Wednesday, November 05, 2008
Tuesday, November 04, 2008
The Almost Final Electoral College Look
It looks like Obama might take North Carolina, Indiana, and Missouri. He's ahead in North Carolina and Indiana and only behind by one point in Missouri. If memory serves me right, the last area to report in Missouri is St. Louis where Obama could be expected to rack big majorities.
If Obama wins all four states, he would have 365 electoral votes to 156 for McCain.
Some notes:
1. No Social Conservatism here. If Obama wins Montana, that will be the only big surprise for a state win. But Obama's margins in Pennsylvania, New Hampshire, and New Mexico exceeded expectations. Pennsylvania is a special case with an 11 point Obama win. Obama rolled up more than a 450,000 vote margin in Philadelphia while also winning all of the inner ring of suburban Bucks, Chester, and Montgomery counties and most all of the second ring as well.
One has to wonder if McCain and Palin spending all that time in rural Pennsylvania actually hurt them by stimulating opposition in the metro areas.
2. Down to their last safe state. The Republicans only have one safe haven and one tossup on the Atlantic seaboard, with Georgia as the toss-up and South Carolina as the lonely Republican haven. The Republicans are in danger of becoming slipping from a regional party to a subregional party of part of the Old South, the Great Plains, and the more isolated Mountain States.
If Obama wins all four states, he would have 365 electoral votes to 156 for McCain.
Some notes:
1. No Social Conservatism here. If Obama wins Montana, that will be the only big surprise for a state win. But Obama's margins in Pennsylvania, New Hampshire, and New Mexico exceeded expectations. Pennsylvania is a special case with an 11 point Obama win. Obama rolled up more than a 450,000 vote margin in Philadelphia while also winning all of the inner ring of suburban Bucks, Chester, and Montgomery counties and most all of the second ring as well.
One has to wonder if McCain and Palin spending all that time in rural Pennsylvania actually hurt them by stimulating opposition in the metro areas.
2. Down to their last safe state. The Republicans only have one safe haven and one tossup on the Atlantic seaboard, with Georgia as the toss-up and South Carolina as the lonely Republican haven. The Republicans are in danger of becoming slipping from a regional party to a subregional party of part of the Old South, the Great Plains, and the more isolated Mountain States.
3. The Next Ultimate Journey. The Holy Grail of the Democratic Party used to be Florida. With Florida at least temporarily conquered, the target for Democratic aspirations will shift to Texas. The Republicans need to rethink.
Crude Emotional Reaction
Holy Shit! I saw it in the numbers. The electoral vote total is going to be in my range. But I couldn't believe Obama would win until Obama actually won. And I still don't believe it.
Live--Blogging 3, It's Over
CNN is projecting Obama as winning Ohio.
Now, Rudy Giuliani is on Fox saying "it ain't over till it's over."'
But it's over.
Now, Rudy Giuliani is on Fox saying "it ain't over till it's over."'
But it's over.
Live-Blogging--No. 2
CNN calls Senate races for Jeanne Shaheen in New Hampshire and Tom Udall in New Mexico. It's been called for Susan Collins from Maine as well. I was a year behind Collins at St. Lawrence during the early 70's.
Wolf Blitzer is back on the air and Obama has clinched 174 electoral votes to 49 for McCain.
But William Schneider is reminding me of why I don't miss television.
He's asking a question about the impact of race on the election but what he's saying would be a lot more significant if he had broken down "racial attitudes" by race.
The students sitting next to me start having a conversation about race. The consensus is that electing Obama will bring an early surge of white racism but that it would peter out.
Wolf Blitzer is back on the air and Obama has clinched 174 electoral votes to 49 for McCain.
But William Schneider is reminding me of why I don't miss television.
He's asking a question about the impact of race on the election but what he's saying would be a lot more significant if he had broken down "racial attitudes" by race.
The students sitting next to me start having a conversation about race. The consensus is that electing Obama will bring an early surge of white racism but that it would peter out.
Live-Blogging Election Night
I'm back on the Morehead State Campus where one of my colleagues has set up a multi-screen set-up for Election Watch.
Very Cool!
My first stop was at the campaign headquarters of my brother-in-law Tom Carew who was running for a city council seat in Morehead. Tom Carew is a very responsible and well-respected citizen in Eastern Kentucky. He won easily.
