Friday, August 31, 2007

The Fluff Right on Gay Marriage and Tradition

Tradition is a tough nut for conservatives. The American right is defined by its ferocious resistance to any effort to move away from the cultural traditions connected with segregation, male-headed households, exclusively male workplaces, and the stigmatizing of gay people. But the traditions themselves have been rejected by most of the American public and the bigoted attitudes that fueled those traditions are no longer socially respectable. As a result, the right has to thread the needle of disavowing racism, misogyny, and homophobia while continuing to campaign against any initiative by black people, feminists, or gay rights activists.

That's especially true for figures on "the fluff right" like Jeff Goldstein and Dan Collins of the Protein Wisdom blog. Their main idea is to appear as cool, hip, and fashionable as they can while pursuing a conservative political agenda of continuing the war in Iraq, campaigning against affirmative action, and opposing gay marriage. Consequently, Goldstein and Collins (who is the better blogger these days) use a lot of literary and pop culture references while avoiding much mention of George Bush, Dick Cheney, or right-wing politicians. They also disavow any association with the homophobia of the religious right and Ted Nugent, the race-baiting of people like Lee Atwater, and standard misogynistic Hillary-hatred.

But it doesn't work.

Conservatives have justified their rear-guard actions against contemporary civil rights activists and feminists by claiming that Martin Luther King and "classical feminists" were closer to conservative positions today. I've recently shown that such a claim doesn't stand up in relation to King. I'm sure the same is true of 19th century feminists as well.

However, there are no "original" or "classical" gay rights activists who conservatives can plausibly claim as their own.

As a result, Goldstein is forced to embrace "tradition" as his key argument in opposing the recognition of the right to same-sex marriage. Needless to say, Goldstein arranges a number of cutesy but specious fluff ideas around his advocacy of tradition. For example, he claims that:
Still, even if marriage is seen as a fundamental right, there is nothing prohibiting homosexuals from marrying. They just can’t “marry” someone of the same sex, because that arrangement does not fit within the traditional and culturally-defined idea of “marriage.”

Obviously, this is meant to be funny and hip. Even on a surface level, however, it is easy to see that this is a gesture of smirking hostility to gay people who want to marry people of their own sex because they have the sense of love and commitment toward one another. That ideal of mutual commitment gradually succeeded the intergenerational transfer of family property as the main motivation for marriage in the West between the 17th and 20th centuries. Goldstein is cynically telling gay people that they can marry any person of the opposite sex whether they love or have a commitment to them or not. It's just that Goldstein does not want gay people to be able to marry the people they love.

Goldstein makes a more general statement about tradition in relation to gay marriage as well.
Instead, the argument is that the kind of arrangement the same sex couple is engaging in is different from marriage as it is traditionally defined, and so it makes sense to call this new arrangement something other than marriage. It is, of course, easy (and correct, I should add) to note that once we allow same-sex unions to be called marriage, we will have effectively changed the definition of marriage, making same-sex couplings “marriage” by dint of broadening the definition to accommodate the new arrangement . . . when dealing with a tradition as sacrosanct to many as the marriage bond, the government and the judiciary should tread lightly.

But Goldstein's efforts to articulate a "really, cool guy" opposition to gay marriage founders on the nature of "tradition" in relation to gay people. Gay people have been "traditionally" excluded from marriage because homosexuality was "traditionally" viewed as damned by God, unnatural, perverse, morally sick, and abominable. Excluding gay people from marriage was an integral part of the whole "traditional" package of prosecuting and punishing people (including executions) for gay sex, hounding any kind of regular meeting places for gays bars, firing anybody from employment who was revealed to be gay, and stigmatizing gay people in families, schools, workplaces, the military, and other institutions.

In other words, the traditional exclusion of gays from marriage was tightly bound with the intense homophobic bigotry of Western and other civilizations. By resting his case for continuing to ban gay marriage on the "sacrosantness" of tradition, Goldstein is arguing in effect that the homophobia of the past and present should continue to exclude gay people from the highest conventional expressions of their love and treat them as second class citizens. Goldstein is also valuing the homophobic bigots of the present over gay people seeking to express their love and live as normal people with jobs, marriages, the choice of having kids or not, and overly short vacations. Whether Goldstein is himself an active homophobe or just a fellow-traveler of the religious right whose too much of a snob to admit it is immaterial.

In fact, he's pursuing a politics of homophobia.

Thursday, August 30, 2007

A Win for Gay Marriage in Iowa

STREET PREACHER PROLEGOMENA. There's been a street preacher on our campus for the last three days and much of his act is condemning gay people to damnation. Having always been fascinated by street preachers, I've been surprised and bemused with the high level of student hostility. However, my bemusement was wrong. As one of my gay colleagues informed me, gay students don't see a kind of pathetic, amusingly bigoted kind of guy in the street preacher. What many gay students at Morehead State see is someone who is replaying all the bigoted hostility they experienced from preachers, teachers, parents, and friends while they grew up in Eastern Kentucky. He's also forcing them to replay all of the pain from those fire and brimstone accusations. Bell hooks writes in "Killing Rage" that racism hurts black people like her. The same is the case with homophobia and gays.

I'm embarrassed to say that I hadn't realized that earlier.

READING THE IOWA DECISION. I've always supported gay marriage. Marriage is one of the fundamental goods in American society and I've always thought that gay people should have just as much right to be married as people like me. As a liberally inclined person, I would have supported gay marriage even if I had never met a gay person (and in fact I didn't meet any openly gay people until after graduating from college--one of the perils of rural existence during the seventies). However, I have had gay friends and colleagues almost continuously since my two-year stint working in a gay bar during the 1980's. As a result, I don't view gay marriage solely as an issue for gay people as a group or social category, but also see gay marriage as an issue for people I know, like, admire, and appreciate as well as a couple of people I've fallen out with. In other words--real people.

