That's especially true for figures on "the fluff right" like Jeff Goldstein and Dan Collins of the Protein Wisdom blog. Their main idea is to appear as cool, hip, and fashionable as they can while pursuing a conservative political agenda of continuing the war in Iraq, campaigning against affirmative action, and opposing gay marriage. Consequently, Goldstein and Collins (who is the better blogger these days) use a lot of literary and pop culture references while avoiding much mention of George Bush, Dick Cheney, or right-wing politicians. They also disavow any association with the homophobia of the religious right and Ted Nugent, the race-baiting of people like Lee Atwater, and standard misogynistic Hillary-hatred.
But it doesn't work.
Conservatives have justified their rear-guard actions against contemporary civil rights activists and feminists by claiming that Martin Luther King and "classical feminists" were closer to conservative positions today. I've recently shown that such a claim doesn't stand up in relation to King. I'm sure the same is true of 19th century feminists as well.
However, there are no "original" or "classical" gay rights activists who conservatives can plausibly claim as their own.
As a result, Goldstein is forced to embrace "tradition" as his key argument in opposing the recognition of the right to same-sex marriage. Needless to say, Goldstein arranges a number of cutesy but specious fluff ideas around his advocacy of tradition. For example, he claims that:
Still, even if marriage is seen as a fundamental right, there is nothing prohibiting homosexuals from marrying. They just can’t “marry” someone of the same sex, because that arrangement does not fit within the traditional and culturally-defined idea of “marriage.”
Obviously, this is meant to be funny and hip. Even on a surface level, however, it is easy to see that this is a gesture of smirking hostility to gay people who want to marry people of their own sex because they have the sense of love and commitment toward one another. That ideal of mutual commitment gradually succeeded the intergenerational transfer of family property as the main motivation for marriage in the West between the 17th and 20th centuries. Goldstein is cynically telling gay people that they can marry any person of the opposite sex whether they love or have a commitment to them or not. It's just that Goldstein does not want gay people to be able to marry the people they love.
Goldstein makes a more general statement about tradition in relation to gay marriage as well.
Instead, the argument is that the kind of arrangement the same sex couple is engaging in is different from marriage as it is traditionally defined, and so it makes sense to call this new arrangement something other than marriage. It is, of course, easy (and correct, I should add) to note that once we allow same-sex unions to be called marriage, we will have effectively changed the definition of marriage, making same-sex couplings “marriage” by dint of broadening the definition to accommodate the new arrangement . . . when dealing with a tradition as sacrosanct to many as the marriage bond, the government and the judiciary should tread lightly.
But Goldstein's efforts to articulate a "really, cool guy" opposition to gay marriage founders on the nature of "tradition" in relation to gay people. Gay people have been "traditionally" excluded from marriage because homosexuality was "traditionally" viewed as damned by God, unnatural, perverse, morally sick, and abominable. Excluding gay people from marriage was an integral part of the whole "traditional" package of prosecuting and punishing people (including executions) for gay sex, hounding any kind of regular meeting places for gays bars, firing anybody from employment who was revealed to be gay, and stigmatizing gay people in families, schools, workplaces, the military, and other institutions.
In other words, the traditional exclusion of gays from marriage was tightly bound with the intense homophobic bigotry of Western and other civilizations. By resting his case for continuing to ban gay marriage on the "sacrosantness" of tradition, Goldstein is arguing in effect that the homophobia of the past and present should continue to exclude gay people from the highest conventional expressions of their love and treat them as second class citizens. Goldstein is also valuing the homophobic bigots of the present over gay people seeking to express their love and live as normal people with jobs, marriages, the choice of having kids or not, and overly short vacations. Whether Goldstein is himself an active homophobe or just a fellow-traveler of the religious right whose too much of a snob to admit it is immaterial.
In fact, he's pursuing a politics of homophobia.