Bringing myself up to date:
Rocky Mountain High, Pennsylvania. Among the contested states, Obama has been declared the winner in Pennsylvania and New Hampshire. With Obama winning in Pennsylvania, things get tough for McCain and that's why the crowd in Grants Park in Chicago is so loud. If McCain wants to win, he is going to have to get Colorado as well as all the toss-up states in order to win.
Personally, I don't see that.
If the rest of the election goes to form, Obama has already won.
Now we need to see if the rest of the election goes to form.
Very Cool!
My first stop was at the campaign headquarters of my brother-in-law Tom Carew who was running for a city council seat in Morehead. Tom Carew is a very responsible and well-respected citizen in Eastern Kentucky. He won easily.
Bringing myself up to date:
Rocky Mountain High, Pennsylvania. Among the contested states, Obama has been declared the winner in Pennsylvania and New Hampshire. With Obama winning in Pennsylvania, things get tough for McCain and that's why the crowd in Grants Park in Chicago is so loud. If McCain wants to win, he is going to have to get Colorado as well as all the toss-up states in order to win.
Personally, I don't see that.
If the rest of the election goes to form, Obama has already won.
Now we need to see if the rest of the election goes to form.
Notes on a Potentially Breaking Wave
Some final thoughts as I wait for voting results to come in:
The Pennsylvania Tease. Pennsylvania has become somewhat of a holy grail for Republican presidential candidates. McCain put a lot of time and resources into Pennsylvania and there's been a lot of commentary about how desperately he needed the Keystone State after losing Iowa, Colorado, and New Mexico. But Bush also put considerable energy into Pennsylvania. The Republicans are constantly tempted by the Republican "T" that surrounds Philly and Pittsburgh with put a lot of conservatives and evangelicals. They'd also like to keep some beachhead in a Northeast that seems to be falling permanently out of their grasp. But the problem for the Republicans is that their social conservatism kills them in the Philly suburbs and Sarah Palin is a constant reminder of the GOP's social conservatism. Bush lost Pennsylvania by four in 2000 and two in 2004. McCain might fall even father behind this time.
Repudiating Rove? This election initially looked like a repudiation of Karl Rove's strategy of maximizing the party base and ignoring independents. But it didn't work out that way as neither candidate made the classic move from "primary partisanship" to "general election moderation" designed to appeal to moderate voters. The dynamic factor here was McCain. He never let up in his efforts to mobilize the Republican Party's conservative base and even brought out Dick Cheney as his campaign closer. But even more importantly, McCain moved Obama away from moderation by mocking him as an empty celebrity. By the time the conventions got started, Obama was just as much a partisan Democrat as Teddy Kennedy or Bill Clinton. If Obama wins as expected, it will be a result of the appeal of the progressive partisanship rather than the "One America" rhetoric he started with in 2007.
No Longer A Center-Right Nation? Charles Krauthammer, Newsweek, and just about anybody doesn't have a DailyKos diary is now reminding Barack Obama that the United States is a "center-right country" that doesn't like the "liberal agenda." Here's Krauthammer:
But Krauthammer might have a surprise coming. It's not just the Bush administration and the Republican Party that's being repudiated. The American public might be pushing the reject button on social and religious conservatism, hyper-aggressive neo-conservative foreign policy, anti-immigrant sentiment, and the heightened concentration of wealth. The broader public is getting fed up with talk radio and Fox as well. Rush Limbaugh is smart enough to know that moderates hate him, but the conservative establishment have yet to catch up with the fact that the American public is rejecting the conservative movement as well as the Republican Party. My own perception breaks down by race. The broader white public is ready to support progressive policies if it looks like they're going to work. Everybody else is willing to live with Obama's mistakes.
The Pennsylvania Tease. Pennsylvania has become somewhat of a holy grail for Republican presidential candidates. McCain put a lot of time and resources into Pennsylvania and there's been a lot of commentary about how desperately he needed the Keystone State after losing Iowa, Colorado, and New Mexico. But Bush also put considerable energy into Pennsylvania. The Republicans are constantly tempted by the Republican "T" that surrounds Philly and Pittsburgh with put a lot of conservatives and evangelicals. They'd also like to keep some beachhead in a Northeast that seems to be falling permanently out of their grasp. But the problem for the Republicans is that their social conservatism kills them in the Philly suburbs and Sarah Palin is a constant reminder of the GOP's social conservatism. Bush lost Pennsylvania by four in 2000 and two in 2004. McCain might fall even father behind this time.
