Saturday, October 18, 2008

The Election Enters the "Archie Bell Phase"

Hi everybody! I'm not Archie Bell. I'm not the Drells and I don't have a new dance either.

And I could really stand a new dance right now.

That's because the 2008 presidential election is starting to remind me of the old Archie Bell and the Drells hit "Tighten Up."

Archie Bell didn't sing much on "Tighten Up." But he had very cool way of talking over the music.

"Tighten up on that bass now/ Tighten it up/ Ha, ha, yeah"

As late as Tuesday, the polls had Barack Obama ahead by 8 points with several polls showing 13 or 14 point leads. "Feeling Stronger Every Day" was my song and I was feeling it. I felt it even more on Wednesday when Barack Obama won the debate and my friend Matthew Kerbel from Villanova told me that he thought the election was in the bag for Obama.

But today, the TPM poll composite has Obama up by only 5.3 with a range from 2 (Gallup traditional) to 7 (Research 2000, IBD/TIPP, Hotline/FD).

As Archie would say, "Now let that guitar fall in/ Oh, yeah/ Tighten up on that organ now."

Actually, there's reason to expect the tightening to continue. The debates are over. McCain doesn't have any more chances to look like a bully, blink 100 miles an hour, pop out with his Uncle Fester eyes, or do that tongue thing. He won't have to worry about explaining his unpopular policies to sceptical audiences of swing voters either.

If McCain doesn't do anything stupid (a big "if"), he can look forward to another solid two weeks of sliming Obama.

Or as Republicans call it, "raising questions."

So, whether liberal bloggers like it or not (and I don't), "Tighten Up" might be the song for the really ugly part of this election.

"Come on and tighten up/ Let's tighten it up now/ Let's tighten it up now/ Tighten it up."

Sing it, baby. Actually, Mrs. RSI says I can't sing.

But neither could Archie Bell.

Friday, October 17, 2008

Palin: Macaca Moment Sans Macaca

One of the things that conservatives have been trying to do is to promote rural or small town life as a symbol of traditional America along with the military, the flag, and the Pledge.


Everybody knows the rural mythology. The myth of rural people is that they are more oriented toward family and religion, closer to the land, and more traditional. People who live in rural areas therefore represent something more honest, less corrupt, and less manipulative than the cities and suburbs. Rural people are also less subject to popular culture than people in cities and represent something that stands apart from, and superior to, the American norm.


This is a relatively small part of what Sarah Palin is referring to when she talks about small towns and rural areas as "the pro-American" part of America, or the "real America."

But here's the rub.


The right isn't attracted to the "ideal" rural America at all. Otherwise, they wouldn't be such big supporters of corporate agriculture against family farms and mountaintop removal against local property owners. If they valued rural life, conservatives wouldn't be so eager to waste the lives of the guys who join the military either.

Conservatives are more attracted to the underside of the rural life--the suspicion of outsiders, the almost palpable sense of cultural inferiority to the urban world, and the traditions of male predominance in households, white elites running the towns and counties, and evangelical religion as an adjunct of the local elites.

They also work overtime to cultivate the resentments that many in small towns and rural areas have for the "liberals" who have undermined the legitimacy of the traditional hierarchies.

And it's largely worked.

I grew up in small town upstate New York and now live in small town Eastern Kentucky. But I've also lived among liberal urban elites in Philly (the academic history circles around the University of Pennsylvania) and college towns like Chapel Hill and Ann Arbor. Urban elites have their weaknesses. My liberal/left friends tend to measure people by the quality of their work and self-control in their manners. They also have a warped view of the United States as a nation because they don't get out of the urban belts very much. But my urban friends are also curious about Kentucky and other rural areas and generally eager to find out more. They like all things exotic and count rural America as having a kind of "friendly strangeness" that they're interested in.

That's not so much the case with rural folks. In upstate New York and Eastern Kentucky, the resentment of urban culture is often very intense. An unhealthy percentage of rural self-identification is bound up in "sticking it" to the liberal opinion they associate with the urban world. That's one of the reasons (although not the only reason) why Confederate flags, nooses, and casual racism and misogyny are so pervasive in rural areas.

It's also one of the reasons why people in rural areas are so emphatic about patriotic symbols like the flag, the Star-Spangled Banner, and the military.

That's why being "pro-American" in Sarah Palin's sense is often a way to express hostility to the "outsider Americans" that rural people view as judging them.

Actually, it's too bad that cultural bitterness has such a hold over rural white areas.

My town of Morehead, KY is a college town in the Appalachian foothills where there's a healthy mix of rural people, people who've moved here from urban areas, and academic types like myself. Given the general poverty of Eastern Kentucky, there's not much here that's very stable. But the lack of stability is also a constant prod to the ingenuity of people around here and Morehead is thus a very creative place.

It's also very friendly.

From the Morehead perspective, it's easy to see a fruitful amalgamation between American urban and American rural, easy to imagine us all as living in one country.

