatically without the benefit of much practice. And he needs it pretty badly.