Repudiating Rove? This election initially looked like a repudiation of Karl Rove's strategy of maximizing the party base and ignoring independents. But it didn't work out that way as neither candidate made the classic move from "primary partisanship" to "general election moderation" designed to appeal to moderate voters. The dynamic factor here was McCain. He never let up in his efforts to mobilize the Republican Party's conservative base and even brought out Dick Cheney as his campaign closer. But even more importantly, McCain moved Obama away from moderation by mocking him as an empty celebrity. By the time the conventions got started, Obama was just as much a partisan Democrat as Teddy Kennedy or Bill Clinton. If Obama wins as expected, it will be a result of the appeal of the progressive partisanship rather than the "One America" rhetoric he started with in 2007.
No Longer A Center-Right Nation? Charles Krauthammer, Newsweek, and just about anybody doesn't have a DailyKos diary is now reminding Barack Obama that the United States is a "center-right country" that doesn't like the "liberal agenda." Here's Krauthammer:
McCain is the quintessential center-right candidate. Yet the quintessential center-right country is poised to reject him. The hunger for anti-Republican catharsis and the blinding promise of Obamian hope are simply too strong. The reckoning comes in the morning.
But Krauthammer might have a surprise coming. It's not just the Bush administration and the Republican Party that's being repudiated. The American public might be pushing the reject button on social and religious conservatism, hyper-aggressive neo-conservative foreign policy, anti-immigrant sentiment, and the heightened concentration of wealth. The broader public is getting fed up with talk radio and Fox as well. Rush Limbaugh is smart enough to know that moderates hate him, but the conservative establishment have yet to catch up with the fact that the American public is rejecting the conservative movement as well as the Republican Party. My own perception breaks down by race. The broader white public is ready to support progressive policies if it looks like they're going to work. Everybody else is willing to live with Obama's mistakes.
Wimpy Conspiracies
The "fluff right" blog Protein Wisdom is pushing the "William Ayers wrote Obama's book" sham. What a wimpy little conspiracy theory! Back when the right-wing had guts, they accused Bill Clinton of murdering half the population of Arkansas.
TODAY'S THE DAY--VOTE FOR OBAMA
I'm so excited about today I couldn't sleep past 6:30am even though I have today off. It's still Obama by 6-8 points. Yesterday was a big plus day for Obama in the polls. Everything looks good.
Monday, November 03, 2008
Vote Suppression as a Civil Rights Crime
If the polling bears out and Barack Obama is elected president tomorrow, he's going to have to deal with a large number of "legacy issues," including the two wars in Afghanistan and Iraq, the financial meltdown, Guantanamo, the military tribunals, the extraordinary rendition program, health care reform, and climate change.
One legacy issue that hasn't caught the media's attention is "vote suppression"--the efforts of Republican officials to intimidate grass-roots vote registration efforts, develop schemes to lower voting rates among poor people, and scare people in minority communities away from voting.
It should be illegal.
Voting is a fundamental right in American society--as much a cornerstone of democracy as the right to freedom of speech, freedom of religion, and freedom of assembly.
At its root, vote suppression is the attempt to intimidate, coerce, or otherwise prevent American citizens from exercising that fundamental right.
As a result, all forms of vote suppression should be outlawed.
It should be a felony to engage in any behavior designed to intimidate, coerce, or otherwise prevent eligible voters from exercising their right to vote. That includes seeking to scare people away from voting, engaging in registration purges with the intent of eliminating eligible (as well as ineligible voters), or excluding people who have moved recently, lost their homes, or are homeless from voting. It should also include the various efforts by election officials to limit participation.
Vote suppression has become "politics as usual" for the Republican Party. Thus, it could be argued that making vote suppression illegal would be a form of "criminalizing politics."
So be it.
Republican vote suppression is an attempt to prevent people from exercising their fundamental rights as Americans.
It should be a crime.