But then the Sarah Palin's of the world get busy stirring up the bitterness to further their own ambitions.

And then you find that the same battles need to be fought over again.

Pre-Emptive Attacks on the Obama Administration

The Wall Street Journal's has started attacking the Obama administration well before the Nov. 4 election.

Today, it was Matthew Kaminski predicting that the David Axelrod approach to inspirational "hope" and "change" didn't work after Duval Patrick was elected in Massachusetts and wouldn't work if Barack Obama is elected president.

According to Kaminski, Patrick's "inspirational outsider" approach didn't work because Massachusetts Democrats didn't want to go along. They were also still holding a grudge over Patrick beating an insider in the primary.

But it isn't the same.

If Obama is elected, he's going to have a very Democratic Congressional leadership. He may have started with outsider rhetoric, but Obama was also a Democratic Party "golden boy" who landed a gig as the keynote speaker for the 2004 convention. The leadership might have thought that Obama was running four years too early, but they were also suffering from a long-standing case of "Clinton fatigue" and weren't looking forward to eight years of a Hillary presidency.

As a result, there hasn't been even a whisper of unhappiness with Obama's nomination from the Democratic Congressional leadership.

But the bottom line is that Barack Obama has added a foundation of good policy ideas to his "hope" and "change" themes. During his debates with John McCain, Obama looked like a steady, seasoned, and practical politician while McCain was playing an immature version of a maverick.

If Obama's elected president, he'll get a tough ride. But it will be because the country is going through tough times more than anything else.

Thursday, October 16, 2008

He's Got Uncle Fester Eyes


What John McCain reminded me most of last night was Uncle Fester on the Addams Family.

The problem was McCain's blinking.

McCain started the debate blinking more than a hundred times a minute. But at some point McCain seems to have realized or been informed that he was blinking like a maniac.

At that point, McCain started fighting so hard to keep his eyes open that it looked like he was in pain.

Here's a video of McCain's Uncle Fester eyes.

Wednesday, October 15, 2008

Greetings from the Socialist Republic of America

Maybe the Bush administration should consider changing the name of our country.

After all, it could be argued that the Bush people have fundamentally changed the relation between government and business in the United States by taking over the gigantic mortgage guaranteeing operations in Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, taking over the nation's biggest insurance company in IAG, and now partially nationalizing the eight biggest banks.

Perhaps we're not the United States of America in the same capitalist sense we used to be.

Personally, I kind of like the Socialist Republic of North America with it's nod toward our Hispanic heritage,

But Socialist Republic of America is shorter.

Maybe we should go with that instead

Looking at the Tuesday Polls

Well, it certainly looks good for Obama.

Yesterday, CBS/NYTimes came out with a poll that had Obama 52, McCain 39. That's the biggest Obama lead but could be even bigger than it looks if the 3 point margin of error is taken into account. Counting margin of error, the CBS poll ranges from Obama 55-36 to Obama 49-42.

What's interesting about the CBS poll is that it has McCain tracking down around the minimum Republican vote of 38% that was established by George H. W. Bush in the 1992 election where Ross Perot ran.

If the CBS poll is right, McCain is scraping the Republican bottom.

My own initial prediction was Obama 57, McCain 43 and the CBS poll is on track for that kind of landslide. GW/Battleground, ABC, and one of the Gallup estimates also have Obama out front by ten or more.

But I'm not going to be distracted by either self-interest or good news. At this point, I tend to agree with Nate Silver at FiveThirtyEight.com that CBS is likely a bit of an outlier and that Obama's actual lead is somewhere around 8%.

Assuming some margin of error here, I think Obama's lead ranges from 5 to 11 points.

If that's the case, the Obama campaign should continue doing pretty much what it's doing--performing well in tonight's debate, using its financial advantage to blanket battleground states with television ads, and gearing up its massive ground game,.

What Obama's doing is working. So the Obama people should keep doing it.

What about the McCain campaign? The McCain campaign should assume that McCain's only down by 5 and that he needs to shave that lead down to 2 over the next two weeks.

If they can get a strong debate performance from the candidate, the McCain campaign could run a two level campaign and it looks like they've already started.

At the top and visible level, the McCain people could run a "nice" campaign in which they have McCain and his lead surrogates (Joe Lieberman, Carly Fiorina, Lindsey Graham) emphasize McCain's sacrifices, experience, and general orientation toward low taxes and a strong military.

Such a Republican brand campaign has a lower value than it used to, but still might be good for a couple of points.

At the gutter level, the McCain people can count on Rush Limbaugh, Sean Hannity, and the rest of the conservative media to engage in racist fear-mongering. Limbaugh came out with a racist rant just yesterday while Stanley Kurtz of NRO did his best to create another bridge from Obama to Jeremiah Wright.

It's ugly bigoted stuff, but it's not like Republicans haven't done it before.

It's still plausible that the combination of nice conservativism and gutter conservatism could move the poll numbers a modest 5% over the next three weeks and give McCain a squeaker win.