The decision of the Iowa court to overturn the state marriage law banning same-sex marriage was interesting on several grounds. It was surprising that the court's decision was a summary judgment indicating that the county officials being sued did not meaningfully dispute the facts introduced by the couples suing over not being allowed to marry. I was also surprised that the county officials sought to introduce testimony from such a lame set of unqualified "marriage experts" who freely admitted that they hadn't read the relevant literature on gays and marriage. Finally, it was interesting that the judge argued that the courts needed to use "strict scrutiny" to evaluate the ban on gay marriage because of the fundamental nature of the right to marriage that had been established when the courts overturned the Virginia miscegenation statutes in 1967.

What was most surprising to me though was the long list of harms experienced by gay people as a result of being banned b gay marriage. Among other harms created by the harms of banning of gay marriage, the two most striking might have been the first mentioned by the court. Those were the devaluing of the relationships at the core of gay people's sexual identity and the badge of inferiority and second-class status that comes from being excluded from a pervasive institution like marriage. The court also highlighted the lack of access to what is generally recognized as the fullest expression of love and commitment in our society and went on to identify a large number of other harms.

It was all heart-breaking and eye-opening to read. I hadn't been aware of how pervasive the effect of the gay marriage ban was on gay people. The court overturned the ban on gay marriage because the law violated the due process and equal protection clauses of the Iowa Constitution. What I learned was just how pervasive the effects of ignoring due process and equal protection are for gay people.

So Sexy

Mrs. RSI is going in for carpal tunnel surgery on her hand in Lexington tomorrow. We have to leave before 6:00am. Oh, the burdens of rural life.

For her surgery prep, Mrs. RSI had to wash her hand with hand sanitizer then hold her hand up in the air for five minutes so it could dry in a sanitized manner.

If she hadn't been so sexy with her hand up in the air, I would have laughed even harder.

Wednesday, August 29, 2007

A New Job for Rove: Outing Republicans

OUT WITH THE OLD CRAIGS. It looks like the Republicans are going to drive Larry Craig out of the Senate before the drama over his resignation becomes two weeks of embarrassment. Of course, if they were that worried about embarrassment, they should be calling for impeachment proceedings against Bush and Cheney.

BUT WHAT ABOUT THE NEW? What about the other Larry Craigs and Mark Foleys out there leading double lives just waiting to further embarrass the Republican Party and the Bush administration? If President Bush really thought his policies were important for national security and economic prosperity, he would do something about the sexual indiscretions of other Republican politicians as well.

PRE-EMPTIVE OUTINGS. Obviously, the best way to deal with Republican proclivities for speed-dialing prostitutes, flirting with pages, and bathroom boudoirs is for the Bush administration to "out" wayward Republican politicians before they get into trouble. Of course, I don't mean "outing" in terms of giving indiscretions broad publicity in the media. That would be counter-productive. What's needed are really confidential "outings" where investigators inform responsible figures that Staffer X, Senator Y, or Representative Z is engaged in embarrassing indiscretions and the administration informs those people that they need to spend more time with their families or fulfill their life-long ambitions to live in a kibbutz. Given that the Bush administration would view the sexuality of Republicans as a matter of national security, it goes without saying that these kinds of confidential outings would be classified as "national security outings" so they wouldn't be leaked to the media. Thus, the program would be called the "Pre-Emptive National Security Outing Program" or PENSOP for short.

A JOB FOR ROVE. But who would be the best person to lead the PENSOP program. Once again the answer is obvious. It has to be Karl Rove. He's loyal to the president, extremely bright, full of energy, and currently unemployed. One of Karl Rove's great contributions to Republican Party politics was the systematizing of opposition research. That means he would be the perfect person to investigate wayward Republicans as if they were the opposition. And Rove would probably enjoy the job. In fact, the mere prospect that Rove would be investigating them would be enough to convince a lot of indiscreet Republicans to change their ways. PENSOP would make the Republican Party a more moral party as well as a more effective political party. It's the only way to go.

Larry Craig's Moment in the Sun

Larry Craig Blames the Press. Let me get this straight. Larry Craig is blaming the Idaho Statesman for his guilty plea for lewd behavior in the Minneapolis airport. He might have done better if he'd just called his behavior "Western friendliness" or having a "special privacy rituals."
Craig and the Surge. Depending on how many other prominent Republicans get caught in "moral turpitude," the Larry Craig scandal won't have much of an impact by the time the general election campaign heats up in 2008. But it's still important. Craig's arrest and guilty plea has completely killled the momentum of the "Save the Surge" campaign by President Bush and the right. The reaction to last week's Vietnam analogy speech by President Bush was "electric" among conservatives. Today, Republicans like Scott Reed are despondent. Again.

Why is Bush Working So Hard to Save the Surge? It's not like the Republicans have to fight that hard to maintain American troop levels in Iraq at 160,000 through spring and summer 2008 anyway. President Bush can still veto any appropriation legislation that gives him anything besides "no strings" funding on the war in Iraq. Likewise, it's clear that Republicans in Congress would support Bush in any veto showdown and that Democrats have no stomach for a long showdown with the White House headed into 2008.

In other words, it looks like Bush has already won the September battle over Iraq. So why is he taking so much time out of his daily exercise routine to travel around the country giving speeches in support of the surge?

My Guess is that the White House is either aware of some news or some potential Democratic strategy that would be a threat to the surge policy or that President Bush is just trying to rally the Republican base so that Congressional Republicans won't be so skittish in September. If it's the latter, Larry Craig has made things a lot more difficult for the President. Right now, the only way to drive the Craig scandal out of the media would be for Craig to resign quickly.

Tuesday, August 28, 2007

The Conservative Face of Evil

Dennis Prager argues that "the Achilles Heel" of liberals is their "desire to be loved." According to Prager, that's why liberals have been reluctant to describe the Soviet Union as an "evil empire," discipline their children, and are so sensitive to the damage that George Bush has done to America's global reputation. Conservatives view the left as reluctant to judge, overly worried about thinking about politics in moral terms, and consequently too cautious in their pursuit of American interest.