One legacy issue that hasn't caught the media's attention is "vote suppression"--the efforts of Republican officials to intimidate grass-roots vote registration efforts, develop schemes to lower voting rates among poor people, and scare people in minority communities away from voting.
It should be illegal.
Voting is a fundamental right in American society--as much a cornerstone of democracy as the right to freedom of speech, freedom of religion, and freedom of assembly.
At its root, vote suppression is the attempt to intimidate, coerce, or otherwise prevent American citizens from exercising that fundamental right.
As a result, all forms of vote suppression should be outlawed.
It should be a felony to engage in any behavior designed to intimidate, coerce, or otherwise prevent eligible voters from exercising their right to vote. That includes seeking to scare people away from voting, engaging in registration purges with the intent of eliminating eligible (as well as ineligible voters), or excluding people who have moved recently, lost their homes, or are homeless from voting. It should also include the various efforts by election officials to limit participation.
Vote suppression has become "politics as usual" for the Republican Party. Thus, it could be argued that making vote suppression illegal would be a form of "criminalizing politics."
So be it.
Republican vote suppression is an attempt to prevent people from exercising their fundamental rights as Americans.
It should be a crime.
I Sure Hope Rove is Right!

Who would have thought I would agree with a moral cesspool like Karl Rove. But Rove's final election map is pretty much what the 52-46 I expect for Obama victory is going to look like. The only difference is that I would have left Indiana and Missouri as toss-ups. But that's splitting hairs and there's something to be said for choosing anyway.
Some final thoughts as I wait for voting results to come in:
The Pennsylvania Tease. Pennsylvania has become somewhat of a holy grail for Republican presidential candidates. McCain put a lot of time and resources into Pennsylvania and there's been a lot of commentary about how desperately he needed the Keystone State after losing Iowa, Colorado, and New Mexico. But Bush also put considerable energy into Pennsylvania. The Republicans are constantly tempted by the Republican "T" that surrounds Philly and Pittsburgh with put a lot of conservatives and evangelicals. They'd also like to keep some beachhead in a Northeast that seems to be falling permanently out of their grasp. But the problem for the Republicans is that their social conservatism kills them in the Philly suburbs and Sarah Palin is a
constant reminder of the GOP's social conservatism. Bush lost Pennsylvania by four in 2000 and two in 2004. McCain might fall even father behind this time.
Repudiating Rove? This election initially looked like a repudiation of Karl Rove's strategy of maximizing the party base and ignoring independents. But it didn't work out that way as neither candidate made the classic move from "primary partisanship" to "general election moderation" designed to appeal to moderate voters. The dynamic factor here was McCain. He never let up in his efforts to mobilize the party base and even brought out Dick Cheney as his campaign closer. Even more importantly, McCain moved Obama away from moderation by mocking him as an empty celebrity. By the time the conventions got started, Obama was just as much a partisan Democrat as Teddy Kennedy or Bill Clinton. If Obama wins as expected, it will be a result of the appeal of the progressive partisanship rather than the "One America" rhetoric he started with in 2007.
No Longer A Center-Right Nation? Charles Krauthammer, Newsweek, and just about anybody doesn't have a DailyKos diary is now reminding Barack Obama that the United States is a "center-right country" that doesn't like the "liberal agenda."
Here's Krauthammer:
McCain is the quintessential center-right candidate. Yet the quintessential center-right country is poised to reject him. The hunger for anti-Republican catharsis and the blinding promise of Obamian hope are simply too strong. The reckoning comes in the morning.
But Krauthammer might have a surprise coming. It's not just the Bush administration and the Republican Party that's being repudiated. The American public might be pushing the reject button on social and religious conservatism, hyper-aggressive neo-conservative foreign policy, anti-immigrant sentiment, and the heightened concentration of wealth. The broader public is getting fed up with talk radio and Fox as well. Rush Limbaugh is smart enough to know that moderates hate him, but the conservative establishment have yet to catch up with the fact that the American public is rejecting the conservative movement as well as the Republican Party.
My own perception is that the broader white public is ready to support progressive policies if it looks like they're going to work. Everybody else is willing to live with their mistakes.
The First Four Polls of the Day
Twenty-four hours to go. TWENTY-FOUR HOURS TO GO!! This morning's first four polls were good for Obama. Gallup had him up by 11, NBC by 8, Zogby by 7, and Research 2000 by 6.