But I don't think the McCain people will be able to turn the tide. To boil it all down, nominating Sarah Palin poisoned the water for a traditional Republican campaign.

At this point, I'd say it's most likely that Obama's going to win.

And he deserves it.

Tuesday, October 14, 2008

The Worst Thing About the Sarah Palin Blunder

The French diplomat Talleyrand was famous for pooh poohing ethics in relation to Napoleon by claiming that one of the emperor's decision was "worse than a crime, it's a blunder."

Today, recovering Republican strategist Matthew Dowd argues that John McCain's nomination of Sarah Palin was mostly a crime of putting politics before country:
Dowd proclaimed that, in his heart of hearts, McCain knew he put the country at risk with his VP choice and that he would "have to live" with that fact for the rest of his career.

Of course, nominating Sarah Palin to be vice-president would be a crime if McCain won. Given the report on the Troopergate scandal in Alaska, it looks less and less like Palin is fit to be the governor of a small state let alone have any national responsibility.

The Palin nomination is also a crime against the Republican Party's future. Palin is a singularly reckless and partisan right-winger whose showmanship makes her a strong contender for the Republican presidential nomination in 2012 (whether McCain wins or loses). But Sarah-mania is also a trap. As long as she's involved in national politics, Palin will be a very attractive figure for conservatives. Palin is also highly unpopular with non-conservatives that she could never win a national election. As a result, any Palin candidacy would tend to keep conservatives trapped in an ideological ghetto of their own.

But nominating Sarah Palin was also a blunder. And it was a blunder for several reasons.

First, the Palin hurt McCain because it put him on the defensive. The problem emerged even when McCain was ahead of Obama and Palin was enjoying popularity. Because Palin lacked much experience beyond Wasilla, Alaska, the McCain campaign first had to answer a wave of questions about her lack of experience. Then, there were succeeding waves of questions, first about her knowledge from the Gibson and Couric interviews and then her abuse of power in the Troopergate investigation.

The McCain campaign was on the offenseive during June and July with their attacks on Obama's celebrity status. But they've been playing defense ever since the Palin nomination.

Second, the Palin nomination cemented the idea that John McCain was running a gimmicky presidential campaign. Of course, McCain had already pulled lots of gimmicks ranging from his poverty tour of Appalachia, the challenge for Obama to travel with him to Iraq, the follow-up challenge to Iraq to do ten townhall meetings, and the nasty, race-baiting "Celeb" ads.

But when John McCain tabbed Sarah Palin as his "stunt nomination," he set himself up for the "gimmicky candidate" narrative that bit him during the financial meltdown. The Wall Street crisis would have played against McCain as a Republican in any case. It played much worse against him because all of his manuevers have been seen as "gimmicks" and McCain was seen as a "gimmicky" candidate in a time of crisis. The idea of McCain as a gimmicky kind of guy began to take hold in the discussion over the Palin nomination and has been one of the cancers on his campaign ever since.

Good Idea from Pat Buchanan

Who says conservatives don't have good ideas. Here's a good idea from Pat Buchanan. Liquidate our empire.

Obama Surging in the States

Obama's surge in last week's national polls is being reflected in this week's state polls. The latest state polls cited at TPM have Obama "up 52%-43% in Colorado, 54%-38% in Michigan, 51%-40% in Minnesota, and 54%-37% in Wisconsin."

There's still very plausible scenarios by which McCain could stabilize his campaign and squeak out a win. What he would have to do is recapture Florida and Virginia and then pretty much run the toss-up states.

But Obama is looking strong right now.

Saturday, October 11, 2008

Was Obama on the Grassy Knoll?

Thank God for American conservatives. True, they haven't gotten to the truth about Barack Obama quite yet. But they're well on their way.

In a very insightful column for the National Review Online, the singularly talented conservative journalist Andrew McCarthy reflects on whether former Weatherman Bill Ayres wrote Barack Obama's memoir of growing up as a black man.


I've finally read Jack Cashill's lengthy analysis in The American Thinker. It is thorough, thoughtful, and alarming — particularly his deconstruction of the text in Obama's memoir and comparison to the themes, sophistication and signature phraseology of Bill Ayers' memoir.
Or was Barack Obama the evil mastermind who wrote William Ayres' memoir instead? Intrepid minds like McCarthy want to know.

Journalists from the National Review Online go even farther. Mark Hemingway has an article today on how Barack Obama endorsed loans from his Chicago friends to Myrtle Beach mob interests.

From all indications, Obama's mob associates are "made" Mafia men, maybe even the Sopranos themselves (bias alert--I'm related to the Sopranos of Waverly, NY). Indications are that Obama is consolidating all the world's mafias under his control before he's elected president. That way Obama will be able to use the FBI to protect his organized crime interests.

But none of these authors captures the whole truth about Barack Obama.