To put the matter crudely, conservatives view people on the left as effete, effeminate and ineffective.

But times have changed.

People on the left have redoubled our identification with the heritage of constitutional liberty, learned to make the harshest kind of moral judgments, and started to use the language of good vs evil.

And we have our conservative friends to thank for that.

Certainly that's been the case with American legal rights. The Bush administration has raised awareness of American rights in a lot of ways. By kidnapping and torturing those accused of terrorism, denying them legal rights, and flushing them into Guantanamo, Bush has reminded liberals of the preciousness of legal rights and the vigilance needed to maintain them. In this context, liberal bloggers like Glenn Greenwald identify the rights enshrined in the Bill of Rights as the essence of the United States as a nation and readily label Bush and his supporters as "un-American," "corrupt," "morally bankrupt," and "cynical."

Contrary to Praeger, neither Greenwald nor any of the other major liberal bloggers care the least about being loved by the Bush administration, the media, or the "establishment" they view as aiding and abetting the abuses of the Bush years. In relation to the moral failings of the Bush administration, liberals are as judgmental as any Puritan, abolitionist, or sixties feminist.

But I doubt Praeger would be comforted by that thought.

But the moral judgmentalism of liberals extends farther than that. Liberals condemn the swaggering arrogance, personal intolerance, and sense of entitlement on the right and everyday liberals refer to people on the right as "arrogant assholes" to such an extent that I've encountered conservatives who have internalized the insult. Liberals also condemn conservatives like Ted Haggard, Mark Foley, David Vitter, and Larry Craig as fantastic moral hypocrites but also believe that conservatives in general share in the outsized hypocrisy of these men. Finally, liberals view the right as racist, misogynist, homophobic, and animated by religious bigotry because of conservative resistance to the Civil Rights movement, feminism, gay rights, and freedom of religion.

That's an enormous amount of moral condemnation. In some ways, I wonder what Praeger had in mind when he accused liberals of not being judgmental enough.

In the final analysis though, I don't think liberals engage in quite enough moral condemnation of the right. There's a growing body of evidence that there is a body of opinion in the American right that favors the overthrow of American democracy and the establishment of a dictatorship. Yesterday a group called "Family Security Matters" published an article by Phillip Atkinson calling for George Bush to kill the Arab population of Iraq and then overthrow democracy in the United States.

If President Bush copied Julius Caesar by ordering his army to empty Iraq of Arabs and repopulate the country with Americans, he would achieve immediate results: popularity with his military; enrichment of America by converting an Arabian Iraq into an American Iraq (therefore turning it from a liability to an asset); and boost American prestiege while terrifying American enemies.

He could then follow Caesar's example and use his newfound popularity with the military to wield military power to become the first permanent president of America, and end the civil chaos caused by the continually squabbling Congress and the out-of-control Supreme Court.


It would be easy to condemn Philip Atkinson and "Family Security Matters" as a bunch of crackpots. But it doesn't work out that way. Even though "Family Security Matters" disavowed the Atkinson article, leaders and opinion-makers on the right have been calling for the end of democracy as we know it ever since the Democrats won control of Congress. For Newt Gingrich, the road to overturning democracy changing the first amendment to restrict political dissent and create military commissions to prosecute war dissenters. Frank Gaffney, the head of the Center for Security Policy that created "Family Security Matters," favors military tribunals for leading war opponents as well. Thomas Sowell is more in favor of a military coup while Harvey Mansfield likes one-man rule in general.

Perhaps more significantly, everyday right-wingers are starting to get the idea that shooting a few prominent liberals would be a good idea. According to Johann Hari, a fellow traveler on the National Review cruise offered up this tidbit.
When I hear her say, " Of course, we need to execute some of these people," I wake up. Who do we need to execute? She runs her fingers through the sand lazily. "A few of these prominent liberals who are trying to demoralise the country," she says. "Just take a couple of these anti-war people off to the gas chamber for treason to show, if you try to bring down America at a time of war, that's what you'll get." She squints at the sun and smiles. " Then things'll change."
The Bush administration correctly characterizes Osama bin Laden as "evil" because he advocates the establishment of a harsh dictatorship and is willing to kill enormous numbers of human beings to accomplish his goal. It's becoming more and more evident that the American right shares that brand of evil. It goes without saying that right-wingers in the United States have had no problem with the deaths of more than one hundred thousand Iraqis over the last four years. Now that right-wing opinions in the United States is beginning to coalesce around the idea of overthrowing American democracy, it may be time to consider the right-wing as a real threat to the American way of life. Certainly, the American right is a much more powerful and scarcely less aggressive force than al-Qaeda. If a right-wing American government made a push to overthrow democratic institutions in the United States, it would certainly be more of a threat than al-Qaeda will ever be able to generate.

In that sense, the right-wing is becoming the most prominent source of evil now facing American society.

Monday, August 27, 2007

"It's Morning in America"--A Line for 2009

One of the most dishonest things about the right-wing is their claims to find precedents in Martin Luther King, Lincoln, Roosevelt, Kennedy, and other figures reviled by conservatives of their own times.

But I can see liberals stealing a line from GOP saint Ronald Reagan when a Democratic president is installed in January 2009.

"It's morning in America."

That's how David Iglesias responded to the resignation of Alberto Gonzales. I t will be even more true when all the Bushies are removed from office.

Poor Al Gonzales

For some of the people leaving the Bush administration, their resignations are gateways to the big-time.

Among the recently resigned, Karl Rove can write his own ticket as a consultant super-star, campaign manager, big-time pundit, or big-money public speaker for even bigger money audiences. Throw in a few cushy appointments to corporate boards and perhaps some advice on how to make really profitable investments, and Rove will be coming into some "real money."

In fact, failure could be as profitable for Rove as it for a lot of corporate CEO's.

Well, maybe not that profitable.