There's a little bit of worry in the Research 2000 tracking poll which has only had Obama up by 4 for the last two nights. That's within the margin of error.
But I've still made my last campaign contribution.
There's a little bit of worry in the Research 2000 tracking poll which has only had Obama up by 4 for the last two nights. That's within the margin of error.
But I've still made my last campaign contribution.
MoveOn.Org SCANDAL!
Yes, that's right. SCANDAL. When Mrs. RSI woke up this morning, she had a message from MoveOn.org in her mailbox asking her if she was "NERVOUS" and to contribute $25 if she was. Of course, she's nervous! Who wouldn't be nervous if they were faced with the prospect of John McCain becoming President of the United States after this campaign? But using that nervousness as a fund-raising gimmick is shear EXPLOITATION and MoveOn.org should be ashamed.
Fortunately, Mrs. RSI resisted the urge the send more of her hard-earned pension to those blood-suckers.
Update: Oh, I forgot to mention that RSI sent $25 in last-minute cash to the Obama campaign. It seems they needed more money.
Fortunately, Mrs. RSI resisted the urge the send more of her hard-earned pension to those blood-suckers.
Update: Oh, I forgot to mention that RSI sent $25 in last-minute cash to the Obama campaign. It seems they needed more money.
Sunday, November 02, 2008
RSI Waffles: Now It's Obama by 6

It turns out that RSI is a nervous, insecure kind of person after all. Who would have known? On Oct. 24, I thought Obama would win by either 6 or 8 points and came down on the side of 8. After a week of waffling, I still see Obama as winning by 6-8 points but now come down on the side of 6.
Now it's Obama--52, McCain--46 and give me my nerve pills.
That's how the Pew polling organization views it as well. Of course, Pew had Obama by 15 in their previous poll. So, they might not be the most reliable people in the world this time around.
Nate Silver's statistical model at FiveThirtyEight.com has gradually come down from Obama by 8 to Obama by 5.4.
The above map from Electoral-vote.com pretty much captures what I see with Obama winning at 52-46. Among the currently contested states, Obama captures Pennsylvania, Ohio, Florida, and Virginia while McCain wins Arizona, Montana, and North Dakota. The only difference is that I believe McCain would also win North Carolina and that Indiana and Missouri would still be toss-ups.
That would put the electoral college at Obama--338, McCain--178 and toss-ups--22. That's a big Obama win and gives him a pretty decent mandate given that the Democrats are going to increase their majorities in the House and Senate.
If Obama wins by eight points, then he would also add Indiana, Missouri, North Carolina, and Arizona which would make it 375-163.
Stay tuned for more waffling.
Saturday, November 01, 2008
Deep Paranoia: Who Will Be the First to Call for a Coup?
Spokespeople on the right have achieved new levels of intensity in their expressions of contempt for Barack Obama. In a column today, Thomas Sowell characterizes Obama's only qualifications as being "ego and mouth."
But who will be the first to call for a coup to prevent Obama taking office?
My guess is that it will be one of the defense neo-cons like Frank Gaffney. But there are others like political philosopher Harvey Mansfield as well.
But who will be the first to call for a coup to prevent Obama taking office?
My guess is that it will be one of the defense neo-cons like Frank Gaffney. But there are others like political philosopher Harvey Mansfield as well.
The Electoral Map: A Quadrant Analysis

This is Karl Rove's electoral map from Wednesday, Oct. 29. It has Obama with 311 electoral votes and leading in states with another 56 electoral votes. That would be 367 electoral votes if Wednesday's trends held. Rove views McCain as having 157 electoral votes and leading in Montana with another 3 for 160 if trends hold.
It's hard to tell what the trends are going to be. Obama is up by 5 today in Rasmussen and 10 in Gallup. Given that Obama's been gaining in Gallup, it may be that the map will look even better for Obama on Tuesday. In particular, Arizona and Georgia might be joining the ranks of the toss-ups by then.
And this brings me to my point. Even if Obama should lose, this map looks very promising for the Democratic Party and I think it looks promising for the future of the country as well. It looks like the Republican Party is going to have to leave the 19th century if it wants to be competitive in presidential elections. And that would be very good for the whole country.