For that, we have to return the the Grassy Knoll in Dallas, the grassy knoll from which John F. Kennedy was really assassinated in 1963.

Newly discovered pictures from Fox News indicate beyond any doubt that Barack Obama was present on the grassy knoll when Kennedy was shot.

And that he had a gun.

Forget Lee Harvey Oswald. Barack Obama really killed John F. Kennedy.

Squeamish liberals might object that Barack Obama was only two when Kennedy was assassinated.

And that Obama was living in Hawaii at the time.

What moral cowards! Obama was not only two years old. In fact, he was two years and three months at the time of the assassination.

And that makes all the difference.

Children who are 27 months old are perfectly capable of traveling by themselves and have been known to easily handle handguns and rifles like the Italian carbine that shot Kennedy. In fact, our vice-presidential candidate Sarah Palin had all her children proficiently handling moose-guns when they were only eighteen months.

Given Barack Obama's superior intelligence, he would have had no problem bringing his carbine from Hawaii to Dallas and taking aim at one of America's greatest presidents.

Barack Obama--plagiarist, mafia kingpin, and the real killer of our beloved president.

Bank on it.

***Note. My younger sister did indeed marry into the Soprano family. Her son "Vinnie" has moved to Myrtle Beach to further the family's interests there.****

I Never Would Have Guessed This

Sarah Palin got booed, loudly booed, when she dropped the ceremonial first puck for the Flyers opening game against the Rangers tonight.

Who would have thought that?

Philadelphia routinely turns out 250,000 vote margins for Democratic candidates. Philadelphia sports fans are legendary for booing Santa Claus. No one in their right mind would have guessed that Philly fans would boo an unpopular Republican vice-presidential candidate like Palin.

To top it off, Palin had two daughters with her to share the misery--seven-year old daughter Piper and pregnant Bristol.

Something tells me Piper and Bristol Palin won't be writing books about what a great mom Sarah Palin was.

Friday, October 10, 2008

The Nails in John's Coffin

Talk about nails in John McCain's coffin. McCain had to stifle his pent-up crowd before the nastiness of his supporters guaranteed a landslide for Obama. Likewise, Sarah Palin was found to have "abused her power" while pursuing a personal vendetta and the DOW was down another hundred points.

Now there's going to be a few days of discussion about McCain's crowds and Sarah Palin's abuse of power. Then there's the final debate which shapes up as a likely win for Obama. Finally, if anybody thinks the stock market is going to disappear from public attention anytime soon, they're crazy. The middle-class people I saw today were talking about losing $25,000 out of their parents or their own retirement or seeing their inheritance disappear.

Nobody's going to forget that kind of thing very soon.

It's not like I'm ready to say McCain's doomed, but it's getting close to the point where one can say that racism is the only chance he has to win.

Avoiding the Very Worst

If you're feeling suicidal over the current financial meltdown, please do not watch President Bush's Rose Garden talk on the economy today.

It might push you over the edge.

How to Talk to a Weatherman

Now that William Ayres is all over the news, my own experience of socializing with a former member of the Weather Underground might be mildly relevant again.

Mrs. RSI and I have been long-time friends with the sister of Kathy Wilkerson who was a fairly well-known member of the Weather Underground, involved in at least one bombing, etc. Every once in a while, we socialize with Wilkerson when she comes out to Kentucky. Last summer, we saw her when she was visiting for her niece's wedding reception.

I can't say that I know much about Wilkerson's Weatherman days. It's never come up. Like most middle-class people, most of her conversation centers around kids. Wilkerson has a daughter who was in graduate school the last time I saw her. I've got two daughters. We talk daughters.

Wilkerson recently published a somewhat remorseful memoir of the 60's entitled Flying Too Close to the Sun. It's supposed to be a very good book.

But I wouldn't have known she was a "60's radical" from talking with her.

Thursday, October 09, 2008

Another Trillion Down the Drain--Maybe Two

The Dow Jones lost 679 points today to close at 8600. But I remember the glory days of the Clinton administration when there were predictions of Dow 36,000 in the air. I feel a nostalgic little tingle just thinking about that number--Dow 36,000.

Speaking of nostalgia, here's some lyrics from Mary Hopkins' "Those were the Days."

Those Were the Days
Those were the days, my friend
We thought they'd never end
We'd sing and dance forever and a day
We'd live the life we'd choose
We'd fight and never lose
For we were young and sure to have our way

La La La La La La
La La La La La La
La La La La La La La La La La

Or something like that.

John McCain and the Jimmy Carter Model

There's been a fair amount of discussion about McCain's proposals on health insurance and social security as if they were serious proposals that could be enacted into law if McCain became president.

In fact, they're not.

The Bush administration could not get a social security privatization bill to the floor in Congress even when the Republicans had majorities in both the House and the Senate.

Why would anyone think McCain is going to get his proposals to tax health care benefits and privatize social security passed by large Democratic majorities?

Any bills like that would be long, long dead before they arrived.