Smaller fish like John Bolton can also cash in. Bolton is a right-wing martyr because of Democratic opposition to his nomination to be ambassador to the UN. Of course, Bolton got into the UN for awhile anyway but he probably resented every moment of his UN tenure because it delayed his ability to cash in on his conservative martyr status. Indeed, Bolton is an idiot if he isn't making six figures to speak to a big-money conservative group as this very moment.

Needless to say, that's not "real" money, but Bolton will be able to pay for a great house in a super-expensive neighborhood and buy some really nice tailored suits for meetings at the American Enterprise Institute where he's still a honcho.

No more off the rack for Bolton.

Which brings us to Alberto Gonzales. Given the fact that Gonzales became the face of Bush administration incompetence to conservatives as well as the rest of the country, Gonzales is not going to a right-wing martyr at all. That means that Gonzales is not going to become a human ATM like Karl Rove, won't get rich on the speaker's circuit like John Bolton, and won't be receiving a multi-million dollar advance for his memoirs. There won't be any cushy appointments at the American Enterprise Institute, Hudson Institute, or Hoover Institution for poor Al Gonzales.

Maybe the George W. Bush library at SMU will want Gonzales for its board, but that will probably be it.

It's kind of unfair. Why shouldn't Gonzales get to cash in on his incompetence and failures like other Bushies?

Isn't there any justice in the world?

Links later.

Cheney Country

Hillary Rosen has a little piece in Huffington Post about how Wyoming is no longer "Cheney Country" because four or five people she talked with while on vacation in Wyoming didn't like Cheney anymore. These kinds of "talking with the natives" pieces are always annoying and are even more annoying because I live in a place where filmmakers and reporters are always talking to the locals as if we had all just stepped out of a production of "Deliverance."

But Rosen is also mistaken if she thinks "Cheney Country" has just disappeared. It's just changed location from the physical space of the Wyoming he used to represent to the virtual space of the conservative talk shows and right-wing blogs.

Right-wing media space will be "Cheney Country" as long as there's a right-wing media.

Sunday, August 26, 2007

Barack Obama in Lexington

Blogging Makes Me a Better Citizen. Before I started blogging, I had the low-grade contempt for politicians that's characteristic of most political scientists and avoided the political events of even those politicians in the Democratic Party I supported. But that's changed. Now that I'm reporting on politics I feel go to events and make myself better informed about the specifics of political campaigns. Initially, I went as a duty to my blog, but I'm starting to think of my blog and my duties as a dad as an opportunity to do what I should be doing as a citizen.

Obama in Lexington. It was in this civic frame of mind that I plunked down $125 for my family (two parents, two daughters, and mother-in-law) to go to Lexington, KY and hear Barack Obama speak today. There's a lot to say about Obama's speech and the event as a whole. But I'll limit myself to a few items here.

The Candidate and the Crowd. One of these days, I'm going to use my status as a blogger to get a press pass, but being out in the crowd was very much an advantage. Where the crowd at the John Edwards speech in Prestonsburg, KY wanted to be roused by Edwards, Obama's sold-out crowd of 1800 in a packed Heritage Hall was roused from the minute we took our seats. People were on edge and excited and excited about seeing Barack Obama speak. What the crowd wanted from Obama was a reason to feel their excitement was justified and the Obama campaign provided that even before the candidate came out. Reginald Smith jr. of the University of Kentucky did a version of the "Star-Spangled Banner" that was so incredible the campaign could have brought out the candidate without further introduction.

Then, Obama himself delivered the goods again and again by outlining a vision of a politics that expressed what many in the room already felt. Obama was inspiring to a racially mixed, progressive crowd because they were already inspired by his main themes. Whether it was waking up from the "long national nightmare" of the Bush administration or developing a politics of common purpose and mutual help, Obama kept hitting the right notes for the audience and the applause was often so loud that I couldn't hear him talk.

Who Deserves Credit. I've read several items about Obama peaking nationally, declining in early primary states, and falling further behind Hillary Clinton. Off Obama's rally, I'd have to say that Hillary Clinton's campaign is doing quite well to be inching further ahead. If the true measure of athletes is how they do against the best competition, Hillary Clinton must be running a very strong campaign to be maintaining their lead over Obama.

Saturday, August 25, 2007

Giuliani's Lying Strategy: Flooding the Zone

One of the striking characteristics of the Bush administration is the readily identifiable lying techniques of top Bush officials. The result has been a diverse, flexible, sophisticated, team-centered approach to lying that worked for a long time. With President Bush, it's saying "white is black" with a straight face. That's how he can say "the United States does not torture" with such sincerity and confidence even though he himself approved the torture techniques. Dick Cheney prefers to torture small bits of information into big dishonest conclusions while Albert Gonzales specializes in saying things that everybody knows are untrue and then daring opponents to prove him a liar.

One of the ways that Rudy Giuliani has tried to prove himself the true heir to the Bush administration legacy is to develop the strikingly new lying technique of "flooding the zone." Of course, "flooding the zone" is a football term for the tactic of sending several receivers into one part of the field. In that way, the offense expects that one of the receivers will be open. Rudy Giuliani's approach to lying can be described as flooding the zone because he's so prolific as a liar.
Here's a catalogue of Rudy's lies from TPM:
But just as importantly, Giuliani keeps undermining his own credibility on all policy issues by exaggerating to the point of comedy. He can't just say he spent time at Ground Zero; he has to exaggerate to say he spent as much time (if not more) than the rescue, recovery, and cleanup workers who spent a year sifting through human remains and rubble. He can't just say he's interested in counter-terrorism; he has to exaggerate to say he's been "studying Islamic terrorism for 30 years." He can't just say he's committed to promoting adoption over abortion; he has to exaggerate his record as mayor. He can't just he cut taxes in NYC; he has to exaggerate his record to include tax cuts he opposed (he even counted one cut twice). The guy can't even release a list of congressional endorsements without exaggerating the numbers.
Steve Benen of TPM thinks that Giuliani is "undermining his own credibility" with all these seemingly unnecessary lies. But that's not the case at all. Right-wing activists enjoy, expect, and even demand these kinds of lies because they interpret Giuliani's contempt for truth as an indication of contempt for the mainstream media, liberal audiences, and the Democratic opposition. One way or another, demonstrations of such contempt are required of Republican candidates.