For the purpose of this analysis, I'd like to divide the country into quadrants. The east/west line is easy because it would run from North Dakota's eastern boundary to the Texas/Louisiana line. The North north/south line is less regular but it would begin at Pennsylvania's southern border, bisect Ohio, Indiana, and Illinois, and continue through the northern borders of Missouri, Kansas, and Colorado through to the Pacific.
The Northeast and Midwest are blue. Obama's domination of the northeastern quadrant bounded by New Jersey, Maine, Minnesota, and Missouri is striking. Famously traditional Republican states like Maine, Vermont, and New Hampshire are solidly blue. Obama's also ahead in Ohio while Indiana has become a complete toss-up. The only two states where McCain is clearly ahead are Kentucky and West Virginia.
A blue region is also coalescing in the Southeastern quadrant of former Confederate states. The inroads that the Obama campaign is making in the formerly Solid Republican South are almost as striking as Obama's northern domination. Maryland is a solid blue state because it's becoming more northeastern in character. But the key is that Obama has leads in Virginia, North Carolina and Florida while he's making inroads into Georgia (which most maps have as a "lean McCain" rather than a solid McCain). Virginia and North Carolina are more heavily influenced by Northeastern style population patterns in the DC suburbs and Research Triangle while Georgia and Florida have burgeoning metro areas that trend Democratic. The ultimate prospect is that the Old Confederacy could split into an "Atlantic South" that is Democratic and a Traditional Gulf/Mississippi/Appalachian South of Alabama, Mississippi, Louisiana, Arkansas, Tennessee, and South Carolina.
If that happened, the Civil War would be almost over.
It's also useful to view the Southwest as a single quadrant although Texas has many Southern characteristics and California is more Pacific than Southwestern. But the Democrats are gaining steadily in the western part of the quadrant other than Utah and only leaving the Texas, Oklahoma, and Kansas corridor to the GOP.
In this sense, Texas becomes the popular anchor point for the national Republican Party even though demographic trends are leading toward larger Democratic constituencies of hispanics and urban dwellers.
In other words, it's a relatively weak anchor.
The northwestern quadrant looks even weaker for the Republicans as Montana and North Dakota become swing states and the Republicans are left with isolated Wyoming, Idaho, and Alaska as well as the Plains states of Nebraska and South Dakota.
In this view, the Republicans would just have to change if they wanted to remain competetive in national elections. They would have to make a real appeal to the metro areas and retreat on social conservativism, hostility to science, and military belligerence.
Otherwise, the Republicans would face a real prospect of being outstripped by some sort of moderate, technocratic third party . . . and dying.
And its' not that far off. Michael Bloomberg already wants to be the presidential candidate of that party.
The Brave Geese of Kentucky
Every morning for the last six weeks, we've seen a couple flocks of geese flying north through Morehead. I'm not sure what's going on but there's a certain way in which you have to admire the brave geese of Kentucky as they fly up into the colder weather.
Friday, October 31, 2008
Sarah Palin's First Amendment
Sarah Palin was on a right-wing news outlet today complaining that she was losing her First Amendment Rights. The crux of her complaint is that the mainstream media is referring to all of her accusations concerning Barack Obama and William Ayres as negative campaigning and convincing people that Palin is campaigning inappropriately.
For Palin, the First Amendment means that she should be free to speak but that it should be unconstitutional for others to try to convince people that she's wrong or acting inappropriately. She should be able to speak but others should not be free to disagree with her in any kind of effective manner.
There's a substantive truth underlying Palin's argument. McCain, Palin, and the GOP media are de-emphasizing their own policy positions and proposals as they rely more very heavily on their accusations concerning Obama and Jeremiah Wright, William Ayres, Rashid Khalidi, socialism, and terrorism. If the Republicans are going to get hammered for negative campaigning every time they make these accusations, there's a sense in which they might as well not have a right to speak at all.
Why speak if what you say is not going to have an audience?
There's another problem as well. There's a certain way in which a person can not have free speech in the fullest sense of the word unless there is an audience to consider their views. In On Liberty, John Stuart Mill worried considerably about the kind of "social censorship" in which the harsh moral judgments of mass audiences either discourage people from speaking. Mill viewed the social censorship of the 19th century United States as doing more to suppress speech than the kind of government censorship that was associated with absolute monarchy. The main punishment of social censorship was the moral ostracism of speakers from social circles or a generalized "respectability." Ostracism is a punishment in two distinct ways. It punishes through the pain and humiliation of being excluded and also punished through the separation of the speaker from any audience willing to consider her speech.