That leads to the larger truth of any McCain presidency. McCain would be a Jimmy Carter-type of impotent, ineffective president.

Of course, McCain himself isn't stupid or incompetent any more than Carter was. But McCain is like Carter in that he has no political constituency. McCain inspires no loyalty among Republican members of the House and Senate who have hated his "maverick" ways for years. In fact, a lot of them think he's a phony and a jerk to boot. The Democrats don't respect him any more either. Whatever affection people on the left used to have for McCain the maverick dried up as soon as he started running his race-baiting "Celeb" ads.

If McCain was elected president, he would have no political capital, no reservoir of personal loyalty among political elites, and no base of popular support. That's right--no base of popular support. If anything has become clear over the last five weeks, it's that the Republican base strongly prefers Sarah Palin to McCain.

That was the formula for Jimmy Carter's failed presidency and John McCain would be no different.

Tuesday, October 07, 2008

Debate No. 2: John McCain's Own Personal Rock Opera

"Even at My Favorite Table, He Can Beat My Best." That line from the Who rock opera Tommy pretty much sums up the presidential debate tonight. Townhall forums are McCain's favorite venue and Barack Obama still beat him. Obama had more convincing arguments, was more comfortable in the environment, and more in command of himself. That's not to say that McCain was bad. He got out his arguments, repeated his criticisms, and kept his contempt for Obama under control. But Obama still did better a better job and that fact is reflected in the snap polls where the CNN instapoll had Obama winning 54-30 and a CBS poll of uncommitted voters had Obama up 39-27 with 35% seeing it as a tie.

If McCain needed a bump from this debate, he didn't get it.

The Place for "Nice" Aggression. That raises a point. Did McCain need a bump from last night's debate? Given the uncertainties caused by the "Bradley Effect" on polling in relation to African-American candidates, there are plausible scenarios in which John McCain can be seen as either slightly ahead or more or less even. Perhaps McCain himself believes those scenarios because he certainly didn't act like he absolutely needed to score a decisive win. John McCain was not nearly as aggressive in tonight's debate as he was in the first presidential debate. McCain demeaned Obama as naive or uninformed once, used the "L" word once, and worried about government mandates once. My friends (as McCain would say), that doesn't add up to a lot of aggression. In fact, one could say that Obama was just as aggressive as McCain because Obama kept insisting on using more time than he was allotted to explain his positions or respond to McCain. Obama was "nice" about it, but he also clearly showed that he was a leader, exercising a kind of "nice" leadership that "undecided" voters like but many Republicans have a hard time understanding let alone matching.

The Problem with Hot Hand Luke. One of McCain's worst moments during the debate was when he said that America needed a "cool hand at the tiller." That's because McCain was playing into Obama's obvious strength and his own weaknesses. Barack Obama projects so much unflappable cool that many Democrats were worried that he was being passive and wanted him if he would project himself more forcefully. But Obama started adding more force and passion to his speeches and that's part of the reason why his acceptance speech was so good--and so reassuring. McCain used to have a self-mocking, cynical, fighter pilot coolness about him as well. But that's pretty much disappeared under the pressure of a difficult campaign. He's stopped talking informally with reporters on the "No Talk Express" and stopped teasing himself about his weaknesses. No longer projecting fighter jock cool, McCain has become the "Hot Hand Luke" who pulls political stunts like suspend his campaign and call for delaying the first debate but then do nothing fruitful in relation to the bailout package and back down from his threat not to show up. If McCain was running against someone other than Obama, this wouldn't have been so much of a problem. But McCain's relative hotheadedness accentuated the obvious fact that Obama would be a very "cool hand at the tiller."

The Bottom Line. Actually, I suspect that John McCain would be losing these debates even if he were as good a debater as Sarah Palin or Joe Biden. That's because McCain is dragging several balls and chains as he debates. There's the connection to the Bush administration that McCain can't shake off because he's a Republican. There's also the highly unpopular Iraq War. McCain was dragging around even more weight on domestic policy. He wants to cut corporate income taxes at a time when everybody wants to punish corporate CEO's. McCain also plans to introduce medical savings accounts in a way that would take people out of health insurance, "reform" social security by reducing benefits, and ramp up on nuclear power. It would take a magician to make these policies sound the least bit palatable in the current climate.

The bottom line is that John McCain is not that magician.

Live Blogging Debate 2

It's only ten minutes since I finished my preview. Do I have what it takes for ninety minutes of live-blogging?

9:03, Here are the candidates. I hope the hell this debate is better than the first one. First question to Obama on global economic conditions.

What's the fastest, most positive solution to the problems of older people in the economy? Please, Obama, please--do not lay out your principles first. Just get to the solutions.

Obama begins with some criticism of the Bush economy, but he is doing pretty good. First, there's the rescue package, then a "middle-class rescue package" before he dribbles on about long-term solutions.

Not that great.

Now, it's McCain's turn. His solution is energy independence, lower taxes, and stopping "the spending spree."