There are several things that are ingenious about Giuliani's flooding the zone with lies. First, lying so often gives Giuliani the chance to cover up some of the more unsavory aspects of his record. Liberal media outlets like TPM and Salon might catch Rudy lying about the time spent at Ground Zero. But when the liberal media is hashing over that lie, they're not talking about Rudy's marrying his cousin, Rudy's use of the Emergency Command Center as a love nest for his mistress, or the inhumane way he treated second wife Donna Hanover during their divorce.

That's a plus for Rudy.

Flooding the zone with lies also means that individual revelations of dishonesty won't be so damaging. Because there's so many more lies coming down the pike, discussion of any particular lie only lasts for 24-48 hours. Rudy's tendency to "exaggerate to the point of comedy" doesn't hurt him because it's impossible to pay much attention to any particular dishonesty.

Another advantage for Rudy is that a few of his lies might get accepted as the truth. Given how hard it is to keep up with Rudy's dishonesty, the media might end up accepting Rudy's exaggerations of his tax-cutting record or his congressional endorsements as "conventional wisdom." Assuming that Rudy's going to have bigger and better lies in the future, the shear frequency of his fibs means that there's a chance that some of those lies will really help him.

"Flooding the zone" with lies is such an effective technique for Rudy that I wouldn't be surprised to see Mitt Romney or Fred Thompson to adapt it pretty soon. Both of them have a long way to go before they show that they're really serious about winning.

Friday, August 24, 2007

Warner Slows "Save the Surge" Campaign

Like most people on the left, I don't think much of John Warners proposal for a token withdrawal of American troops by Christmas. If Warner doesn't think the surge should be successful, he should just join the Democrats in calling for a withdrawal.

Yet, it seems like Warner's speech has pretty much stopped the "Save the Surge" momentum that had been developing since the O'Hanlan/Pollack op-ed a couple of weeks ago. It certainly wrong-footed the Bush administration which had to backtrack and ask if they still had Warner's support.

Between Warner's speech, the pessimistic NIE Report, and Peter Pace's recommendation for troop withdrawals, it looks like the Save the Surge campaign will have to start over.

Full Circle for Right on Iraq

Yesterday, Hugh Hewitt pushed hard on President Bush's Vietnam analogy, emphasizing that a U. S. withdrawal would leave Iraqis to the Arab Pol Pot, genocide, and torture. Images of American guilt for Cambodian genocide were as hot and heavy as facts and analysis about Iraq were scarce and unmentioned.

This brings the right-wing full circle on Iraq. When the Bush administration and the attack media originally promoted the invasion, the argument that got them over the top was the idea of establishing "democracy in Iraq" and spreading democracy in the Middle East. That's an idea that had it's liberal origins in the French Revolution and Marxist development in the goal of spreading communism. The administration's conservative arguments about American "empire" and fear of Saddam Hussein's weapons of mass destruction were not moving popular opinion decisively in favor of invasion. As a result, the administration had to throw in the liberal idea of spreading democracy abroad even as they were undermining the rule of law and our democratic rights at hom. The administration had to do this because United States is not a conservative country despite the presence of an active right-wing. To seal the deal on the war, the Bush administration's propoganda machine had to appeal to the liberal instincts of most Americans.

The right is making the same move now. Giving up temporarily on conservative analogies about Winston Churchill, our fate, and god's design for us, the right is now trying to appeal to a liberal sense of guilt over our potential responsibility for civilian casualties. Given the prominence which liberal filmakers and teachers have given to the Cambodian "Killing Fields" over the last twenty years, it's easy to see the power of the image and the sense of guilt and responsibility that it would stimulate.

One could be outraged over the cynicism of the right-wing's appeal. I don't remember the right caring too much about genocide in Cambodia in the years after the news emerged.

And it is outrageous.

Instead of being stuck on our outrage, however, let's design a little test for the sincerity of right-wing figures like President Bush, Hugh Hewitt, and the rest of the people flogging the Vietnam/Cambodia analogy.

The test is simple. If the Hugh Hewitts of the world are sincere in their worries about genocide, they will have already expressed a great deal of"guilt" and remorse over the at least one hundred thousand Iraqi civilian deaths since the invasion.

Personally, I haven't seen any of that guilt. So, I have to assume that the current effort by the right to promote a Vietnam/Cambodia analogy is as cynical and dishonest as the rest of their propoganda ploys.

Thursday, August 23, 2007

The Shadow of Disaster in Iraq

A Pinch of Progress. The National Intelligence Estimate (NIE) on Iraq is a typical bit of bureaucratic obfuscation. The main claim is that there have been "measurable but uneven improvements in Iraq's security situation." Then the authors divide the security situation in half. What's "measurable" is that the "escalation of rates of violence has been checked for now and that overall attack levels in Iraq have fallen . . ."

These are two separate things. When the authors are talking about "escalation of rates of violence," they are referring primarily to violence against civilians in car bomb attacks, assassinations, death squad killings, and the like. In halting the "escalation of rates of violence," the surge has merely kept the situation in Iraq from getting progressively worse as it had in 2006. It has not made the situation better. The only sense in which there is progress is in the sense that things are "better than they could have been." In fact, violence against civilians "remains high" and I've seen other sources that indicate that violence against civilians is higher than it was last year at this time.

At the same time, the surge has resulted in declines of attack levels against American troops and that's especially in Anbar where the insurgents who had been attacking Americans have switched sides and are now fighting with Americans against al-Qaeda.

As the soldiers op-ed stressed on Sunday, conditions have not improved for Iraqis at all. But the declining attacks on Americans do represent a pinch of progress.