From Sarah Palin's point of view, media characterizations of her references to William Ayres as negative campaigning serve as a social censorship that deprives her of her First Amendment Rights. Indeed, there is a sense in which she is being censored in that she is being ostracized out of the political community and therefore kept morally apart from the audience which she is trying to convince. Obviously, Palin's references to the First Amendment are misplaced because the First Amendment addresses government censorship rather than the social censorship she is experiencing as a vice-presidential candidate.
But the effect is powerful all the same.
Ultimately however, Sarah Palin has no complaint. What she is attempting to do to Obama is the same thing she accuses the media of doing to her. In repeating the insinuations about William Ayres, referring to Obama as a socialist, etc., Palin is calling Obama's status as a member in good standing in the American moral community with the implication that no one should take Obama's policy proposals seriously because Obama is not "really one of us."
In this sense, the McCain and Obama campaigns have been engaged in a game in which each side appeals to the larger American community to decide which campaign is outside the moral consensus and should therefore be socially censored. The McCain/Palin campaign is losing the moral war in the mainstream media and is suffering some social censorship effects as a result. But Palin has no basis for complaining about a condition that she would have been glad to impose on the Obama campaign.
"If [the media] convince enough voters that that is negative campaigning, for me to call Barack Obama out on his associations," Palin told host Chris Plante, "then I don't know what the future of our country would be in terms of First Amendment rights and our ability to ask questions without fear of attacks by the mainstream media."The poor dear.
For Palin, the First Amendment means that she should be free to speak but that it should be unconstitutional for others to try to convince people that she's wrong or acting inappropriately. She should be able to speak but others should not be free to disagree with her in any kind of effective manner.
There's a substantive truth underlying Palin's argument. McCain, Palin, and the GOP media are de-emphasizing their own policy positions and proposals as they rely more very heavily on their accusations concerning Obama and Jeremiah Wright, William Ayres, Rashid Khalidi, socialism, and terrorism. If the Republicans are going to get hammered for negative campaigning every time they make these accusations, there's a sense in which they might as well not have a right to speak at all.
Why speak if what you say is not going to have an audience?
There's another problem as well. There's a certain way in which a person can not have free speech in the fullest sense of the word unless there is an audience to consider their views. In On Liberty, John Stuart Mill worried considerably about the kind of "social censorship" in which the harsh moral judgments of mass audiences either discourage people from speaking. Mill viewed the social censorship of the 19th century United States as doing more to suppress speech than the kind of government censorship that was associated with absolute monarchy. The main punishment of social censorship was the moral ostracism of speakers from social circles or a generalized "respectability." Ostracism is a punishment in two distinct ways. It punishes through the pain and humiliation of being excluded and also punished through the separation of the speaker from any audience willing to consider her speech.
From Sarah Palin's point of view, media characterizations of her references to William Ayres as negative campaigning serve as a social censorship that deprives her of her First Amendment Rights. Indeed, there is a sense in which she is being censored in that she is being ostracized out of the political community and therefore kept morally apart from the audience which she is trying to convince. Obviously, Palin's references to the First Amendment are misplaced because the First Amendment addresses government censorship rather than the social censorship she is experiencing as a vice-presidential candidate.
But the effect is powerful all the same.
Ultimately however, Sarah Palin has no complaint. What she is attempting to do to Obama is the same thing she accuses the media of doing to her. In repeating the insinuations about William Ayres, referring to Obama as a socialist, etc., Palin is calling Obama's status as a member in good standing in the American moral community with the implication that no one should take Obama's policy proposals seriously because Obama is not "really one of us."
In this sense, the McCain and Obama campaigns have been engaged in a game in which each side appeals to the larger American community to decide which campaign is outside the moral consensus and should therefore be socially censored. The McCain/Palin campaign is losing the moral war in the mainstream media and is suffering some social censorship effects as a result. But Palin has no basis for complaining about a condition that she would have been glad to impose on the Obama campaign.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)