In other words, McCain is totally avoiding the question.

Ah, the first surprise of the evening. McCain proposes to buy up all the bad mortgages as a way to "stabilize home values."

McCain takes his second stab at being funny when he says he's not appointing Tom Brokaw as Secretary of Treasury.

It doesn't work. I'm not sensing much sense of humor out there.

Obama wants a treasury secretary who doesn't believe in the "trickle down" theory of economics. McCain named some names. Obama does not.

Oliver Clark wants to know how the bailout package is going to help. I don't think there's going to be a lot of baiting and denunciations tonight. Everything is really somber.

Ooops. I'm wrong there. McCain segwes to to Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac as an example of "cronyism," "greed and excess." I don't know. It will be interesting to see if this is going to work. The idea of buying up housing loans doesn't seem like it's going to work.

Obama's turn. At least, he starts dealing with reality. Two points to Obama for realism. Obama is pretty good on deregulation, better than McCain on Fannie Mae. At least I think he's better.

9: 16, Brokaw asks if things are going to get worse before they get better. I think they're going to get worse, but Obama punts like any good politician would punt. McCain punts too and says "it depends."

Once again, this is a pretty dreary, evasive debate. I'm not impressed. Does TPM think they're on they're "A" game again.

9:18, Question of "both parties" getting us into this global economic crisis. Obama accepts that there is a lot of blame to go around. Obama claims that the Bush administration should get most of the blame even though nobody is innocent. Now he goes onto investments and spending cuts.

9:20, What the hell is McCain doing. He's moving around in the most artificial, Penguin-like way? Where's Danny Devito when we need him?

9:22, McCain points to Obama as the "most consistent big-spending liberal" in the Senate. McCain gets into the pork-barrel thing again. It looks like McCain is taking the kind of "medium aggressive" strategy that I thought would be most likely.

Actually, McCain scored a couple of points on pork despite his Penguin imitation. Maybe the Penguin made the whol manuever a negative.

9:24, McCain begins a response on the big problems with "entitlement reform" and tells people they won't be able to get the same Social Security benefits that they've been getting. That doesn't sound like good news.

McCain--"Gutting social security, building nuclear power plants, and bad health care."

Obama starts with energy independence and sounds pretty nice. Then, he moves to health care and education. Pretty good. Obama's pretty good on these issues. He's sounding presidential and McCain is sounding pretty cranky.

9:28, McCain wants to eliminate programs and agencies and he mentions defense contracting and Boeing. Well, Boeing is in Seattle and Chicago. McCain wasn't going to win Wash State and Illinois anyway.

9:29, McCain mentions an across the board spending freeze.

9:30, McCain throws a big health care softball to Obama. Obama has an interesting response in that he moves to 9-11. This is Obama at his best because he's convincing when he's talking about personal responsibility. When McCain talks about personal responsibility, I think about him dumping his first wife. Now, Obama's giving a testimony to young people. This is all very nice.

9:33, EVERYBODY GOT REAL STONED--Is everybody drunk like Wall Street. Obama wants to begin ith Washington, talks about "sharing the burden" and uses teachers as an example, and is pretty convincing while doing it. This is the kind of moment where I'm proud to carry Obama's water.

9:35, Now McCain is accusing Obama of ruining small business and he's trying to sell his awful health care proposal.

9:37, Questions about "huge unfunded federal mandates" and Brokaw piles on with social security and medicare.

Obama's stab at humor doesn't work either.

Obama insists on replying to McCain on tax policy. They're going to fight it out here. Obama is pretty strong here and sounds presidential.

9:41, McCain claims that fixing Social Security isn't that tough. Right! McCain then proposes a "Medicare Commission." Now McCain goes back to taxes and claims that he has a better record.

9:42, Question from Ingrid Jackson who wants to know what McCain would do about climate change and green jobs within two years. McCain talks about his efforts on greenhouse emissions. McCain thinks that nuclear power is "safe and clean." I'm sorry. I just don't see "Chernobyl Power" as a green technology.

9:45, The people in the audience look pretty skeptical about Obama. Are they just as suspicious of McCain? Or are they just weirded out by being on camera?

9:46, Obama nails McCain for voting against alternative energy sources.

9:47, Brokaw complains about candidates not obeying the rules of the debate. They don't care.

9:48, McCain looks like he's ready to break out his horrible Joker smile. Don't do it John!!!

9:49, Now there's a question from Lindsey Trulla on health care. Obama's up and is explaining his health care proposal. It looks like this debate is working out for Obama because it's basically a wash. Obama's doing well on health care by explaining both his proposals and McCain's really awful health proposal.

9:52, McCain tries to be personal but he starts moving around Penguin style again. Why is he doing this? Now, McCain moves onto criticizing the mandatory dimensions of Obama's health care proposals. This isn't working. McCain is giving a $5,000 tax credit for what adds up to a $12000 insurance expense.