The Regress in the Progress. The conventional wisdom about the weakness of the surge is that the al-Maliki government has not used the supposed "breathing space" from the surge to forge compromises with Sunni politicians about re-Baathification, the distribution of oil revenue, and regional autonomy. However, both the Maliki government and its constituencies have fallen apart. The Maliki government was built primarily on the support of the Shiite religious parties, the Sadr bloc, secular Shiites like Ayad Allawi, and relatively moderate Sunni politicians. But the government has been abandoned by the Sadrists, the Allawi Party, and the Sunnis. Even worse from the American point of view is that Sadr is becoming even more popular than he was as a politician even though his militia is fragmenting into little fiefdoms.

What the conventional wisdom doesn't acknowledge is that the dramatic weakening of the al-Maliki government is a consequence of the surge. What the surge did was create a set of cross-cutting pressures that were well beyond the Maliki government's ability to cope. Given that one of the main (though unstated) goals of the surge was the destruction of al-Sadr's Mahdi Army militia, the Sadr political party pushed against the surge within the government. Stuck between the more aggressive Americans and the more popular al-Sadr, Maliki did nothing and the Sadr bloc eventually left the governing coalition because Maliki wouldn't set a timetable for American withdrawal.

Maliki couldn't satisfy the Sunnis or secularists either. Those parties used the occasion of the surge to push al-Maliki to destroy the Mahdi Army and other Shiite militias altogether. Fortunately, Maliki proved that he wasn't as stupid as the Bush administration by refusing to risk a likely Shiite insurrection. So, the Sunnis and secularists withdrew as well.

The final outcome is a very mixed bag. As a result of the pressures created by the surge, the Maliki government isn't strong enough to function effectively. However, it has avoided the major disasters of confrontation with the American military on the one hand and confrontation with the popular Shiite militias on the other. Like the surge, the Maliki government isn't making much progress, but it has prevented the worst from happening.

The Shadow of Disaster. However, things can get much worse in a hurry, something emphasized by the NIE when it says that the escalation of violence has been stopped "for now." The problem is the intense American dissatisfaction with Maliki and the Shiites. The Bush administration has never wanted Shiite majority government in Iraq because of the intense sectarianism of the Shiite community and their ties with Iran. The outcome of Iraqi elections have stuck the Bushies with governments dominated by Shiite religious parties that have been very reluctant to engage the Sunnis in the way the Bush administration wants. Now that the American military sees an opportunity to bring former Sunni insurgents into the Iraqi government structure as soldiers and policemen, Bush and his advisers are even more tempted to seek a replacement for al-Maliki than they've been before.

The conditions are right for the Bush administration to be tempted to engage in a little putsch against Maliki. Maliki's government is weak, there's general dissatisfaction with the performance of that government, Ayad Allawi is available as a substitute, and Allawi is much more pro-American than Maliki.

But Allawi would be a disaster because his "conciliatory" policies toward the Americans and Sunnis would alienate the majority Shiite population. Given that Allawi would be committed to destroying the militias, an Allawi government could be a recipe for a Shiite insurrection. In other words, blowing up the Maliki government could lead to a dramatic de-stabilization of the situation in Iraq and reverse the pinch of progress that's been associated with the surge.

There's a lobbying group in Washington promoting the installation of Allawi in Baghdad. Hopefully the Bush administration won't be so stupid that they'll listen.

Job Training for Mitt

Mitt Romney obviously got his bounce from the Iowa straw poll. Big Mitt finally got off the 10% mark in the RCP average and has passed McCain at 13.5% to 11.7% in the national polls. He also leads in Iowa and New Hampshire.

What's not to like about Mitt? He's handsome, clean-cut, well-spoken, and seemingly sincere. I imagine that he also knows who's the president of Pakistan. The main questions about Romney come from liberals like Josh Marshall at TPM who think that Romney's too transparently dishonest to be taken seriously. Here TPM catches Mitt in a particularly gratuitous lie concerning Teddy Kennedy.

But I don't see why Marshall has to be so "negative." Liberals tend to overuse the "outrage" pedal in relation to conservatives anyway. I think it would be much better just to say that Romney was doing a little "job training." Given that routine lying is practically a job requirement for a Republican president, Romney will need to sharpen his "truth evasion" skills as a way to prepare for the job.

In fact, the next time Romney tells a whopper, people should stand up and cheer. It shows that he's really serious about winning.



Wednesday, August 22, 2007

Cold-Water Hillary Notes

Needless to say, I'm heavily biased toward Hillary Clinton as a presidential candidate. Viewing her as the best qualified candidate to make progress while the right-wing is waging war on the next Democratic president, I've endorsed Hillary and will put money into her campaign. Moreover, I've promised my daughter to take her to a Hillary inaugural if she wins.

But today, I'm going to throw some cold water her way.

1. Too Good at the Poll Margins. A Gallup poll has Hillary doubling up on Obama at 42%-21%. Rasmussen's robo-poll isn't much different at 42-22. I don't like it. Having only run as a candidate in only one real campaign, Hillary needs more experience with tight races. So does her campaign team. Edwards and Obama are still challenging in early primary states, but Hillary really needs them to be more competitive if her campaign is going to be running on all cylinders for the general election.

2. Too Positive About the Surge. While at the VFW convention, Hillary claimed that "We've begun to change tactics in Iraq, and in some areas, particularly in Al Anbar province, it's working." First, this is inaccurate. As Anthony Cordesman made clear, the progress in al-Anbar was much more a matter of the luck of some Sunni tribal leaders changing sides than tactics associated with the surge. What's more, Hillary's indicating that she was influenced by the war cheerleading NY Times op-ed of Michael O'Hanlon and Kenneth Pollack. Would she actually give those clowns jobs in a Hillary administration?

3. Irresponsible About Maliki. But the worst is Hillary's irresponsible comments about removing Nouri al-Maliki as Iraqi prime minister. Who would take al-Maliki's place. Maliki's government is so weak because Iraqi politics is so fragmented. Not only does Iraq have the three big mutually irreconcilable Shiite, Sunni, and Kurdish groups, but the Shiites and Sunnis are tremendously fragmented within themselves. According to Hillary:

The Iraqi government's failures have reinforced the widely held view that the Maliki government is nonfunctional and cannot produce a political settlement, because it is too beholden to religious and sectarian leaders . . ." Clinton went on to say she "hope[s] that the Iraqi parliament will replace Prime Minister Maliki with a less divisive and more unifying figure when it returns in a few weeks."
Of course, the Maliki government is beholden to religious and sectarian leaders. That's because the Shiite political parties, civic institutions, militias, and population are mostly religious and sectarian. Here Hillary is biting out of the same delusion of "moderate" Iraqi government as Bush. In fact, a "moderate" government would be even weaker than the Maliki government because it's support would be even more fragmented and tenuous than Maliki's.

The American cause in Iraq is on such tenuous ground that it's difficult to say what should be done with Iraq's central government. My best guess is that supporting Shiite elites as they figure out how to govern is the wisest course in the long run. But replacing Maliki is a bad idea in both the short and the long run.

Hillary's week isn't going as badly as my week, but I'm still hoping she starts to do better.

Postscript 1: Glenn Greenwald criticizes Carl Levin's and, by implication, Hillary's call for the removal of Maliki as a sign that the Democrats are going to give support to the surge ("embrace and celebrate") while blaming the horrific conditions in Iraq on the Maliki government. According to Greenwald, the Dems are "afraid to challenge the U.S. military's claims that we are Winning, and are even afraid to oppose the Surge." That's not likely. Harry Reid is already on record as challenging Gen. Petraeus. Instead, I would bet that the Democrats don't have the votes to effectively challenge the military and have decided to minimize their target area for right-wing attacks. It appears to me that the Democrats want wins but are willing to tread very carefully if they can't get the wins.


The Solution to Primary Creep

The conservative-leaning blog, The Politico, has an informative article on the sanctions the DNC might apply to Michigan and Florida for moving up their primaries to January.

But the only solution to the "primary creep" where states keep scheduling their primaries earlier is to end the Iowa/New Hampshire duopoly on the earliest primary events.

There's no reason why Iowa and New Hampshire should get to hog all the extra influence that goes with being the first big events for the presidential calendar. As long as Iowa and New Hampshire are first, states like Florida, Michigan, New York, and California are going to try to move ahead in order to have influence proportionate to their populations.

And who can blame them.

What the Democrats need to do is develop a system where states can rotate as the first state primaries for a presidential campaign. They could divide all the states (and the District of Columbia) into groups of five "first primary" states and then alternate the groups. For example, Group I could be defined as California, Nebraska, Indiana, Georgia, and Massachusetts and that group could be have the first primaries spread over three weeks in 2012. If such were the case, that group's next shot at the first primary apple would be 10 elections later.

The point here is that an entirely different group--perhaps Texas, Maine, Ohio, Oregon, and Mississippi--would be the first primary states in 2016.

The Democrats are the party of equality. The only way to solve the problem of primary creep is to spread the wealth of being a "first primary state" more equally.

Tuesday, August 21, 2007

Democrats and Their Two Visions

Joan Walsh of Salon has a very useful review of Matt Bai's The Argument: Billionaires, Bloggers, and the Battle to Remake the Democratic Party. Actually, Bai's book itself doesn't sound that interesting. Bai's bothered by the rise of the netroots as a force in the Democratic Party and he mounts a fairly typical and fairly tedious line of attack. Bai likes his liberals to have "big ideas" but he wants them pure of heart and above the vulgar day-to-day nastiness of party politics. In other words, Bai wants his liberals to be noble losers. What's worse is that the big ideas Bai really likes are Republican big ideas like privatizing social security, dismembering labor unions, and juicing up the defense industry. So Bai is especially favorable to Democrats who embrace a lot of Republican positions like Joe Lieberman and especially disturbed by the bare-knuckled liberalism of popular blogs like DailyKos.

Not much interesting there.

But Joan Walsh does identify a tension that I believe is going to plague any incoming Democratic administration. That's because she's on both sides of the tension.

On the one hand, Walsh believes that any Democratic administration is going to have to come up with "big ideas" on important issues like health care to be successful.
Let me be clear: Like Bai, I would like to see more political will (the ideas are there; it's a mobilized constituency behind a few key ideas that's missing) to do something about the healthcare nightmare, the public education crisis, persistent inner-city poverty, the shock waves of globalization ... I could go on and on. I think the 2008 Democratic nominee will need to articulate and build a constituency behind a compelling vision of post-Bush America that reckons with terrorism, security and a new U.S. role in the volatile global economy. He or she may not need it to get elected, the way the Republicans are going, but they'll need it to govern and to solve the problems voters elect them to address -- as well as to get reelected.

Walsh's vision about a possible Democratic agenda is so expansive here that it would take a combination of the New Deal and Great Society to get it all done. Edwards and Obama (at least to a certain extent) are campaigning on this decisive separation from the Bush era, but neither of them asks how they're going to get big popular majorities and various elites to support such an agenda let alone how they would administer programs and pay for them. It's all pie in the sky and here Walsh is being as naively idealistic as Bai himself.

But Walsh also seems to recognize the insanity of trying to do that much and soon pulls back into a minimalist mode.
But unlike Matt Bai, I think undoing the disasters of the Bush administration makes for good policy as well as good politics, and I think most Americans agree.
In other words, Walsh believes that an incoming Democratic administration is going to have to clean up a lot of the Bush administration's messes before it embarks on a any ambitious new plans. In my opinion, this is the right track. In fact, undoing the damage of the Bush administration is a pretty big ambition in itself. The Bush administration has made an enormous mess of the war in Iraq, international institutions like the UN and the World Bank, terrorist detention, interrogation policies, the Justice Department, federal agencies like FEMA, and the federal budget.