McCain's leery of government mandates.

Obama defends his mandates.

9:59, Moving onto foreign policy--One guy asks about the ability of the U. S. to be a peacemaker. McCain talks about military strength. McCain doesn't sound very convincing talking about keeping the peace. That's because he believes in military action first.

10:01, McCain stands on his judgment. Obama is going to have a strong comeback on Iraq.

10:02, And Obama has a strong, reasoned response on Iraq. I'm beginning to be impressed with Obama. McCain is doing well, but I think Obama's doing better.

10:03, Brokaw asks about the Obama and McCain doctrines on intervening in humanitarian crises. Obama is against standing idly by in the face of genocide and ethnic cleansing but acknowledges the limitations of our resources. Obama emphasizes alliances in dealing with humanitarian crises.

10:06, McCain bores into Obama on withdrawal deadlines for Iraq. He emphasizes that the situation requires a "cool hand at the tiller." But McCain is not a cool hand and he demonstrates it with his contempt for Obama on Iraq.

10:07, tie on intervention goes to Obama.

10:08, Katie Ann has a question about Pakistani sovereignty and hot pursuit across Pakistani borders. Obama responds with a strong statement on the problem with the threats in Afghanistan and Pakistan. Obama is for intervention if we can kill bin Laden. McCain responds with need for confidentiality on attacking Pakistan. McCain goes to his hole card in the reference to Petraeus. "Talk softly, carry a big stick."

Obama is pretty much ignoring the rules of engagement.

10:15, Brokaw asks about Afghanistan. I think Obama's showing leadership on Afghanistan. He was strong on Afghanistan during the last debate as well. McCain's waving around "General Petraeus" like a kind of magic wand. Is Petraeus more like holly and Phoenix feather or walnut and unicorn hair. I go with unicorn hair.

10:19, This debate is wearing me down because it's not that good. Now, they're talking about Russia. McCain is criticizing Putin. Does Putin want to "reassemble the old Soviet Union?" McCain talks about international pressure on Russia.

10:22, Students are starting to leave. I don't remember students leaving the Biden/Palin debate. There were 60 students here altogether.

10:23, Obama is doing well in the townhall format. If Obama had done all ten towhalls that McCain wanted, he would have a bigger lead.

10:24. Question from Terry Shirey on Iran attacking Israel--like Iran with its 6 billion defense budget would actually attack Israel with its 10 billion/year in American aid.

Give me a break. Iran isn't a threat at all. McCain responds with his comic book concept of a League of Democracies.

10:27, Obama is against nuclear weapons for Iran and has a long answer on Iranian nukes. Obama's in four-corner mode as he strings out the debate.

10:29, The Last Question from Peggy in New Hampshire about "what don't you know and how will learn it." Obama has a nice response about passing on the American Dream to the next generation.

10:32, McCain moves forward to reply. I don't think McCain understands is that the quesgtion is about whether he's willing to keep learning.

McCain gives one too many testimonies to the wonderfulness of America. As a result, my daughter collapses into an exhausted heap.

I thought Obama won. Hopefully, that won't jinx him

The Second Presidential Debate--Preview

The Lay of the Land. Contrary to most media and pundit opinion, the facts of the political terrain going into the second presidential debate are neither knowable nor simple. What's least known is the issue that most needs to be known--where public opinion stands four weeks from the presidential election. Many of the tracking polls (Rasmussen, Gallup, GW, Research 2000), Obama has a 7-8 point lead. But other polls (Zogby, Hotline, CBS, Democracy Corps) only have Obama up by 2-3. Given a 2-3% margin of error, the latter group of polls could be read as portraying the election as tied. Rassmussen and Gallup are generally the most respected of the polling operations, However, there's a big five to nine point polling discrepancy and there's no principle that would allow one to tell which poll is right and by how much.


That's the known discrepancy. What's unknown is the impact of the "Bradley Effect" where white voters tell pollsters they're going to vote for a black candidate in order to not appear racist and then vote for the white candidate. As a result, African-American candidates like Barack Obama can find that the polls overestimate their vote by as many as 10%. In the 2008 election season, Obama has found that some polls (Iowa, North Carolina, etc) accurately capture his vote, but has seen other states (for example, New Hampshire) where polls have over-estimated his appeal along the lines indicated by the Bradley Effect.


To what extent is the current polling over-estimating Obama's vote as a result of the Bradley Effect?


Nobody knows.


However, the other major unknown--the impact of Barack Obama's voter registration efforts and turnout drives--cuts in favor of Obama's candidacy. States like Pennsylvania and Colorado report huge increases in the number of people registered as Democrats. But the question is what percentage of those newly registered voters (and young voters) are going to show up and vote on election day. The Obama campaign believes that "new voters" are going to make a big difference and believes that it has evidence from their own canvassing to back up their convictions. But the public opinion polls don't have any reliable way to pick up that impact and thus the final impact of Obama's registration efforts has to be considered unknown at this time.