And that's just the well-known disasters. It may turn out that a big chunk of the federal government is as dysfunctional as FEMA.

Cleaning up the federal government and repairing our relationships with other countries is going to be a full time job for incoming Democrats. That's especially because a Democratic administration will be under a lot of pressure from the right-wing attack media. Unlike Obama and Edwards, Hillary seems to have a sense of how tough the environment is going to be for the next Democratic president. That sense of hard-headed practicality is one of the reasons I support her candidacy even though my own views are closer to those of Edwards.

But there's one thing for sure, the moderate Democratic--DLC--Lieberman era that Bai so much embraces really is over in the Democratic Party. In that sense, the liberal bloggers have won the war even if they continue to lose a lot of battles.

Monday, August 20, 2007

Drezner's Disappointing Attempt to Escape Dialogue

There's been a lot of back and forth over the last few days over blogger criticism of "the foreign policy community" between liberal bloggers Glenn Greenwald and Matthew Yglesias and foreign policy specialists Gideon Rose and Daniel Drezner. The liberal blogger or "netroots" critique of the foreign policy community or "establishment" is essentially the same as their critique of the mainstream media. According to Greenwald and Yglesias, the prominent foreign policy specialists who promoted the invasion of Iraq suffered no apparent consequences for their egregious misjudgments. In fact, the consensus of the foreign policy community still seems to be at least close to neo-conservative military adventurism. Likewise, it still appears that war opponents are frozen out of significant participation in foreign policy discussion. Despite the monumental nature of the Iraq disaster, nothing seems to have changed in the foreign policy community.

Greenwald and Yglesias are two of my favorite bloggers though and I think it fair to say that I'm biased toward them. However, I have to say that my main reaction to the controversy is disappointment in the writing of Drezner and Rose. They both work at foreign policy full-time and I believe they have more knowledge in the area than generalists like Greenwald and Yglesias. Yet, instead of using his expertise to further the discussion, the specialists set up a bunch of straw men and phony hypotheticals that seem designed to obfuscate rather than enlighten.

Let me give an example from Drezner's discussion of military intervention. Greenwald argues that "the U.S. should not attack another country unless that country has attacked or directly threatens our national security . . ." Greenwald's main weakness as a commentator is that he often engages in overly broad formulations like this and Drezner certainly could have contested this definition of legitimate attacks on other countries as too broad to be useful or in need of modification. Given Drezner's expertise in international affairs, he could have done so in a way that advanced the discussion of appropriate American conduct in a post/9-11 and post Iraq world. In other words, Dresner could have used his specialist knowledge to improve on Greenwald. But no dice. Instead, Drezner asks a set of rhetorical questions:

How does one define direct threats to national security? For the United States, would civil war in Saudi Arabia or Pakistan qualify? Should the use of force be categorically rejected in both cases? Does Iran's links to the Khobar Towers bombing justify the use of force against Teheran, as per Greenwald's criteria?
Ultimately, these questions are disingenuous, and perhaps dangerously so. By using the hypothetical examples of civil war in Saudi Arabia and Pakistan just to frame a rhetorical question about Greenwald's definition, Drezner implicitly claims that Greenwald's definition fails because Drezner can raise these kinds of questions. Instead of using his expertise to further discussion, Drezner apparently seeks to drive Greenwald back to a zero point where there is no limitation on the ability of the American government to attack other countries.

It didn't have to be this way. At a minimum, Drezner could have used his examples to articulate something like a concept of "indirect threat" to American national security as justifying attacks on other nations as a complicating factor. Such indirect threats certainly would not always justify attacks, but civil wars in Saudi Arabia or Pakistan "might" impinge enough on American national security to justify attacks in "certain circumstances" that shouldn't be discounted in advance. In such a case, one could justify an American military operation without aiming for the global domination envisioned by PNAC and the Bush doctrine.

In other words, Drezner could have defined a "prudent" rule of thumb that closed off military adventures like Iraq but didn't unnecessarily hamstring American policy-makers.

There's a danger in Drezner's giving Greenwald the back of his hand like this. While attempting to close down Greenwald's effort to define a limit to American attacks, Drezner is opening up the possibility that the U. S. has a right to attack any country any time we want as neo-cons like Ledeen, Bolton, and Robert Kagan (especially in Of Paradise and Power) argue. Without any principled limitations on the right of the American government to attack other countries, the question then becomes whether the U. S. has the military power to execute all the attacks that the warmongers can imagine. Given that the neo-cons believe we have potentially unlimited military power, that means we can attack practically any country (except Israel) at any time.

Drezner goes on to bait Greenwald in ways that refuse to take him seriously even though the article was entitled "Taking Glenn Greenwald Seriously." Ultimately, both Drezner confirms the blogger critique of the foreign policy community. They are determined to learn nothing from Iraq.

More than anything else, I find that disappointing.

The Bears in the Cage

Over the weekend, a drunken Serb was killed and partially eaten after he climbed into a bear cage at the Belgrade Zoo. Apparently, the victim had been throwing beer cans, bricks, stones, and even mobile phones at the bears. However, after he climbed into the cage to show who was really boss, he probably lived long enough to regret his mistake. The two bears, Masha and Misha, "dragged the body to their feeding corner," started eating him like any other piece of meat, "and reacted angrily when keepers tried to recover [the body]."

The Republicans are more wary than the drunken Serb these days, but they have to wonder if they are going to be dragged into a bear cage as they watch the sub-prime mortgage crisis. Right now, it's sub-prime mortgage companies and the Wall Street firms that invested in their mortgages that are being eaten.

Who cares about them?

However, if heavily indebted consumers are dragged into the cage with Wall Street, the economy will be looking at a recession on top of the unpopular wars in Iraq and Afghanistan, Katrina, the on-going health care crisis, and the various Alberto Gonzales scandals.

Given that all these other things have occurred on George Bush and the Republican Party's watch, the onset of a recession would mean that the Republicans would get eaten alive by voters.

Couldn't happen to nicer people.