What Does This All Mean for the Debate? The conventional wisdom is that McCain is in a difficult box because of Obama's recent rise in the polls from 3% behind to 7-8% ahead. The idea is that McCain would like to "take the gloves off" but that going on the offensive runs the risk stimulating a backlash among undecided voters who don't like aggressive partisanship. The conundrum is heightened by the fact that conservative commentators and voters are eager to see McCain attack at the same time that the debate is being held as a townhall meeting with an audience of undecided voters who generally don't like partisanship.

But a lot of McCain's strategy would depend on whether he thinks he's ahead because of the Bradley Effect, closer than the polls indicate because of the Bradley Effect, or behind because he isn't considering the Bradley Effect.

McCain could quite plausibly think he's ahead if he takes the polls showing Obama with a 2-3 point lead as the most accurate and estimates that the Bradley Effect would give him another 5-6 points. That gives McCain a 2-3 point lead in which case McCain could very well take a disciplined, moderate approach to tonight's debate in which he lays out his case but avoids things like calling Obama "naive" that raised McCain's own negatives after the first debate. In this scenario, McCain would be patterning himself after Joe Biden's disciplined but forceful performance in his debate with Sarah Palin.

Who knew that Joe Biden would grow into a campaign role model?

Oops. I'm running out of time. If McCain estimates that the Bradley Effect makes the race closer than the polls indicate but still leaves him behind, I think he would hue to the traditional Republican line of attacking Obama as a liberal, claiming that Obama is out of touch with the "real America," and perhaps using Obama's associations with William Ayres and Jeremiah Wright to emphasize Obama's cultural marginality.

Such a strategy could have the effect of making a traditionally effective Republican appeal to swing voters while also reminding undecided voters that Obama is black and reinforcing the Bradley Effect.

That's what seems most likely to me.

If McCain assumes that he's really 7-8 points behind, he's in just as much a box as the media says. In that case, McCain's best approach would be to unveil some sort of big policy surprise, push Obama really hard on liberal vs conservative oppositions, get in a lot of zingers about Obama's "questionable associations," and hope that Obama falls apart.

The Obama campaign believes Obama is well ahead and thinks Obama could win in a landslide. But I wonder if the Obama strategy will be for Obama to push hard against McCain's association with the Bush administration and lobbyists as a way to show how tough, determined,. and presidential Obama is. That would allow them to make their argument to undecided voters in case the Bradley Effect is indeed making the election closer than it appears.

Given the uncertainties over the state of the election, the McCain and Obama campaigns could reasonably adopt any number of strategies. It will be interesting to see what they actually do.

Sunday, October 05, 2008

Is America Ready to Be Skunked?

This morning was an extremely bad morning at the Caric household. We got skunked. While following my wife to the car at 5:30am, our blue heeler mix made a quick move and got a skunk in its mouth. Now we're all paying the price. The smell is awful and it permeates the whole yard and house. My wife had to drive to Lexington to take an exam for her master's program. Good luck to the students sitting next to her. I'm not any better. I'll be taking my second shower after I give the poor dog another peroxide bath.

She might be getting three altogether.

But that's okay because it looks like the Caric family is going to be a symbol for the whole country--even Alaska. That's because the whole country is going to be skunked during the last month of the presidential campaign.

The McCain campaign started skunking up the political scene by sending out Sarah Palin to talk about how Barack Obama has been "palling around with terrorists." The terrorist reference is to William Ayres, the ex-Weatherman and current education professor who served as co-chair with Obama on an education project and hosted an Obama event in the nineties. According to the NY Times, Obama was never close to Ayres but Palin made it sound like they were buddies. Assuming her full attack dog demeanor, Palin added this little nugget that the Associated Press called "racially tinged."
"This is not a man who sees America like you and I see America," she said. "We see America as a force of good in this world. We see an America of exceptionalism."

It's a classic Republican race-baiting manuever. Palin is directly but vaguely claiming that Obama sees the world differently from other Americans. But she's indirectly alluding to the idea that Obama is different from other Americans and that he's different because he's black. The beauty of this kind of rhetorical manuever is that Palin can make a reference that's well-known to be racial but also plausibly deny that her remarks have a racial connotation.

Of course, attacking Obama's association with William Ayres is just the warm-up act for all the nastiness about the Rev. Jeremiah Wright that the McCain camp will be delivering sooner or later.

But the Obama camp is going to do some skunking of its own. As soon as Palin made her William Ayres comments, the Obama campaign got to work on an ad linking McCain to the Keating Five scandal of the 1980's. Material on McCain's links to Watergate felon G. Gordon Liddy and radical right, racist organizations is on the horizon as are questions about Sarah Palin's involvement with an Alaska separatist party.

McCain's trying to bounce back in the polls by dishing the dirt and Obama isn't going to take it lying down.

We're all about to be skunked.

And I don't think a peroxide bath is going to get rid of the smell.

Well, time to check on my dog.